I voted on the second option. I don't find that I have to have more extreme things to get off. I do, however, find that I am more open minded to the extreme and willing to try practically everything, except perhaps poop.
I can deal with Golden showers giving or receiving if my partner was interested, but the poop things is just too much for me.
I'd love blood play, piercing, knives, needles, electro-stimulation, I might even try enema's at some point. I don't have to have them, I am just as happy with whips and floggers or paddles and canes.