For the guys - Do you prefer a realistic dildo or non realistic dildo while getting pegged?

Contributor: - Kira - - Kira -
I'm answering for my husband. When we started he only wanted the non-realistic dildos. About three dildos in he decided he didn't care anymore and just wanted whatever was going to feel the best. His initial hang up was that he didn't want anything that looked like a real dick coming at him. I guess because he thought this would somehow make him feel gay about the whole thing. Once he got it in his mind that pegging didn't make him gay, the look of the dildo no longer mattered. In fact, his favorite dildo happens to be a realistic one based on how it feels.
01/17/2012
Contributor: Juicy Juicy
I prefer non-realistic dildos - they are just "better looking", colorful etc. My girlfriend also prefers them. I guess a purple dildo can be more easily associated with "fun" and is less serious, which is especially important at the beginning. However, now when we want to try some gender-play we use more realistic one - with balls, veins and that can cum!
01/19/2012
Contributor: Boobs and Lubes Boobs and Lubes
as long as it's not painful, who cares. I never see it...it's in my ass.lol
02/08/2012
Contributor: Eliyahu Eliyahu
The closest to realistic I like would be my wife's Feeldoe...
02/08/2012
Contributor: Bebela Bebela
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
When I started I was definitely in the non-realistic camp. Abstract and colorful just made it more comfortable.

Now it doesn't bother me as much either way. Because a non-realistic dildo isn't limited to a certain shape my opinion is ... more
If you want large semi-realism and awesome texture go for the Tantus O2 Revolution. It has dual-consistency (harder inside for support and softer/fleshy outside) with a very large, soft head.

I'm starting to get my bf into it because I can tell he wanted something a bit bigger than the O2 Niagara. He definitely loves it so go try it out!
02/10/2012
Contributor: MR Chickhabit MR Chickhabit
Quote:
Originally posted by Bebela
If you want large semi-realism and awesome texture go for the Tantus O2 Revolution. It has dual-consistency (harder inside for support and softer/fleshy outside) with a very large, soft head.

I'm starting to get my bf into it because I ... more
have you tried vixskin?

I LOOOOVE vixskin with all my heart but, ive not tried O2.

But I wanna.
02/10/2012
Contributor: Bottom Boy Bottom Boy
Quote:
Originally posted by Boobs and Lubes
as long as it's not painful, who cares. I never see it...it's in my ass.lol
My lady and I are wild about her wearing a replica taken from a real porn star. We've even made videos of her fucking me in the ass with one, and love watching them together.
03/02/2012
Contributor: LinToxic LinToxic
I like non-realistic, only because some of the non-realistic ones have uunique shapes like bulbs or ridges
03/02/2012
Contributor: John E W John E W
I don't think it would matter on which one it was.
03/02/2012
Contributor: Stark Stark
I see no real need for it to be realistic, it's just another great fun toy, it shouldn't have to resemble a penis, saying that if it's the perfect feel who cares!
03/11/2012
Contributor: you know you know
It didn't really bother me one way or another. As long as it is from her I do not care. Visually I wanted colorful to really draw attention. That said my gf expressed wanting a non realistic colorful one.
04/04/2012
Contributor: mlmac mlmac
Never been pegged before, but if one day a miracle happens and the opportunity comes about, I would prefer a non realistic dildo, but then again, I'll take what I can get.
04/04/2012
Contributor: HusbandandWife HusbandandWife
Quote:
Originally posted by stlouisxxx
In the private voting, I am wondering if the guys who are getting pegged would rather have their woman wear a realistic dildo, or have a non penis looking dildo in their harness, or if they don't care.
I prefer the realistic look, but it has more to do with the feel during the act. With non realistic you have a much larger selection of textures.
07/11/2012
Contributor: Love&War Love&War
I'm interested to see what the women have to say for their preference.
07/11/2012
Contributor: pestilence pestilence
I don't mind a real cock up my ass, but a dildo isn't a real cock and I prefer when it doesn't pretend to be one.
07/20/2012
Contributor: JackNit JackNit
The realistic ones look really good but the non realistic ones look like they might feel better so I don't really have a preference.
07/24/2012
Contributor: Ganconagh Ganconagh
Quote:
Originally posted by stlouisxxx
I for one would rather have a non penis looking dildo in her harness that would be aimed at pegging me. I'm not sure if I could logically justify the reason behind it, but I am more comfortable with a colorful silicone extension that doesn't ... more
We have used both. I don"t really have a preference as to looks. Do prefer the cyberskin/ur3 material types, though.
07/24/2012
Contributor: Missmarc Missmarc
Quote:
Originally posted by stlouisxxx
In the private voting, I am wondering if the guys who are getting pegged would rather have their woman wear a realistic dildo, or have a non penis looking dildo in their harness, or if they don't care.
Realistic, but no hair would be great.
07/24/2012
Contributor: DashO'Roark DashO'Roark
I don't really care but I do prefer something with a high degree of texture.
08/06/2012
Contributor: Life's Little Secrets Life's Little Secrets
I would prefer a realistic looking dildo (when we do start pegging), I don't know why but I have always wanted to feel what it was like being with a guy, without actually having to be with a guy. So for me the more realistic looking the better.
08/09/2012
Contributor: Kat and Aaron(aaron) Kat and Aaron(aaron)
It really depends on the mood. Realistic really turns her on which makes it so much better.
09/27/2012
Contributor: playsalot playsalot
It does not matter to me if it is realistic or not. The size and shape are more important. The two that we have for the strapon right now are realistic the next one probably will be purple.
10/03/2012
Contributor: AmethystSmoke AmethystSmoke
I answered for my husband - he doesn't care what it looks like, it just has to feel good.

We don't own a large number of dildos and two of them (three if you count vibrating ones) are non-realistic. The dildos were purchased for me and I chose the material first (silicone) then did my homework before buying my first VixSkin. I LOVE the feel of VixSkin!

So, by default, my husbands choices are pretty limited but it turns out he really likes the feel of VixSkins, too. He says they're much more comfortable than the O2 Cush.
10/03/2012
Contributor: MrWill MrWill
I vote no preference, but if takes a realistic dildo to have some sensation (I DO NOT like toys that are perfectly smooth with no texture/bumps) then I would prefer a veiny thing.
11/21/2012
Contributor: hanjonatan hanjonatan
i prefer it to look realistic. (i'm not straight, though, if it matters - but my answer refers to when i'm being done by a girl)
11/21/2012
Contributor: dancingduo dancingduo
Call me immature but supposed "realistic" dildos look hysterical to me...that and I, as the male,would not like to feel balls back there.
02/01/2013
Contributor: misterazor misterazor
Quote:
Originally posted by stlouisxxx
In the private voting, I am wondering if the guys who are getting pegged would rather have their woman wear a realistic dildo, or have a non penis looking dildo in their harness, or if they don't care.
rather have non-penis shaped...preferably glass.
02/02/2013
Contributor: spiced spiced
I like realistic. I'm bisexual and married; I only have sex with my wife, but I still enjoy the experience of being with as realistic a cock as possible. My favorite dildos are both Vixskin: Johnny and Mustang.

I like the design of the Goodfella, with its 360° balls, even though it's not big enough to be fully enjoyable. Feeling balls bump up against my ass definitely adds to the illusion. I hope Vixen will make a larger version of this design soon; something about the size of Johnny would be totally excellent.
02/05/2013
Contributor: Kitt Katt Kitt Katt
Realistic vs. non-realistic? He does not have a preference. Either way as long as the size is good. Sometimes I choose the toy based on what matches the outfit or harness I'm wearing. He willingly takes what is offered.
02/05/2013
Contributor: SecretKinksters SecretKinksters
He prefers non-realistic
02/25/2013