I think it depends on what you're going for. I have the Big Boss and Patchy Paul. If I could only have one, I'd probably take the PP, but it's a tough decision. I like the BB because it's bigger and more full kinda feeling, but the PP is awesome for the bugles it has and for the little hook at the end. Both do a good job at hitting my g-spot, but I think the PP is just more fun to play with.
I love my older version of patchy paul, but if i were to upgrade I might just go for the paul and paulina just to have something different that I would most likely enjoy.
I love them both, but I find I reach for the Tiger more often because he is easier to use. With the Big Boss and his girth, I have to work up to him. My g-spot loves both.
I have the G4 Big boss in orange. It's a beautiful toy with some power. But it's huge. I couldn't and still can't use it. Plus the battery life isn't long and the motor is located by the controls and not in the end of the vibrator so you can feel all the vibrations in your hand but not at the end of the shaft that's inside of you