I have the mustang and its great but I quickly wanted something with more diameter. So trying to decide now weather to go with 1 3/4 or a little bigger.
So if it was me to doing it over I would start with the bandit.
I went ahead and got the bandit. Have not had a chance to try it yet but man I think its going to be perfect! I posted some comparison pictures on the product pages if you want to check them out.
I think the shape of the Bandit would be better for first timers in anal play. The curve of the other one might be nice, though, but I doubt that everyone would find the design works well with their own anatomy.