Okay, so how many hetero couples have tried fisting and been successful? Boy do I have a story that boggles even my mind.....

Bignuf Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I love it) and a small toy or my finger is all my hubby gets.

So, here we are, on our first cruise ever (we travel all over, but have, by chance, never done a cruise). It has been totally amazing, by the way. Except one period of rain, while at sea, it's been ideal. We managed to enjoy that time exploring this huge ship, anyway.

So...here we are, in one of the ships "hot tubs" which extends over the ocean. It is prime dinner time, and to our amazment it is just us and another couple (I expected one hundred people to be there, but for a short while, it was just us). Seems they were there on their honeymoon. We told them we were enjoying our many, many year anniversary. That is how the talk started. Well, this "20 something" couple and us start chatting and of course, on their honeymoon, a word or two about "sex" leaks out. We go with the conversation...all fun. No one ever figures to see each other again on cruise anyway, right? So, the moment these two cute newlyweds realize they can "very openly" speak about sex to us, the "floodgates" open. Not only are they asking us about toys, positions, lubes, swollowing, anal play, enema's, handcuffs, tickling and a hundred other things, (Like we are some sages of sex, sitting on a mountaintop, since we have been married so long and appeared to be "really in love" as they put it), but then they start describing their "trip" so far...including the fact they just tried "fisting"...something she was (no kidding), waiting for marriage to have a trusting partner to do with!!!! Now, you have to picture this. She looks like she is maybe five feet tall, and she is a petite little thing.Tiny perky breasts, narrow hips, flat tummy, tiny, but nicely rounded tush. Cute, very petite package. He is small for a guy, maybe five foot five or six, but nicely muscled. We didn't find out till later he was just discharged (honorable) from the military and now in buiness. Anyway, she "bluts out" that they had tried "fisting" and he was "able to get his entire arm inside her up to his elbow". She was GIDDY with pride, and the thrill in her voice was incredible as she had found someone to "brag" to about it. My jaw almost hit the deck. I cannot imagine it, let alone picture it. Again, a couple fingers is all I can handle.

So....here we are, with two strangers, on a boat, telling us about fisting "up to his elbow". What to do next??? Well, people joined us in the hot tub shortly thereafter, so there was nothing to do but invite them to join us for dinner. Rather then do the dining room, we asked them to join us "our treat, to say congrats on their wedding" at the onboard "steak house", and in a nice, secluded booth. Our conversation continued there, quietly. Later, we asked them to our cabin to sit on the large balcony (we have a suite with a large outside sitting area) and have a beverage. We chatted about life and sex for hours. They had a small "inside" cabin, so ours was the place to be.

While I guess I will take this as a serious compliment, this young, attractive couple actually hinted..no, actually they asked, "would you guys ever do a foursome for fun"? Not sure if they were asking us to join them then and there, or asking for our "sage" advice, but we said, "no, we are totally menogomous and not into "group" anything" and so that issue dropped right there. No one seemed the least "put out". Well after midnight, we were tired and our brains were mush, so we wished them a great evening and off they went, her hand on his butt...I am sure, to go play (hard) in their cabin. We laid in bed...amused, stunned and rather..well amazed at the whole encounter. We did not arrange to meet them again, and on a boat of over 5000 passangers, we may not even see them in the next 48 hours before we pull into port. However, we have years of stories from these two, to look back on. Wow. They sure have an interesting life ahead.

So..back to my question. How many of you Hetero's out there have tried "Fisting" , with what you deem "success"???
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
I am the female in the couple, and have taken my guys hand/arm successfully in my rear.
I am the male in the couple and have taken my gals hand/arm successfully in my rear.
DashO'Roark
1
I am the female in the couple. We tried, but I couldn't take him in me that way
epiphanyjayne
1
I am the male in the couple and I tried, but could not take her in me that way.
Other?
Mrs.Tee , falalena , ellieprobable , panthercat23 , Geogeo , Gone (LD29) , SaiDiscordia , DigitalSweety , comatose-kitty , married with children , padmeamidala , phoenixfire , Cat E. , lainebug , brevado , SilverMinxxx
16
Total votes: 18 (18 voters)
Poll is closed
02/08/2013
  • Save 60% on 3 item set
  • It's Better Than Real! Buy 1 Dildo Or Anal Toy And Get 1 FRE
  • Save 60% on 3 item set for him

    • Crystal Pussy
    • Beginner silicone p-spot massager
    • Eden vibrating ring
    Save 60% on this 3 item set

    Expires on Aug, 29 at 3pm ET Terms

  • Save 60% on 3 item set for her

    • Compact Mini G
    • Single Kegel Ball
    • Waterproof nubby rabbit
    Save 60% when buying in a set

    Expires on Aug, 29 at 3pm ET Terms

  • Save 60% on 3 item set for couples

    • Passionate wrists cuffs
    • Luxury fetish passionate eye mask
    • Eden 20 function remote bullet
    Save 60% on this 3 item set

    Expires on Aug, 29 at 8pm ET Terms

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Ansley Ansley
And you're 100% positive she was talking about anal fisting? Even vaginally, this story is almost impossible to believe. I'm about the same size as she is, maybe even a little smaller and my husband is a pretty big guy so it's a matter of physics at this point but he can just barely get his hand inside (and would never attempt to do so for anal play).

I call shenanigans. Well, more to the point, I call hyperbole. She was probably over-exaggerating her accomplishment because that's what it felt like in her mind.
02/08/2013
Mrs.Tee Mrs.Tee
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I ... More
Intresting story. Fisting is something that I have never tried before. From reading your story is it very surprising that that lil lady actually took her whole husbands fist
02/08/2013
falalena falalena
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I ... More
very interesting. ive never tried fisting since my fiances penis can be fairly difficult to get in at times (im small, hes big). that is a pretty interesting story!
02/08/2013
ellieprobable ellieprobable
This is not something I've ever aspired to.
02/08/2013
panthercat23 panthercat23
Never sounded pleasurable to me.
02/08/2013
Geogeo Geogeo
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I ... More
I have no interest in fisting!
02/08/2013
Gone (LD29) Gone (LD29)
We've tried vaginal fisting (not anal) and not been successful. It's been a long time since we did that, though, and I think we could probably do it a lot more easily now if we tried.
02/08/2013
SaiDiscordia SaiDiscordia
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I ... More
My husband and I are about the same size as the couple on the ship, we have only been able to do vaginal fisting. We are still working on get his penis in the rear. Only toys and fingers for now.
02/08/2013
DigitalSweety DigitalSweety
I'd say they were full of it and possibly seeing if they could shock you, but... given some of the things I've seen on the Internet, well, you never know.

Personally, I've got no interest in fisting. None at all.
02/08/2013
comatose-kitty comatose-kitty
I have no other but would probavly never fist
02/08/2013
Bignuf Bignuf
Quote:
Originally posted by Ansley
And you're 100% positive she was talking about anal fisting? Even vaginally, this story is almost impossible to believe. I'm about the same size as she is, maybe even a little smaller and my husband is a pretty big guy so it's a matter of ... More
She was certainly speaking...in no uncertain terms, about anal fisting. Trust me, I took the story with a grain, no a shaker...no, a 5 ton truck of salt. I relayed it as she said it. Did I believe it at the time? Nope. Do I really think it was exactly as they laid it out? No. Maybe...but yes, I think you are very correct. It was the ultimate in B.S. to a couple strangers they were having fun with on the "Love Boat" in a hot tub. It was braggart story time!!!
02/08/2013
married with children married with children
would never try, we are not into that kind of play
02/08/2013
epiphanyjayne epiphanyjayne
I've had 3 babies all natural and still there is no fitting his hand up there. can not get past his knuckles, they hit my bones.
02/08/2013
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
She was certainly speaking...in no uncertain terms, about anal fisting. Trust me, I took the story with a grain, no a shaker...no, a 5 ton truck of salt. I relayed it as she said it. Did I believe it at the time? Nope. Do I really think it was ... More
Sounds about right. Eh, good for them. They'll tell stories for years how they shocked and horrified you all and it was just a big joke. That's what honeymooning is all about - building those foundations.
02/08/2013
phoenixfire phoenixfire
This is something I would never try. No thanks. (Shivers.)
02/08/2013
Cat E. Cat E.
I'd never do that.
02/08/2013
DashO'Roark DashO'Roark
I frequently take her entire hand during anal play. I love the slow gentle stretching followed by the quick relaxing around her wrist.
02/08/2013
lainebug lainebug
Quote:
Originally posted by Bignuf
As a couple, we really enjoy anal play. We have tried "fisting", but I am so tight, a few fingers is all that will ever happen in me. Period. Same with hubby. Thus, his penis is the biggest thing I ever take inside my tush (but OH, how I ... More
nope but hmmm myb try
02/08/2013
SilverMinxxx SilverMinxxx
I'm not into anal or vaginal fisting.
02/09/2013
Total posts: 20
Unique posters: 18