What was your first anal toy?

My first (and thus far, only) plug was the small Njoy Pure Plug.

Mine was the Love Pacifier. I definitely recommend it! I still use it even after using other toys. Solid awesome toy.

Here: link

Well, the first thingI stuck up my butt was a hairbrush. But I wouldn't recommend it.

My first toy was a glass dildo, but I'm afraid I can't remember the name. It was lovely, but I would suggest silicone for beginners. Unfortunately I don't have a prostate, so I can't speak to that, but Bob is supposed to be good for p-spotting. And it's a great toy in general! I really like Love Pacifier Beginner and Ace Plug Small.

Happy shopping! Wheeee!

My first one was the "My First Butt Plug," which I still remember was tiny, didn't stimulate much and couldn't stay in for much longer than a minute or two before slipping out. Me and the gal tossed it after a week.
Several years down the line I bought the Belladonna Evil Pink Bumpy Butt Plug. That was the day I decided that sex toys were the lifestyle for me.

My first anal toy was Naughty Boy.
If I had it to do over again I probably would go with the Slim by Tantus and work up to the Butt Boy. The Naughty Boy has retention problems.

First "real" toy was the Tantus Big Flirt. Nice for active play but doesn't stay in well on its own (the neck isn't long enough). Before that I used fingers and some found/repurposed objects.

My first toy was the rude boy. It took sometime to be able to comfortably fit it in. I got it because it didn't look that obvious unlike a dildo.

I guess technically the first toy I ever used was a spoon that had a nuce handle on it when I was in college. I had no idea what I was doing really, but I had a serious hunch that I could get something out of sticking something in my butt while I jerked off. I did that for a series of months if I remember correctly, but then I stopped and life moved on.

Years later I purchased an Aneros MGX after reading about the wonders of the Super O. I'm so glad I got that massager and all the orgasms I've had since from it and all the other toys I've found my pspot with.

It was my first toy ever. It was a small anal plug made of jelly, and about 1" in diameter.

My first was a drumstick. Not recommended! Even the biggest ones lack girth.

My second was a Classic Dong or something like it. I loved that thing, though it took me several attempts to get it in. I would no longer attempt anything without a flared base.

Njoy pure plug.

The Triple Ripple by Doc Johnson. It was pretty fantastic then, though I've someone grown away from it and towards regular dildos.