I got so excited when I saw this, I love Supernatural.
I'd do Jared cause his body is epic. He's so muscular and tall. It would just be amazing.
I'd do Jensen because he's got one of the most handsome faces ever and he has a cool name.
I'd do Misha and his wife at the same time because she wrote a book on it (The Threesome Handbook
). But Misha would have to be dressed as Cas and do the raspy Cas voice for the entire time.
I'd also do Jeffrey Dean Morgan because John Winchester is badass and he's the sexiest 45-year-old I've ever seen.
I feel like I'm leaving Bobby out but I mean...he's Bobby.