Yes. I am like you, I love clean places, I clean my own room multiple times a week and the rest of the house at least once - usually sweep the floors three or more times and vaccume once a week.
The only thing I don't really judge on is dishes, if they are in the sink or on the counter by the sink and just look like they haven't been taken care of in a couple of days (2 or 3) then it's kind of w/e - if there are weird smells then it annoys me.
I hate cleaning up after people too ._. which is a big issue with my brother b/c he's a complete slob and if anything is cleaned I have to clean it. It's incredibly annoying considering he invites his guests over and they all make messes and don't clean after themselves...
Anyway, I very much judge people on cleanliness, because I don't want to be in an environment that makes me twitchy and uncomfortable. And disorganized, dirty environments do that. A bit of clutter? I'm cool with, some people like all their little decorations and things.