The Definitive Jelly Belly Poll - Official 50 Flavors

  • Get FREE 5 Gifts with Orders $59+

The Definitive Jelly Belly Poll - Official 50 Flavors

Ansley Ansley
(Private voting for neatness sake, not because I actually think people want to hide their jelly bean preferences.)

Which of the Official 50 flavors do you enjoy the most? Pick as many as you'd like.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
A&W Cream Soda
17
A&W Root Beer
23
Berry Blue
6
Blueberry
14
Bubble Gum
13
Buttered Popcorn
33
Cantaloupe
7
Cappuchino
18
Caramel Corn
10
Chili Mango
4
Chocolate Pudding
15
Cinnamon
10
Coconut
17
Cotton Candy
18
Crushed Pineapple
15
Dr. Pepper
21
French Vanilla
17
Green Apple
15
Island Punch
7
Juicy Pear
20
Kiwi
8
Lemon Drop
10
Lemon Lime
6
Licorice
6
Mango
10
Margarita
7
Mixed Berry Smoothie
10
Orange Sherbert
14
Peach
20
Pina Colada
13
Plum
4
Pomegranate
13
Raspberry
11
Red Apple
9
Sizzling Cinnamon
10
Strawberry Cheesecake
20
Strawberry Daiquiri
12
Strawberry Jam
6
Sour Cherry
8
Sunkist Lemon
3
Sunkist Lime
4
Sunkist Orange
6
Sunkist Pink Grapefruit
4
Sunkist Tangerine
4
Toasted Marshmallow
28
Top Banana
13
Tutti-Fruitti
11
Very Cherry
16
Watermelon
15
Wild Blackerry
4
I eat them one flavor at a time
53
I eat them a handful at a time, mixing flavors
4
I follow the recipes to make specific jelly belly gourmet 'desserts'
26
I forgot what the question was...AKA the "other" option
4
Total votes: 692 (89 voters)
Poll is closed
09/06/2011
  • Buy 3 Items for $70
  • Buy 3 Items for $50
  • Buy 3 Items for $30
  • Save 20% on Luxury Toys
  • Add Some Buzz To Your Favourite Toy & Save 60% On Kit
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Kkay Kkay
Kudos on the patience to make the poll!

For me, it's all about the buttered popcorn. I'll actually get a bag just of that when I'm craving it.
09/06/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by Kkay
Kudos on the patience to make the poll!

For me, it's all about the buttered popcorn. I'll actually get a bag just of that when I'm craving it.
Thanks!

I apparently only dig 26 out of 50 flavors. The buttered popcorn just makes my tongue feel weird, but I know it's *the* most popular flavor besides juicy pear.
09/06/2011
Ansley Ansley
Wow, so far no one likes the "original" fruit flavors. Neat.
09/06/2011
Jul!a Jul!a
I... honestly have no idea lol. It's been so long since I've eaten Jelly Bellies. I may have to go track some down lol.
09/06/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by Jul!a
I... honestly have no idea lol. It's been so long since I've eaten Jelly Bellies. I may have to go track some down lol.
The pomegranate ones are new and those are one of the flavors I would snag just a whole bag of. There's a four pound tub at either Costco or Sam's or one of those places and I have to stop myself from buying it every time I go in there. At $11.99 for four pounds, it's a steal.
09/06/2011
ZenaidaMacroura ZenaidaMacroura
Ooh, I keep forgetting I have a couple little packs of Jelly Bellies in my purse! Thanks for reminding me with this poll. My absolute favorite flavor is tutti frutti. Which is unfortunately also my boyfriend's favorite, so if we only get one in a package, we have to flip a coin for it. The soda flavored ones are pretty awesome, no matter which soda. I also (I think) really like the buttered popcorn (it's such an odd but interesting flavor, I'm never sure what to think of it).
09/06/2011
GravyCakes GravyCakes
i haven't had jelly belly jelly beans in a while
09/06/2011
mistressg mistressg
BERRY BLUE IS THE ONLY GOOD ONE!!!!!!
09/06/2011
Owl Identified Owl Identified
BUTTERED POPCORN FOREVER.
09/06/2011
FaerieLove FaerieLove
Roasted marshmallow!!!
09/06/2011
Lucky21 Lucky21
Jucy Pear. End of story!
09/06/2011
Nora Nora
Juicy Pear, Buttered Popcorn, and Toasted Marshmallow...oh how I wish they made these in sugar free so I could enjoy them without completely blowing my diet!
09/06/2011
ThoughtsAblaze ThoughtsAblaze
It's been way too long since I had some jelly beans! I'm all about the fruit flavors, and am going to admit that I strongly dislike Buttered Popcorn. The last time I had jelly beans was a bag of them while in Gatlinburg with my family last fall. It drove me bonkers that my sister would snag a handful and pop them in her mouth. One flavor at a time!
09/06/2011
Yaoi Pervette (deleted) Yaoi Pervette (deleted)
Count me as another one flavor at a time person. I like to savor each flavor. I tend to stick to the traditional fruity flavors mostly.

Speaking of Jelly Belly flavors, do they still make the "Vomit" flavor beans? I've never tried them, but I wondered if anyone had had the guts to do it.
09/06/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by ThoughtsAblaze
It's been way too long since I had some jelly beans! I'm all about the fruit flavors, and am going to admit that I strongly dislike Buttered Popcorn. The last time I had jelly beans was a bag of them while in Gatlinburg with my family last ...
When I as a kid, I would beg my mom to let me get a pound from the candy store. I would take tiny scoops of my four favorite flavors then weigh it to see if I was under and keep adding tiny scoops until I was just at a lb. Drove my mom insane cause it would take me forever.
09/06/2011
Antipova Antipova
Buttered popcorn and caramel corn are a totally different breed---I'll buy them separately, or separate them and eat them before all the other jelly beans, or after. They're delicious!

I'm a big fan of peach, juicy pear, and toasted marshmallow too.

The only one I really hate is tutti fruti, or if you get a cinnamon in with a mouthfull of others. I separate my favorite flavors (more than I just listed here, but after a while I'll get lazy and eat them grab-bag style.)

I think I'm going to walk to the store and pick some up, actually. Great poll, Stormy!
09/06/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by Antipova
Buttered popcorn and caramel corn are a totally different breed---I'll buy them separately, or separate them and eat them before all the other jelly beans, or after. They're delicious!

I'm a big fan of peach, juicy pear, and ...
Thanks, Antipova! I haven't had the caramel corn yet. I assume it tastes like candy corn? The only flavor I really, really dislike is margarita. It reminds me of the night our favorite bartender made me her version of a margarita and I ended up getting extremely sick. And it just seems completely out of place with the rest of the flavors.
09/07/2011
indiglo indiglo
I've only tried some of those flavors. Looks like I have some important research to do next time I go to the grocery!
09/07/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by indiglo
I've only tried some of those flavors. Looks like I have some important research to do next time I go to the grocery!
Target is the only big box store I know of that has the separate containers for each flavor, but the really cool thing is that if you grab a package where the flavors are all mixed is that each one is hand-blended and you'll get a different amount of each flavor in each package. Peach seem to be the hardest to get in abundance.

This post all started because I was watching the Dirty Jobs episode where he made his own flavor: Mike's Stinky Boots and I later saw the documentary on the creator of Jelly Belly: David Klein. The history of it is fascinating.
09/07/2011
The Giveaway Diva The Giveaway Diva
too many favs to list! i love the butter popcorn, juicy pear, tutti fruti and i love mixing them up to see what flavour combos i can make
09/07/2011
GenderSexplorations GenderSexplorations
I don't honestly think that there are any flavours that I don't really like. Jelly beans are awesome!
09/07/2011
MR Chickhabit MR Chickhabit
buttered popcorn and toasted marshmallow for the win

also, what about bertie bots every flavor beans?
09/07/2011
ToyTimeTim ToyTimeTim
Where's the "All of the above" option? lol Never had one I did not like. We use to have a store back in Colorado where you could get them all, either mixed or all the same, sure miss that place.
09/07/2011
El-Jaro El-Jaro
I can't stand the buttered popcorn one. Blech to them. I'm not a fan of most sweet/salty combos.

I love the toasted marshmallow!
09/07/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by ToyTimeTim
Where's the "All of the above" option? lol Never had one I did not like. We use to have a store back in Colorado where you could get them all, either mixed or all the same, sure miss that place.
LOL I figured 53 slots was enough...LOLOL

I miss candy stores in general, especially penny candy stores (but when I was a kid they were a nickle). There just aren't enough of them around.
09/07/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by El-Jaro
I can't stand the buttered popcorn one. Blech to them. I'm not a fan of most sweet/salty combos.

I love the toasted marshmallow!
The toasted marhsmallow, chocolate pudding, banana and french vanilla together taste almost like a Boston Creme pie. Soooo good. And I'm with you on the butter popcorn. It's just wrong.
09/07/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by Yaoi Pervette (deleted)
Count me as another one flavor at a time person. I like to savor each flavor. I tend to stick to the traditional fruity flavors mostly.

Speaking of Jelly Belly flavors, do they still make the "Vomit" flavor beans? I've never ...
Yeah, they still make the Bertie Botts beans. They're so nasty, but those Harry Potter fans love them.
09/07/2011
Ansley Ansley
Quote:
Originally posted by MR Chickhabit
buttered popcorn and toasted marshmallow for the win

also, what about bertie bots every flavor beans?
They're gross and no person in their right mind over the age of 12 would willingly eat them.
09/07/2011
Sunshineamine Sunshineamine
The only one i don't like is licorice. HATE licorice. Otherwise I love 'em all and eat 'em one by one. Now I want jellybeans dammit.
09/07/2011
Total posts: 79
Unique posters: 58