Originally posted by
That should be added to the instructions . Or a quick reviewer pane that lets the author know what changed.
Thanks for the info though, and I'll keep that in mind on my next review.
It's supposed to go like this, if you aren't ranked high enough to self publish:
A contributor reads your review. For every piece of information missing and such they dock your rating. For every typo and run on sentence they dock the editors rating.
It's the editors fault if there are grammar and spelling issues if you're not self publishing, which is why they can be downvoted. If there are typos and such either they didn't read your review well enough or they put them there, themselves. If they get too many downvotes, meaning they left too many errors in your review that people noticed, they won't be accepted into an editor round in the future.