Rewriting reviews - Do you?

The New Intimacy

Rewriting reviews - Do you?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Fun Lover Fun Lover
Quote:
Originally posted by Dragon
I was glad to hear In the Pink chime in here. It's the competitiveness that I hate the most about Eden.

I am glad that it works for others, I know that it can be a powerful motivator.

For those that just want to learn about sex, ... more
I agree just want to spend my money wisely and have some fun in the process. Life is to short to always have to be number 1.
03/04/2009
Contributor: Adriana Ravenlust Adriana Ravenlust
Quote:
Originally posted by Dragon
I was glad to hear In the Pink chime in here. It's the competitiveness that I hate the most about Eden.

I am glad that it works for others, I know that it can be a powerful motivator.

For those that just want to learn about sex, ... more
I'm sorry it is such a negative thing for you, DBD. I think competition is absolutely necessary in everything and it certainly helps me to be my best.
03/04/2009
Contributor: Rockin' Rockin'
In the Pink called it a selfless act to edit/rewrite less-than-adequate reviews. I couldn't agree more, and I see those sorts of acts as the basis of why we're here. (I don't want to sound over-important because I'm new, but...) People who use this site to buy toys want the best information they can get before purchasing. If I'm a customer reading reviews, I want them to be high-quality, and I don't care if they have been edited, as long as they are honest and helpful. As far as rank is concerned, if you did leave reviews in their original form, but then went on to become a highly ranked contributor, I think it would look strange to a customer who read reviews from this acclaimed contributor if the reviews were sub-par, even if there were a follow-up review (because sometimes they might not make it to the follow-up).
03/25/2009
Contributor: Tuesday Tuesday
I just re-wrote one of my first reviews. As I look them over I just can't stand that writing like that has my name associated with it.

My only concern is that people will read the review, then the comments and think "WTF?" since they no longer match.
03/25/2009
Contributor: Rockin' Rockin'
Quote:
Originally posted by Tuesday
I just re-wrote one of my first reviews. As I look them over I just can't stand that writing like that has my name associated with it.

My only concern is that people will read the review, then the comments and think "WTF?" ... more
Huh, I didn't think about the comments part not matching. Maybe if you seriously rewrite a review or heavily edit it, you could note it with a date? Then someone could at least compare the edited date with the comments if they were confused.
03/25/2009
Contributor: Sammi Sammi
Quote:
Originally posted by Tuesday
I just re-wrote one of my first reviews. As I look them over I just can't stand that writing like that has my name associated with it.

My only concern is that people will read the review, then the comments and think "WTF?" ... more
I hadn't thought about that.
03/25/2009
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
You could note the parts that have been modified to address comments as well - something like [in response to comment] would work.

If it helps, don't think of rewriting reviews as a selfless act of cooperation, think of it as competing with yourself!
03/26/2009
Contributor: Tuesday Tuesday
These are good suggestions. I think I'll re-edit again so I can implement them.
03/26/2009