Do you prefer long toys, wide toys or downright Big toys for anal play, or do you prefer moderate sized toys?

  • Christmas shipping schedule
  • 20% OFF sitewide — Code: ENJOY20

Do you prefer long toys, wide toys or downright Big toys for anal play, or do you prefer moderate sized toys?

White Wolf White Wolf
When it comes to anal i like anything that goes in deep. Sadly enough though, many things that are long enough to satisfy are so wide that it just cant possibly go in very far. It would seem that anything 1.5 inches or wider just wont go in past 6 inches.

To my question... I am looking for recommendations of toys that are long,flexible, and relatively skinny while still being somewhat filling. Personal input is well appreciated.

I think i shall make this somewhat fun i shall make a poll, do you prefer width? or length? when it comes to anal toys. (i would really appreciate it if you made a comment going into further detail, maybe stating a favorite toy?)
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
The longer the better.
White Wolf , Istanbull , plaidvulva
3  (2%)
Stretch me! (width)
Research , Jenniae09 , SydVicious , JustYourAverageGuy , Love Buzz , CleverKitty , Yoda , Carrie Ann , Vexed , CafeSabroso , Shellz31 , Danielle915 , greatleader , heydude , gothikstars , RubenesqueAna , Brianna91 , Cookie Monster Mike , Berekiah , Sex'и'Violence , GonetoLovehoney , flyanddrive91 , delcubed , DanK63 , Dreaus
25  (18%)
Make if HUGE! (long and wide)
Robin Goodfellow , jb1walker , dv8 , potstickers , slynch
5  (4%)
Prefer moderate sized toys.
sexysweetieshan , Kayla , LittleBoPeep , mllebeauty , Waterfall , Passionate Pastor , Coralbell , Miss Cinnamon , aleong , RadRach , SexyySarah , testing123 , jakjak , Lady Venus , ~LaUr3n~ , onehotmomma , Adriana Ravenlust , lamira , Naughty Student , Hannah Savage , Stagger13 , Rainbow Boy , Fun Lover , NuMe , sasweetheart89 , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , RedRed , ToyGeek , Kitty Kitty , csweatc , ZenaidaMacroura , Phoenix713 , TheSexista , Twist , Liz2 , P'Gell , SexyTabby , seaofneptune , mnc5051 , Avalee , clp , dhig , MR Chickhabit , Intertwining , Lady Neshamah , mrs.mckrakn , toxie m , navigator-d , ihavenipples , jrz , Linga , Kindred , Solar Ray , Angel deSanguine , magicmac , Eric , zracer , kfdarling , The Curious Couple , tkphoto6 , liilii080 , cburger , callsignhusker , MaryExy , tits only , padmeamidala , Rossie , CharmCity , krisvida , Spilock , starsNairguitars , ichwillwaffels , Drifter86 , Hallmar82 , Eva Schwaltz , bliss after dark , Mary-Anne-Xun , kendra30752 , AOutrajus , 724-6924 , PassionCpl , LQ , Equinegoddess3 , allybee , AMTTT , Clandestine , Kendrir , namelesschaos , Jon S , markwashere , geliebt , Missmarc , Willow Wand , Apirka , tinadice , Boosty , Two Grand , bog , evie.amor , TheirPet , ashboo32 , Brandiewhy
102  (74%)
does not matter.
guy4guyz420 , Jimmy.P
2  (1%)
Total votes: 137
Poll is closed
09/25/2010
  • Buy 1 Toy, Get 1 FREE! Mix and Match
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Couples!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Her!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Him!
  • Holiday Clearance – Save 80%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
ToyTimeTim ToyTimeTim
I like a little variety. When first starting out I like something long, like my Gold Laced G (5 3/4" long, I can not take it all in). This works for probing around and getting the prostate exited. Then I switch to something with some more girth, for this I use my Happy valley Deep Secret (1 1/4" dia.). The bulbs feel really good with some fast thrusting and there is still some room for probing. To finish my new favorite is the Pure Wand, using the large end (1 1/2"dia.). This provides the full feeling and all the pressure I want. I notice that the larger size does not work as good for thrusting though, maybe due to the size or lack of room, I am not sure.

I am looking to go up in size from the Pure wand, something in the 1 1/2"- 1 3/4" range. My ass seems to want more girth rather than length.

Not sure what to recommend for you though, the only toy I find that has length and still flexible are the G force at 7" insertable 1 1/8"dia. and possibly the Bandito at 10" insertable 1 1/2" dia.
09/25/2010
Kayla Kayla
I don't enjoy anal, but the boyfriend does, and he likes moderately or small sized toys.
09/25/2010
mllebeauty mllebeauty
I really enjoy anal, especially having something stationary inside me. Perhaps because I don't have a prostate? I prefer wide to long but I'm still working in the moderate range.
09/25/2010
ScottA ScottA
What do you mean by moderate?

I like them in the 2" diameter range and 7+ inches, with a curve and some sort of head (sometimes texture, depends on mood). Plugs vary, but I can't see myself liking anything under 1.5" diameter.
09/25/2010
Research Research
I prefer wide over long because I'm a little afraid of hurting something down deep. For a wide toy I've had some great luck with the Large Big Stuff from Doc Johnson. It's made specifically as an anal toy and works out great.

When I'm feeling adventurous and want to go deep, I use the Translucence double dong from Cal Exotics. It's too thick to take all the way but I can usually handle about 2/3 of it.
09/26/2010
SexyySarah SexyySarah
I don't like anything too big in my ass, but love girth in my pussy!
09/26/2010
SydVicious SydVicious
Quote:
Originally posted by SexyySarah
I don't like anything too big in my ass, but love girth in my pussy!
Pretty much the same here.
09/27/2010
~LaUr3n~ ~LaUr3n~
I can get perfect long and thick from my partner, so I prefer to have or use toys smaller than him.
09/29/2010
lamira lamira
When it comes to anal, I prefer moderate. I'm a bit too sensitive for overly large toys there.
09/30/2010
ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by Research
I prefer wide over long because I'm a little afraid of hurting something down deep. For a wide toy I've had some great luck with the Large Big Stuff from Doc Johnson. It's made specifically as an anal toy and works out great.

When ...
As long as it's a soft toy and you aren't too wild you're pretty safe.
10/01/2010
Yoda Yoda
I guess this depends on the person. For dildos, I consider anything over 1.75 inches in width to be large and ideal, but not wider than 2.15 inches. It just doesn't feel good after that.

In length, I find that I can only take about 5-6 inches of any toy comfortably. Anything longer hits a spot that can be tender in inserted with force.
10/06/2010
Naughty Student Naughty Student
I usually tend to stay around the 1 inch and 1/2 mark in terms of width and I don't like anything longer than 6 inches. So I consider that to be pretty moderate to my standards.

I have never tried anything larger than 1 inch and 1/2 but maybe I will eventually.
10/06/2010
guy4guyz420 guy4guyz420
Quote:
Originally posted by White Wolf
When it comes to anal i like anything that goes in deep. Sadly enough though, many things that are long enough to satisfy are so wide that it just cant possibly go in very far. It would seem that anything 1.5 inches or wider just wont go in past 6 ...
i like any size toy really sometimes i want something moderately sized and other times i want something big and fat. just go with whatever gets you off better.
10/07/2010
Rainbow Boy Rainbow Boy
I've never been able to go beyond the 6 inch mark in terms of length, so long toys I don't really care about. Girth is what's more pleasurable for me, but nothing to large. I've been able to accommodate a 1.75 inch diameter plug, but it didn't feel too arousing. The maximum diameter I penetrate myself with nowadays is 1.5 or 1.6 inches in diameter (with a good deal of warming up).

My favorite dildo right now is Doc Johnson's The Tool (link). It's a wonderful girth without being too thick (1.375 inches in diameter). It gives an excellent feeling of fullness, and it has a narrow head for easy insertion. However, make sure you do some warming up prior to inserting this. I typically start out with the Tantus Silk medium, then Doc Johnson's Pop Plug medium, and then I use the Tantus Ryder before finally penetrating myself with the Tool.
10/08/2010
Vexed Vexed
I love thick toys. That are 2" - 3" in diameter. Sometimes I like taking a 2.5" toy in deep past the curve inside me. It usually takes 11" to bottom out then. If I don't go pass that curve, 7" hits bottom. This is the case with toys that are 3" in diameter.
10/17/2010
Shellz31 Shellz31
Depends on my mood but usually love thicker toys!
10/18/2010
NuMe NuMe
For anal I prefer the moderate sized ones.
10/18/2010
Liz2 Liz2
Overall, I prefer moderate sized anal toys but size is not the prime issue, so much depends on shape, design and material and how I "feel" at the time.
I need time for larger plugs as I have to prep by using smaller plugs and moving up.
I have the 2.0 inch NJoy which I enjoy but I have to work up to it.
11/04/2010
P'Gell P'Gell
Quote:
Originally posted by ~LaUr3n~
I can get perfect long and thick from my partner, so I prefer to have or use toys smaller than him.
I like smaller toys, and beads are nice if I'm in the mood. Although stretching is really fun vaginally, I prefer only mild to moderate toys anally. I don't like "pokey" toys, ones with pointy ends. Not comfortable. I prefer teardrop or bead shapes.
11/04/2010
seaofneptune seaofneptune
I prefer moderate sized or smaller toys, but I am new to anal and it's easier for me to relax with something smaller. I don't want anything huge shoved up there.
11/04/2010
Research Research
I haven't been able to find anything that fills the gap between the 2.5 inch Triple Ripple Royale and the 3 inch Tex. I am looking at some of the inflatable plugs now to see how far I can go, I see some inflate to 4-5 inches across!
11/05/2010
Robin Goodfellow Robin Goodfellow
You need the Jollies Wave. It is quite long and narrow enough.
11/06/2010
Twist Twist
I am a big guy so I need a long toy for prostate message. The Aneros models don't really work as well as they should because of that.
11/15/2010
Avalee Avalee
Small
11/22/2010
clp clp
I think 'tapered' is more important to me than the final size. As long as I get a head start, so to speak, I can take pretty girthy toys. I definitely need that build up, though.
11/22/2010
dhig dhig
Moderate please. Big enough to do the job, not so big that they leave me gingerly sitting for a few days, lol
12/03/2010
mrs.mckrakn mrs.mckrakn
nothing too big. moderate is good for me. maybe ill expirement with a large one one day
12/14/2010
kfdarling kfdarling
New to this so small for me.
04/11/2011
The Curious Couple The Curious Couple
My fiancee and I both prefer moderate sized toys.
04/12/2011
Total posts: 63
Unique posters: 61