First anal toy? Butt plug or vibrating plug?

The New Intimacy

Featured by EdenFantasys

Butt Plugs for Enhanced Pleasure
Butt Plugs for Enhanced Pleasure
Learn How
Thrusting butt plug
Anal plugs
6 Ways To Get More Pleasure With Butt Plugs
6 Ways To Get More Pleasure
With Butt Plugs
Explore Now

First anal toy? Butt plug or vibrating plug?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Though I couldn't call myself a beginner at the experience at all but I still have to get used to it, and considering to get something to make myself get used to the feeling better, with small sizes for now...

What do you think would be best, and/or what was your first anal toy for the purpose?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
kittychilla , slynch , Flash777 , philly , sexydelphia , Eucaly , indiglo , LAndJ , ichwillwaffels , boobookittyfuk , Love Perpetua , Churga57 , Jon S , cmm , Eva Schwaltz , Masokisti , Mr. E , The-IT-Guy-And-My-Secretary , Entropy , missjnicole , prttynink , Missmarc , TerryAnne , LavenderSkies , Jroc , Rin (aka Nire) , T&A1987 , Lizzy , Funtastic , Allstars316 , HouseWench , Lucky21 , (k)InkyIvy , McTavishes , Vadim50 , PassionateLover2 , OroNomi , potstickers , Raizer911 , Andersonda , tinadice , mlmac , GoneBabyGone , C.C. , Howells , SimpleTwistofFate , klyte , Stinkytofu10 , Azule , bh253 , Librarian , roskat , SkinFlute , BoobCopter , Kappa8564 , Kat and Aaron(aaron) , Dr. Curious , Tango8976 , Athena313 , untster69 , LoneOokami , ashboo32 , KrissyNovacaine , SecretKinksters , TJtheMadHatter , smilinkayak , BrittaniMaree , padmeamidala , Septimus , Rawr4483 , dolfie84 , Lena Eden
72  (77%)
Nazaress , <3BF , Beck , Stagger13 , MR Chickhabit , geliebt , Bonny69 , Incendiaire , JennSenn , britanny0620 , Rayne Millaray , AlianneCimorene , clockwork451 , cj89 , thesquaredeific , PurplePainter23 , Apple3192 , Hallmar82
18  (19%)
IndridCold , Mr Dj , ihavenipples
3  (3%)
Total votes: 93
Poll is open
12/17/2011
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Save 70% On Selected Items. Limited Quantity
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: GingerAnn GingerAnn
Collection of related topics on Butt plugs:

How can I keep a dildo(not butt plugs) in my butt while penetrating my wife?
I have looked at various harnesses but they are all geared toward women to pleasure men. Most don't have a hole through which to stick my penis or if.

The super big end– butt plug
nice! But could someone tell me how it'd feel?

Large metal plugs?
I know that EF sells the njoy plugs, but those don't really meet my requirements for diameter. Can someone refer me to a site that sells large...

Tantus O2 Plugs?
Just wondering what the chances might be of a Tantus plug being made with 02 material? I've been watching all these amazing new Tantus products being.

Metal or silicone butt plugs?
I'm thinking about getting a nice metal butt plug, but there's a lot of nice silicone ones out there too. Should I save up a little more for one of...
12/17/2011
Contributor: Flash777 Flash777
non vibrating is better imo
12/18/2011
Contributor: Nazaress Nazaress
I'm definitely no expert (I've yet to delve too much into this type of play) but from what I've read, the vibration helps to relax you. I know my boyfriend likes it for the vibration, not really for it just "being in there", if that makes sense.
12/18/2011
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by Flash777
non vibrating is better imo
Oh I wonder what the reason may be!
12/19/2011
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by Nazaress
I'm definitely no expert (I've yet to delve too much into this type of play) but from what I've read, the vibration helps to relax you. I know my boyfriend likes it for the vibration, not really for it just "being in there", if that makes sense.
Well yep, that's what I think too, though simple, nonvibrating plugs are just sooo popular as I see, that it makes me wonder how come they are used more...

That's why I opened this discussion to find it out...
12/19/2011
Contributor: philly philly
I'd say go with a simple butt plug, that's what I had and still love it the most
12/23/2011
Contributor: sexydelphia sexydelphia
Quote:
Originally posted by philly
I'd say go with a simple butt plug, that's what I had and still love it the most
i agree
12/23/2011
Contributor: Highmaintenancegirl916 Highmaintenancegirl916
Butt plug something small yet simple 2 start out with.
12/28/2011
Contributor: indiglo indiglo
I started with a very basic butt plug that did not vibrate. I recently got a toy that vibrates and can be used anally for an assignment - and I love it!

I think I went about it the right way. Start with something very basic just to get used to that kind of stimulation, and then move up to something that vibrates. (In fact, now that I know I like vibrations back there, I plan on getting another vibrating butt toy!)
12/28/2011
Contributor: LAndJ LAndJ
Definitely go for a smaller plug if trying for the first time. We order one that was huge (in our opinion) for the first time recently. It worked, but it took a few tries for insertion and hurt like hell the first time we tried to use it.
12/28/2011
Contributor: ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by DreamWolf
Though I couldn't call myself a beginner at the experience at all but I still have to get used to it, and considering to get something to make myself get used to the feeling better, with small sizes for now...

What do you think would be ... more
I would just go with the plain plug. When I started I thought adding vibration might be a bit much, but then again I'm a bit of a wimp.
12/29/2011
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Oh my... Surprising answers... How sweet I can get to know these, I was going more for a vibrating plug...

Though of course a good one can be used without vibration too... ^^
12/30/2011
Contributor: Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
The first butt toy I ever used (besides fingers) was a vibrating inflatable butt plug my boyfriend bought. It was a little too much stimulation for a newbie so I only let him use it on me a couple times. I would go for a non vibrating plug or probe as a first toy.
12/30/2011
Contributor: cmm cmm
Vibrating plugs are more geared towards men in my opinion.
01/01/2012
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
Vibrating can help relaxation, but the big issue with them is that if they're not waterproof cleanup is much more difficult.

A number of silicone plugs come with a removable "silver bullet" type vibe. If you're going for a plug that buzzes get one of these. You can always turn it off.

It's better to get a good size, shape and material plug for you first, then worry about vibe or no vibe later. If it's got a vibe great, if not then start without one and move on for your next toy.
01/01/2012
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
Vibrating can help relaxation, but the big issue with them is that if they're not waterproof cleanup is much more difficult.

A number of silicone plugs come with a removable "silver bullet" type vibe. If you're going for a ... more
Yep, that's my thought on it very much nowadays, and I think I am gonna go for a "training kit", not that one couldn't get the pieces individually too, but why not to get a set of 3 different sizes, and I will get a vibrating tiny one too, just in case...
01/01/2012
Contributor: Eva Schwaltz Eva Schwaltz
Go with something simple. I started off with the First Time Love Beads.
01/01/2012
Contributor: Mr. E Mr. E
I'd focus more on selecting one that is appropriately sized for your comfort level. I've personally had more success with non-vibrating plugs.

Good luck and have fun!
01/01/2012
Contributor: The-IT-Guy-And-My-Secretary The-IT-Guy-And-My-Secretary
Quote:
Originally posted by DreamWolf
Though I couldn't call myself a beginner at the experience at all but I still have to get used to it, and considering to get something to make myself get used to the feeling better, with small sizes for now...

What do you think would be ... more
Dont spend a lot of money until you decide if you really like anal play. You could find yourself spending a bit money on a toy you end up not using. Start out simple then move yourself up.
01/01/2012
Contributor: Entropy Entropy
Learn to enjoy the feeling of a plug inside of you before you venture into vibrations.
01/02/2012
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by The-IT-Guy-And-My-Secretary
Dont spend a lot of money until you decide if you really like anal play. You could find yourself spending a bit money on a toy you end up not using. Start out simple then move yourself up.
That's the plan...
01/03/2012
Contributor: prttynink prttynink
Quote:
Originally posted by Entropy
Learn to enjoy the feeling of a plug inside of you before you venture into vibrations.
agreed
01/03/2012
Contributor: Missmarc Missmarc
Quote:
Originally posted by DreamWolf
Though I couldn't call myself a beginner at the experience at all but I still have to get used to it, and considering to get something to make myself get used to the feeling better, with small sizes for now...

What do you think would be ... more
I'd recommend a butt plug on the smaller end.
01/12/2012
Contributor: <3BF <3BF
Quote:
Originally posted by DreamWolf
Though I couldn't call myself a beginner at the experience at all but I still have to get used to it, and considering to get something to make myself get used to the feeling better, with small sizes for now...

What do you think would be ... more
We both like the Vibrating anal-T:
link

We've tried both vibrating and non-vibrating ones and feel that the vibrations make a plug feel more pleasure, hence more desirable for a beginner.
01/12/2012
Contributor: Jroc Jroc
Simple.
01/12/2012
Contributor: Beck Beck
I want vibrations in my anal toys usually.
01/13/2012
Contributor: T&A1987 T&A1987
the lil' end, it was also the first toy I ever bought.
01/13/2012
Contributor: Lizzy Lizzy
Try both to see which kind you like. Start out w non vibe first.
01/20/2012
Contributor: Allstars316 Allstars316
Simple one
01/24/2012