Males Only! What is your max diameter for anal toys?

cmm cmm
I will post one for females as well.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
1.25 inches
1  (3%)
1.5 inches
14  (42%)
1.75 inches
3  (9%)
2 inches
1  (3%)
2.25 inches
1  (3%)
2.5 inches
7  (21%)
2.75 inches
3 inches
3  (9%)
> 3 inches
3  (9%)
Total votes: 33
Poll is closed
08/24/2013
  • Weekly Special; Buy 1 Vibe, get 1 FREE
  • Save 15% on Luxury Brands
  • Annual Clearance - Save 30%
  • Buy Cascade vibe and save 50% on lubricants!
  • Save 20% on self-lubricating Cascade vibe and sleeve kit
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
SecretKinksters SecretKinksters
Right now he can take 1.75", but his goal is 2.25"... It will take some practice, but it will be fun trying to get him there.
08/25/2013
C&K0143 C&K0143
Does my wife’s hand count as a toy? - C
08/25/2013
RonLee RonLee
Quote:
Originally posted by C&K0143
Does my wife’s hand count as a toy? - C
Lucky you!
08/25/2013
cmm cmm
Quote:
Originally posted by SecretKinksters
Right now he can take 1.75", but his goal is 2.25"... It will take some practice, but it will be fun trying to get him there.
1.75" is my max right now. I think I should bump back down to a 1.5" dilator.
08/26/2013
misioooo misioooo
Quote:
Originally posted by cmm
I will post one for females as well.
I think it would be 1,5... for now...
08/26/2013
DashO'Roark DashO'Roark
Depends on the toy. For plugs; say toy's 6" or less in length, 3 to 3.5 inches is great as long as they have a tapered tip. I prefer depth play though and right now my favorite dildo measures 2.6" at the tip.
08/26/2013
Genderfree Genderfree
2.5 period. Have not been able to get bigger than that.
08/27/2013
cmm cmm
Quote:
Originally posted by DashO'Roark
Depends on the toy. For plugs; say toy's 6" or less in length, 3 to 3.5 inches is great as long as they have a tapered tip. I prefer depth play though and right now my favorite dildo measures 2.6" at the tip.
Would love to get that kind of diameter one day!
08/27/2013
babyrock babyrock
wow, some of these numbers are impressive!
09/04/2013
Oriental husband and wife Oriental husband and wife
Two inches and no plans to go any wider.
09/04/2013
UsArmyGuy UsArmyGuy
I've tried 1.75 and that hurt like a bugger, so I try to keep it at 1 1/2.

I don't see how anyone could take a 3" or bigger....
09/15/2013
Life's Little Secrets Life's Little Secrets
Wow some of these number are crazy! Right now for me it's only 1.5" but I would like to increase to 2" eventually.
09/16/2013
Two Grand Two Grand
Usually 1 1/4" sometimes I'll go up to 1 1/2" not interested in going larger now maybe one day I will try something bigger.
09/16/2013
Chou Wang Chou Wang
Quote:
Originally posted by cmm
I will post one for females as well.
I just love the John Holmes UR3 but really need to have at least a heavy sex/pegging session before I can really enjoy it. Most of the time solo since she is having a hard time to control this huge thing properly
09/25/2013
cmm cmm
Quote:
Originally posted by Chou Wang
I just love the John Holmes UR3 but really need to have at least a heavy sex/pegging session before I can really enjoy it. Most of the time solo since she is having a hard time to control this huge thing properly ... More
Holy Shit that is huge!
09/25/2013
Dreaus Dreaus
My Doc Johnson ace of spades is my regular toy. It's 3.0. But I have been playing with the Doc Johnson Ass Servant for a few months now and it's not a problem going in. It's 3.75
10/02/2013
Genderfree Genderfree
Quote:
Originally posted by Chou Wang
I just love the John Holmes UR3 but really need to have at least a heavy sex/pegging session before I can really enjoy it. Most of the time solo since she is having a hard time to control this huge thing properly ... More
That must be a lot of fun!!
10/02/2013
HappyInNJ HappyInNJ
I would have to say nothing more than an average size penis.
10/24/2013
xkellx xkellx
Quote:
Originally posted by cmm
I will post one for females as well.
well I can fit my Remote Rick, so about 3 inches.
11/13/2013
RonLee RonLee
I have attempted my Tantus A-Bomb again and again, I just cannot do it. That toy has to be bigger than its published dimensions.
12/06/2013
Yellow Dog Yellow Dog
I can't do any thrusting with anything bigger than about 1.5 inches.
12/07/2013
aspiration aspiration
Did 3.25 once after a long session, but it was still very uncomfortable. I think I top out at about 3 inches for enjoyment.

It may seem impressive, but being a size queen can get pretty expensive pretty fast. Especially if you want quality toys.
12/11/2013
Total posts: 23
Unique posters: 18