Ummm yes I have also seen some odd things go in and come out from anal play that have shocked me a bit. Although on the other hand its only strange untill you attempted it yourself. Hmmm lets see I'v had toes, flogger handles, golf balls and I have nearly had a soda can inserted in me analy it never made it but yeah.
When I was in high school, applying to schools and studying for the SATs were rather stressful experience. I would always end up masturbating. I remember inserting smooth end of pens I was writing with into my ass. That was me, experimenting.
Food, phallic shaped food, smooth wooden handle from a ball in the cup toy (very phallic shaped), hairbrush with condom, tooth brush cover (about 7 inches phallic shaped), small sample shampoo bottles, sharpie, tooth brush handle, other random things
The first time I ever put anything up my butt I was 13 I think. I had an old curling iron that I removed from the electrical part, removed the clamp portion and scrubbed it up. It was a little cold at first, but it was smooth and smaller and didn't hurt.
Woohoo, Three Word Phrase comic! When I was first just entertaining the idea of anal stimulation, I shoved the following up my butt:
-Thick Sharpie marker
-Smooth handle end of a screwdriver (I know, AHHH!)
-Butt end of vibrating razor without the razor attached
I also used aloe goop as lube a couple times back in the day. What a depraved soul I was/am! Actually, I'm lucky I didn't ever hurt myself...
this is probably one of the stupidest, lol. When I was like 12 I tried to tie string around a (tightly closed) nail polish bottle and stuck it up there. The string of course fell off. Fortunately I was able to push the bottle out. One of the stupidest things I've ever done!