What's a good starting plug?

Collection of related topics on Butt plugs:

Which butt plug tail and ears would look the sexist with a french maid costume?
The purpose of this poll is to get an overall opinion of combining which tail and ears with a french maid to get the sexist outcome. Please feel free.

anal plug/advice for a couple who has little anal experience
Over the past year me and my girlfriend have gone from analingus to fingers to small anal vibe. Just the other night she asked me to use her Lelo Liv...

Scared of the butt plug.
Ok, so I bought a butt plug from Eden and when it arrived my eyes, just about popped outta my head. It's HUGE! I prolli should have gotten the junior,

Juicing your butt?
link This looks like a curious toy to use for anal. Anyone have comments or experiences to share? I know juicers are mostly for women and vaginal...

Total size of Pure Plug Large
I was looking at the Pure Plug Large, and noticed that there's no 1:1, nor is there any measurements for the neck. What's the top/bottom diamter of...

I would go with The Bootie for a first one maybe.

The Fun Factory Bootie is a good suggestion. The silicone beginner's kit has some nice variety to it. There's also the Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small to consider.

Bootie!