What do you do with anal toys you've outgrown?

ChrisD ChrisD
As I become more experienced in anal play and purchase more advanced toys, I've noticed that most of my beginner and intermediate toys are collecting dust. Part of me says to throw them out, but the other part says I'll end up regretting that. I assume other people have been in this situation. What have you all done?
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
7
20
10
1
5
Total votes: 43 (37 voters)
Poll is open
Jan 24, 1:42 am
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 70%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • Better Price - Save 40%
  • Try a luxury harness with a dildo and save 45% on a kit!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
dv8 dv8
Regularly practice muscle control with the smaller toys. Using only larger "advanced" toys is a bad idea.
Jan 24, 8:41 pm
Bignuf Bignuf
Quote:
Originally posted by ChrisD
As I become more experienced in anal play and purchase more advanced toys, I've noticed that most of my beginner and intermediate toys are collecting dust. Part of me says to throw them out, but the other part says I'll end up regretting ... More
I only use smaller toys, despite being an "advanced" user. However, there are many toys I grow tired of, or don't like the feel of, and they just get piled in a drawer, or closet and forgotten. Until I purged my "Jelly" toys a few years ago, I had never tossed a toy that wasn't broken or physically ruined, but I think I really do need to do some serious housecleaning in the "toy" department.
Jan 24, 9:18 pm
PadoruLover PadoruLover
The ones you don't like I say get ride of but the ones your ore with you never know when you might want to try them again.
Jan 25, 6:56 pm
Two Grand Two Grand
I've tried to give them away but nobody wants them so most times I just toss them out. I only keep the expensive ones.
Jan 27, 1:35 pm
edeneve edeneve
I don't want a used anal toy. sounds so gross.
Jan 28, 3:24 pm
dv8 dv8
Quote:
Originally posted by edeneve
I don't want a used anal toy. sounds so gross.
Would you use a used vaginal toy?
Jan 29, 3:57 am
SaucyxGirl SaucyxGirl
I keep them I tend to to still use them on occasion and would kick myself if I found myself wanting to experience them again and had gotten rid of them. I do keep them stored separate from the ones I use more on a regular basis though.
Jan 31, 1:13 pm
MaeGal MaeGal
I would probably keep them just as part of my collection of sorts. Might want them again some day, who knows.
Feb 20, 12:50 am
Dairygirl8808 Dairygirl8808
Quote:
Originally posted by ChrisD
As I become more experienced in anal play and purchase more advanced toys, I've noticed that most of my beginner and intermediate toys are collecting dust. Part of me says to throw them out, but the other part says I'll end up regretting ... More
Honestly I don't think toys should ever have more than one owner ever just because they're used so personally.
Feb 20, 9:33 pm
epiphanyjayne epiphanyjayne
Selling them has never been an option in my mind. maybe a close friend and the toys are boilable. but still I don't see my closest friend wanting one of my used anal toys . I personally keep them in my collection and you never know you might use them again.
Mar 13, 3:58 pm
Rossie Rossie
If it's something I won't use again -- I'd throw it out.
Mar 30, 7:11 pm
Fantasy Restraints Fantasy Restraints
Quote:
Originally posted by ChrisD
As I become more experienced in anal play and purchase more advanced toys, I've noticed that most of my beginner and intermediate toys are collecting dust. Part of me says to throw them out, but the other part says I'll end up regretting ... More
Over time some toys are replaced with newer ones. We play with them all allowing time for shrinkage to play with the smaller ones. They are great to wear for extended periods for all day play.
Apr 17, 3:17 pm
Boyqueen Boyqueen
Keep them for the time being. You never know when you want to go back and try things that felt nice before.
Jun 16, 1:41 am
Oriental husband and wife Oriental husband and wife
I threw out the ones that definitely did not work out. Did get some just too too large. Guess my eyes were bigger than my .... LOL. I've kept my beginners ones. I'm glad I did. Every now and then in the mood to use them. Also who knows, maybe one day my wife may want to try them.

Share and share alike.
Jun 16, 10:34 pm
icyqueen icyqueen
I would keep them. Maybe you want to use the toys again someday.
Jun 26, 4:49 am
dv8 dv8
Quote:
Originally posted by Oriental husband and wife
I threw out the ones that definitely did not work out. Did get some just too too large. Guess my eyes were bigger than my .... LOL. I've kept my beginners ones. I'm glad I did. Every now and then in the mood to use them. Also who knows, ... More
Which ones were too too large?
Jun 26, 7:27 am
Oriental husband and wife Oriental husband and wife
Quote:
Originally posted by dv8
Which ones were too too large?
It was a "Thu Hole Large". Not carried on Eden. Tried multiple times til gave up. I still have the medium. Good for letting gas out. Don't like the non tapered neck though.
Jun 26, 12:46 pm
toysforall toysforall
For some reason I have an issue getting rid of old toys. I typically just keep them, I've grown quite a collection!!!
Yesterday, 9:51 pm
Total posts: 19
Unique posters: 16