What's The Best First Anal Toy?

  • Save 15% sitewide — code: THRILL15

What's The Best First Anal Toy?

Madeira Madeira 08/01/2011

I'd really like to try anal, but I want something easy to try with first... so basically I want to know what's a good beginning anal toy?

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

Madeira Madeira
All I've ever had up there was a finger once years ago, I feel I'm ready to try again. What would you suggest?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Gunsmoke , MeliPixie , Brandonn
switzerland , Kitt Katt , plaidvulva , animepanda89
daveysgirl , mandaj , Anne
Dawn (Lilac Distraction) , ily , alliegator , ThoughtsAblaze , tooshy , Sweet-Justice , Kitka , punkstar283 , ColorMeCute , eeep , fuzzypeaches , Llewey , thesquaredeific , SaiDiscordia , unfulfilled , panthercat23
sarki , Miss Nessa , Kitka , Highmaintenancegirl916 , Mikemanz
PassionateLover2 , MeliPixie
klyte , Modern^Spank^Anthem , True Pleasures , thesquaredeific
MaryExy , Kindred , systematicweasel , ToyBoy , Lio , dv8 , ZenaidaMacroura , Waterfall , alliegator , dawnkye , ToyTimeTim , potstickers , Steve of Eden , Ms. Spice , jay28 , Elnoa , Alan & Michele , bayosgirl , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Andersonda , disenchanted , zracer , AvgJon , The Curious Couple , boobookittyfuk , Eucaly , Howells , kissyspanx , fleshlightluvr1 , NarcissisticLust , Bignuf , Powder , holypoison , sktb0007 , LM , Stagger13 , DreamWolf , Ninja Wolf , lalapetitee , mastersonv , klyte , mandaj , IndridCold , punkstar283 , ToyBox , Eva Schwaltz , ColorMeCute , markwashere , dhig , Love Perpetua , Flash777 , Badass , levellc09 , AJvil , fuzzypeaches , Nazaress , Apirka , Highmaintenancegirl916 , Misfit Momma , Iron Man , Kitt Katt , Diabolical Kitty , elli , kittychilla , LavenderSkies , Raizer911 , Lano4ka , Jon S , SecretKinksters , pfoof , GONE! , roskat , Lioncub , ToyGeek , ginainohio
Total votes: 113 (102 voters)
Poll is open
  • Black Friday Sale! Save 80% on select items
  • Black Friday Sale! Save 50% on select items
  • Black Friday Sale! Save 40% on select items
  • Black Friday Sale! Save 30% on select items
  • Black Friday Sale! Save 25% on select items
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Kindred Kindred
I would rule out the glass items for a beginner. Stick to softer materials such as silicone until you are more comfortable with anal.
Liz2 Liz2
I would suggest the NJoy Pure plugs, med and try wearing it around for awhile.
ToyBoy ToyBoy
I agree with kindred in that softer materials are best for beginners, so I would get a silicone toy. The bootie and lil end look like the best options for you.
Miss Nessa Miss Nessa
I would have to say butt hungry! I think it looks the thinest, and the lest scary.
Waterfall Waterfall
As others have mentioned, I would not suggest glass for a first time anal toy because it is very firm. The Bootie is a good size and material for a beginner toy.
MaryExy MaryExy
The bases of the L'amour and the Hopper look a little too small with too short of a stem area in between; they make me paranoid. The Bootie has the most ergonomic shape to me... I love mine.

Oh, and the Ass-berries and Butt Hungry don't look like they'd stay in very well if you want to wear them as plugs. The Ass-berries also gives me the same paranoia about slipping in as the L'amour and the Hopper.
dawnkye dawnkye
I went with the Tantus Ryder, but during the course of my long search process for just the right first toy, I heard great great things about the Bootie.
Ms. Spice Ms. Spice
the bootie. it's very cute and non intimidating. i really am growing to love mine
bayosgirl bayosgirl
I own the Lil End and while it is a good size for beginners, it does NOT stay in. That being said, the Bootie is a similar size (if not a tad smaller) and I've only heard good things about it.
Beck Beck
Ass-berries Raspberry, I have had my eye on this one.
AvgJon AvgJon
Bootie! Excellent for beginners!

Rossie Rossie
Originally posted by Liz2
I would suggest the NJoy Pure plugs, med and try wearing it around for awhile.
Totally agreed with Liz2. The Njoy Pure Plug medium link might be the only anal toy you'll ever need.
Eucaly Eucaly
The Bootie looks very much like the right size and features.
daveysgirl daveysgirl
Icicles No. 13 looks like fun
Bignuf Bignuf
Originally posted by Madeira
All I've ever had up there was a finger once years ago, I feel I'm ready to try again. What would you suggest?
My STRONG suggestion is not listed here. It is the KEY TO YOUR BUTT sold on EF.
Trillian Trillian
A sharpie for me
ajwonder ajwonder
hmmm I am now interested in the bootie...
PassionateLover2 PassionateLover2
I found glass great! My first was with the Luxotiq anal plug (Blue) or (pink). The Bootie may have too large of head to allow your sphincters mussels to relax.
Kitka Kitka
The Lil' End or Butt Hungry seem small enough and safe enough for a beginner to use.
MeliPixie MeliPixie
Now personally I'm a huge advocate of glass for a beginner because that's what we started with. Something very narrow with a nice big base and not too much texture. I DO NOT, however, recommend the Icicles No. 13 for a beginner! It may not look like it, but that bulb is huge, and even as a knowledgeable player I can barely get it in without pain.
Eva Schwaltz Eva Schwaltz
The Bootie looks like a good choice, but personally I'm saving up for one of the Pure Plugs.
markwashere markwashere
The lil end doesnt stay in, and hmmmn, like i think using some fingers (with latex gloves on) will give you the same effect but the bootie looks small and good for a beginner.
Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
I think the Bootie is a great choice.
levellc09 levellc09
I skipped toys all together until I was comfortable with taking 2-3 fingers. My first anal toys were the Joe Rock and anal t black. I just didn't want to buy something small then want something bigger soon after.
Highmaintenancegirl916 Highmaintenancegirl916
the bootie one.
Modern^Spank^Anthem Modern^Spank^Anthem
I'd go with a slimmer one
Misfit Momma Misfit Momma
Bootie is awesome for beginners! It's one of my favorites for starting with or for long term use.
Kitt Katt Kitt Katt
The bootie looks nice
Diabolical Kitty Diabolical Kitty
Lano4ka Lano4ka
Bootie, it's so cute too
Brandonn Brandonn
Take note: the Sasha Grey plugs all run one size larger. In generality to other toy sizes. Example: the SG small plug is closer to a medium size standard plug.
plaidvulva plaidvulva
For your first, I'd aim cheap, honestly. L'amour looks good for it's price.

Although, if price doesn't matter, Bootie DOES look nice.
thesquaredeific thesquaredeific
Elements Pi seems really good, though pricey.
aluminummm aluminummm
So glad I read this thread.
roskat roskat
The Bootie or one of the newer Mood silicone plugs.
SaiDiscordia SaiDiscordia
Lil End and Butt Hungry look like good beginners. I wrote a review on on that would be perfect for beginners. It is by Doc Johnson and called the Slim Jr. Butt Plug. It is firm with a little give, has a good base, and is nice and slim.
animepanda89 animepanda89
Mikemanz Mikemanz
kind of a funny name, but i've heard good things about the butt hungry
unfulfilled unfulfilled
little end for me.
ToyGeek ToyGeek
Small, soft, flexible silicone with a secure base would be the sensible choice. I'm not sorry I started with glass, though, it had good results.
panthercat23 panthercat23
The little end I think.
ginainohio ginainohio
Total posts: 43
Unique posters: 43