Dildo Comparison

Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
How does a 2.5 in diameter anal plug compare to a 2.5 diameter dildo? Is it easier or harder to insert anally? Do dildos feel better than plugs? I have never actually used a dildo except for one that was 1.75 in diameter.
06/12/2010
  • Weekly Special; Buy 1 Vibe, get 1 FREE
  • Save 15% on Luxury Brands
  • Annual Clearance - Save 30%
  • Buy Cascade vibe and save 50% on lubricants!
  • Save 20% on self-lubricating Cascade vibe and sleeve kit
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
VieuxCarre VieuxCarre
Quote:
Originally posted by Uncommon Pleasures
How does a 2.5 in diameter anal plug compare to a 2.5 diameter dildo? Is it easier or harder to insert anally? Do dildos feel better than plugs? I have never actually used a dildo except for one that was 1.75 in diameter.
If you're not experienced with anal, anything is going to fell larger and be harder to insert. Start small if you're not used to it with anal beads and such. That's a safer and smarter way to go about it.
06/12/2010
Red Red
Quote:
Originally posted by Uncommon Pleasures
How does a 2.5 in diameter anal plug compare to a 2.5 diameter dildo? Is it easier or harder to insert anally? Do dildos feel better than plugs? I have never actually used a dildo except for one that was 1.75 in diameter.
A jump from 1.75 to 2.5? At best, you won't be able to get the toy in; at worst, you'll tear your sphincter. Perhaps there is more to this than you said, I dunno. 2.5 inches in diameter means you should be able to take a whole hand (or close to it) - can you? .

Best to make stops at something like 2" and 2.25" along the way. Go slow and enjoy the ride. 2.5" won't happen without good warm up anyways, so you might as well stock up on toys that can help you along and will work as warm up toys later, if this is a 'goal' of sorts. The Tantus Cowboy will get you there gradually, and for large plug, I recommend the Tantus A Bomb. Note, the A Bomb is not even at 2.5", but I can pretty much promise you'll find it stimulating, challenging and satisfying.

Enjoy!
06/13/2010
Jimbo Jones Jimbo Jones
Quote:
Originally posted by Uncommon Pleasures
How does a 2.5 in diameter anal plug compare to a 2.5 diameter dildo? Is it easier or harder to insert anally? Do dildos feel better than plugs? I have never actually used a dildo except for one that was 1.75 in diameter.
I think that large plugs are a little more comfortable to use anally than large dildos because with plugs you usually get a smaller diameter to rest on after getting the largest diameter of the toy. With dildos, that often isn't the case as they are meant more for thrusting than wearing.
06/13/2010
El-Jaro El-Jaro
Yeah, I agree with Jimbo.

Plugs are more for plugging a hole and leaving it there. A dildo or a probe is meant to go in and out. Sometimes you have a crossover, but not too often.
06/13/2010
Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
Quote:
Originally posted by Red
A jump from 1.75 to 2.5? At best, you won't be able to get the toy in; at worst, you'll tear your sphincter. Perhaps there is more to this than you said, I dunno. 2.5 inches in diameter means you should be able to take a whole hand (or ... More
Yes I can take a fist in my butt. And I can take triple ripple royal no problem. Just wondering what people think about the difference.
06/14/2010
Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
I have a lot of anal experience but just not with toys really. haha. lots of home made toys. shampoo bottles and coke cans and candle holder. In the past few years i have gotten triple ripple royal, rear enders pleasure tree, classic butt plug royal and a couple others. just curious about dildos.
06/14/2010
Red Red
Quote:
Originally posted by Uncommon Pleasures
I have a lot of anal experience but just not with toys really. haha. lots of home made toys. shampoo bottles and coke cans and candle holder. In the past few years i have gotten triple ripple royal, rear enders pleasure tree, classic butt plug royal ... More
well then, its kinda like a passive versus active butt play thing, then (to me anyways). You could be different. I would imagine you'd find a large dildo to be similar to shampoo bottles, but who knows. Let us know what you find out.
06/14/2010
harohunter harohunter
I prefer dildos anally, They are harder to insert but i love being filled with length and being able to move it in and out and not have to go slow. They are much more fun to me.

What dildo were you going to get? Im waitin gfor the Cyberskin Extreme to come in stock its a 2.5in diameter. The only other 2.5in is John Holmes.
06/25/2010
harohunter harohunter
I ordered the Cyber Skin Extreme Cock from another website because i couldnt wait. Then an hour later it comes back in stock on EF! doh.
06/25/2010
Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
Quote:
Originally posted by harohunter
I ordered the Cyber Skin Extreme Cock from another website because i couldnt wait. Then an hour later it comes back in stock on EF! doh.
how is the new toy you got? I am looking at getting the rascal this time round but dont know if I should go big or go home??
11/02/2010
Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
thanks for all of the help. sorry i have not replied. I have been slammed with work and have hardly had time to slam myself with any toys.
11/02/2010
ScottA ScottA
EF doesn't have them, but you might want to look around for some of the Vamp Silicone toys. It looks like they go up to 3".
11/02/2010
Vexed Vexed
I have both the Cyberskin Extreme Cock, and the Cyberskin Gonzo Cock (nice that it doesn't have balls).

I have my eye on the thicker dildos from Vamp Silicone also. They have a nice pronounced head, and a base that's very suitable for strapon use.
11/03/2010
ScottA ScottA
Large Talula Softskin looks just about right for me.
11/03/2010
Uncommon Pleasures Uncommon Pleasures
i just got the natural dildo with balls yesterday so ill let you know how i take the dildo at 2 1/8 diameter. wish me luck
11/07/2010
yayy yayy
Quote:
Originally posted by harohunter
I prefer dildos anally, They are harder to insert but i love being filled with length and being able to move it in and out and not have to go slow. They are much more fun to me.

What dildo were you going to get? Im waitin gfor the Cyberskin ... More
lovee it
12/30/2010
Shellz31 Shellz31
I personally prefer dildos than anal plugs. They feel more natural.
Plus, I like the thrusting action which isn't easy with some plugs. The only plug I have owned had the bulge before the thinner stem so when it was left in my ass and I relaxed, it actually hurt to get that bulge back out.

I have looked at getting another plug but one that is a little more even. But personally, I haven't bothered cause my dildos give me the desired effect at this stage.
12/30/2010
ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by Shellz31
I personally prefer dildos than anal plugs. They feel more natural.
Plus, I like the thrusting action which isn't easy with some plugs. The only plug I have owned had the bulge before the thinner stem so when it was left in my ass and I ... More
Dildos also hit bits deep inside that most plugs miss. You do have to take longer to get ready to go with dildos, I find. Whereas plugs is mostly opening up your anus enough, with dildos you need to open up your anus and then relax inside and get everything lined up so you can thrust comfortably. Do keep in mind that this isn't as much trouble as it sounds - I usually slowly open up around the dildo and slowly slide it in with mini-thrusts, sometimes bearing down to get everything lined up. Let it sit for a few minutes so your body gets used to it and then go ahead.
12/30/2010
Total posts: 19
Unique posters: 10