Ella or Sugar Drop?

Tori Rebel Tori Rebel
I like the similar shape of both of these, and the ratings aren't too far off nor are the dimensions (the Sugar drop is a bit larger). If anyone has tried both, can you recommend one over the other?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Ella
Alegria , LicentiouslyYours , Kayla , cherryredhead88 , Envy , Waterfall , onehotmomma , jreed24 , ToyGeek , Lady Venus , tits only , J's Alley , ReadyAllTheTime , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , Sera , Avalee , Sebmissive , Stujen , purplecandles , moonlitlilly , princesspassion , cherryblossoms , fairykisses , glitterhugs , loveshocks , celibacysucks , menotu , dv8 , MasterBlaster , Nightcrawler , Miss Morphine , C4ss , potstickers , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , SerenityRed , SexyTabby , LavenderSkies , Miss T , Wild Orchid , kittychilla , Stagger13 , cburger , Xiel , toxie m , mariedoll , EndlessFrost , ichwillwaffels , Lithaewyn , Mason , zracer , Willis2011 , zeebot , Love Perpetua , sktb0007 , AshMegYo , jessi2 , FemmeFlo , pleasurehunter , succulenthunny616 , vampyroteuthidae , The Mother of a SiNner , Howells , svalentine;) , BoobCopter
64  (91%)
Sugar Drop
Carrie Ann , SydVicious , Gunsmoke
3  (4%)
Neither? Both? Other???
Heartthrob , Sweet-Justice , streetshark182
3  (4%)
Total votes: 70
Poll is closed
09/24/2010
  • Get 3 amazing toys for $60 only
  • Black Friday Cyber Monday 70% Clearance
  • Black Friday Cyber Monday 50% Clearance
  • Black Friday Cyber Monday 40% Clearance
  • Black Friday Cyber Monday 25% Clearance
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Tori Rebel Tori Rebel
And I would've used the comparative discussion form but it's just such a simple question
09/24/2010
Alegria Alegria
I read a review (can't even remember where) that suggested the flat head on the Sugar Drop was too thick and the edges on it were too harsh to be able to use comfortably.

Then again, it does come in some amazing(!) colors =)
09/24/2010
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
The dimensions are actually a lot different than they appear, Ella is a LOT smaller. There's a video of both, if you can watch it, that shows.

Personally, I like the Sugar Drop better - though I do not use the flat handle as a head. Ella catches on my pubic bone a lot and is a bit small to me.
09/24/2010
LicentiouslyYours LicentiouslyYours
I voted Ella, but to be fair, I don't have a Sugar Drop to compare the two.

I do absolutely love Ella tho. Far more than I expected to.
09/24/2010
Kayla Kayla
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
The dimensions are actually a lot different than they appear, Ella is a LOT smaller. There's a video of both, if you can watch it, that shows.

Personally, I like the Sugar Drop better - though I do not use the flat handle as a head. Ella ... More
I'm with CA. I bought the Sugar Drop, and it's like "HOLY SHIT. It's a monster!" It's so much bigger than the dimensions make it look. Even CA's video doesn't portray it nearly as much as it really is.

I like the Ella tons more. The Sugar Drop is definitely more for those that like larger-diameter toys which I don't. Plus, the Ella was made for g-spot stimulation while the Sugar Drop was made as a dildo with an odd handle.

As for what I'd recommend over both, it's easily the Bent Graduate. That's my favorite g-spot toy by far.
09/24/2010
cherryredhead88 cherryredhead88
sorry... i have only tried ella but i still voted because I love her! IMO if you want size then SD would be the way to go, but Ella is just so lavishing!
09/25/2010
Tori Rebel Tori Rebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
The dimensions are actually a lot different than they appear, Ella is a LOT smaller. There's a video of both, if you can watch it, that shows.

Personally, I like the Sugar Drop better - though I do not use the flat handle as a head. Ella ... More
I'm definitely afraid if the catching on the pubic bone...I do not like that feeling.
09/25/2010
Tori Rebel Tori Rebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Kayla
I'm with CA. I bought the Sugar Drop, and it's like "HOLY SHIT. It's a monster!" It's so much bigger than the dimensions make it look. Even CA's video doesn't portray it nearly as much as it really is.

I like ... More
The Bent Graduate is supposed to be amazing but I need a bit of flex in my g-spot toys which is why I'm looking at silicone...I have some glass ones and while a few work, I mainly just end up bruising myself
09/25/2010
Kayla Kayla
Quote:
Originally posted by Tori Rebel
The Bent Graduate is supposed to be amazing but I need a bit of flex in my g-spot toys which is why I'm looking at silicone...I have some glass ones and while a few work, I mainly just end up bruising myself
I'd go with Ella more. It has more happy g-spot "I Swear by this" users.
09/25/2010
Envy Envy
I have an Ella and can only say for that. However, remember, the Sugar Drop is not double ended.

(I want a SD too, in green, it looks lovely and I have no green toys.)
09/25/2010
onehotmomma onehotmomma
I voted Ella because I love it! I had considered the Sugar Drop however, and I there was a reason I didn't get it, but for the life of me I don't remember why. It must've been something I read in a review that turned me off about it.
09/26/2010
Selective Sensualist Selective Sensualist
Well, I'm not voting because I don't have the Sugar Drop. I have the Ella and I love it!

My best silicone G-spotter is the Ophoria Beyond No. 3 though. I had to file down the seam on it because I am so sensitive, but none of my other silicone toys work quite as well as that one does -- and I have some great silicone G-spotters. (Too bad you don't like hard materials because I can recommend some amazing glass, metal, and wooden G-spotters!).

The Jollies Thrust is a good silicone G-spotter, too. For a vibrating silicone G-spotter, the Fun Factory Delight is wonderful, as is the Je Joue G-Ki.

I haven't tried the Luxotiq silicone Isis, but it is on my Wish List. It looks like an amazing G-spotter!
09/26/2010
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
I just realized I have pictures of the two side by side, figured I'd share.



09/27/2010
Alegria Alegria
Holy cow they are wayyyy different in size than I thought! Thanks for the pics Carrie Ann.
09/27/2010
mllebeauty mllebeauty
Quote:
Originally posted by Alegria
Holy cow they are wayyyy different in size than I thought! Thanks for the pics Carrie Ann.
Wow! That is definitely a difference. The pics really help. Thank you!
09/27/2010
ToyGeek ToyGeek
I have the Ella and I really like it. I've never had any trouble with it catching, as it does have some give to it. I'm always more careful with the Gigi for that reason, as it's the same shape, but firm.
09/27/2010
Tori Rebel Tori Rebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
I just realized I have pictures of the two side by side, figured I'd share.



HO. LY. COW.

Well that definitely shows the difference! Thanks so much Carrie Ann!!!!!
09/27/2010
ZenaidaMacroura ZenaidaMacroura
I don't have either of these. I want one.
10/30/2010
buzzvibe buzzvibe
Thank you for posting the photos, that really helps! Of course, I still want both.
11/22/2010
menotu menotu
Quote:
Originally posted by Tori Rebel
I like the similar shape of both of these, and the ratings aren't too far off nor are the dimensions (the Sugar drop is a bit larger). If anyone has tried both, can you recommend one over the other?
ella
11/22/2010
Miss Morphine Miss Morphine
I have to go with the ella on this one; the sugar drop was a bit uncomfortably large.
12/07/2010
Herp Herp
Ella definitely.
02/09/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
The Ella's too small. We have the Sugar that was made before they put the bumps on it. She likes it but actually prefers the Alumina Flow - similar shape but that nice heavy metal feel.
02/09/2011
LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by Tori Rebel
I like the similar shape of both of these, and the ratings aren't too far off nor are the dimensions (the Sugar drop is a bit larger). If anyone has tried both, can you recommend one over the other?
Ella!
02/09/2011
Sweet-Justice Sweet-Justice
Neither. But only because they are not in MY taste.
03/11/2011
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by Tori Rebel
I like the similar shape of both of these, and the ratings aren't too far off nor are the dimensions (the Sugar drop is a bit larger). If anyone has tried both, can you recommend one over the other?
Id prefer the ella
04/22/2011
Lithaewyn Lithaewyn
The Ella is great if you're looking for a silicone dildo in this shape. Thanks to Carrie Ann, we can see just how big of a difference there is between it and the Sugar Drop. I'd love to try the Sugar Drop but I think it'd be too big to use comfortably.

My favorite g-spot toy is the Pure Wand, though.
04/22/2011
Willis2011 Willis2011
Ella!
04/22/2011
zeebot zeebot
I haven't tried either, but everything I've heard about ella is fabulous.
04/22/2011
  • 1
  • 2
Total posts: 34
Unique posters: 27