We have Johnny in Vixskin and love him. Personally, I prefer Vixskin's texture to that of regular silicone, which is much firmer. I think (non-Vixskin) Johnny should be about the same firmness as Leo??
I answered "other", because it depends on you
and your personal preferences. If you like your Vixskin Johnny, but wish he were firmer or wish he felt a little bigger, then I'd say it wouldn't be a waste of money at all. But if you prefer the softer texture of Vixskin to the firmer texture of regular silicone, then I'd say buying Johnny in regular silicone would
be a waste of money. I hope that helps!