Ladies if you had to choose between the Vixen Lone Star or Johnny VixSkin which would you choose and why ?

  • Christmas shipping schedule
  • 20% OFF sitewide — Code: ENJOY20

Ladies if you had to choose between the Vixen Lone Star or Johnny VixSkin which would you choose and why ?

Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
For Valentines Day I want to get my wife a large new soft silicone dildo. I've read all the reviews for the Lone Star and Johnny VixSkin dildos - both get 5 stars from most reviewers - so I just can't make up my mind.

Your help is appreciated.
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Vixen Lone Star link
ZenaidaMacroura , Carrie Ann , Miss B Haven , Modern^Spank^Anthem , Xavier7 , CafeSabroso , Shellz31 , toxie m , fleshlightluvr1 , Philia , Dr. Curious , ashboo32
12  (23%)
Johnny VixSkin link
potstickers , Envy , DeliciousSurprise , Elliotstar , sophie2229 , Redboxbaby , VenusianThunder , PussyGalore , pinkcupcakes , NarcissisticLust , Devz , MaryExy , 3d3n1 , ichwillwaffels , Gunsmoke , REDRUM , dv8 , Selective Sensualist , Miss Nessa , LadyDragonfly , rmr34 , EJ , Love Perpetua , Callisto , badk1tty , Rawhide , geliebt , Cookie Monster Mike , The Curious Couple , Diabolical Kitty , ghalik , Apple3192 , Tango8976 , PurplePainter23 , darkr , Arlinnae , leanright69 , thedapperwolf11 , karenm
39  (74%)
The infamous 'Other' - what would you suggest
Alan & Michele , EndlessFrost
2  (4%)
Total votes: 53
Poll is closed
02/01/2011
  • Buy 1 Toy, Get 1 FREE! Mix and Match
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Couples!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Her!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Him!
  • Holiday Clearance – Save 80%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
potstickers potstickers
I have the Mustang and Vixskin is wonderful. Out of these two I'd choose the Johnny only because it's longer. Maybe it's just the pictures, but the Lone Star seems a little too... squat.
02/02/2011
Envy Envy
I don't have either, but the one with the more pronounced curve is what I'd pick.
02/02/2011
DeliciousSurprise DeliciousSurprise
Of those two, the VixSkin.

But I've got a giant lust for an O2 cock, so I'd go to the Adam before either.
02/02/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by DeliciousSurprise
Of those two, the VixSkin.

But I've got a giant lust for an O2 cock, so I'd go to the Adam before either.
Delicious Surprise - thanks for your suggestion. FYI we have the O2 Revolution. It's OK but just a tad too large for regular use. I'm hoping the 1/8 smaller diameter (that's nearly 1/2 smaller in circumference) will make the Lone Star or Johnny more comfortable.
02/02/2011
sophie2229 sophie2229
For everyday Johnny is my favorite. Although I also love the Maverick (but it is massive)
02/02/2011
Redboxbaby Redboxbaby
I don't have either, just by looks I would go with the Johnny. It is more aesthetically pleasing.
02/02/2011
ZenaidaMacroura ZenaidaMacroura
I have the Lone Star, and I'm pretty happy with it. It's not too short, but because it's kind of squishy, I sometimes wish it were just a tad thicker. I loves me a girthy dildo.
02/02/2011
Alan & Michele Alan & Michele
I already have the Johnny and love it, so naturally I'd pick the Lone Star now

We have the O2 Revolution you mentioned too, and I find the VixSkin toy to be more comfortable.
02/02/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Alan & Michele
I already have the Johnny and love it, so naturally I'd pick the Lone Star now

We have the O2 Revolution you mentioned too, and I find the VixSkin toy to be more comfortable.
Alan & Michele:

Thanks for the comparison with the O2 - it's very useful to know.

Would you give up the Johnny in favor of the Lone Star - or keep your Johnny?

You voted 'Other' what did you have in mind?
02/02/2011
Alan & Michele Alan & Michele
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
Alan & Michele:

Thanks for the comparison with the O2 - it's very useful to know.

Would you give up the Johnny in favor of the Lone Star - or keep your Johnny?

You voted 'Other' what did you have in mind?
No, I'd keep Johnny because without being able to try the Lone Star I can't say for sure it would work for me, but I *know* Johnny works for me.

The "Other" would be to consider the new Tantus O2 line, which to me feels better than the original O2 Revolution. I have O2 Mikey and enjoy it as much as Johnny but just in a different way (Johnny is a G-spot gentleman). However, Mikey is on the short side, so I suspect O2 Mark would be better.

Here are a few minor things to consider that might help you a little more with your decision if you wind up pondering between the two VixSkins you mentioned and one of the new O2's though:

1. VixSkin has more of a sticky feeling when it's dry than the new O2 does. It's not a residue or anything, but I have heard a couple people say they disliked the feeling in hand.

2. The O2's have no balls, so she won't be able to ride them as easily as the VixSkins (yep, you can prop those VixSkins and ride 'em). Then again, if ballsy toys creep her out that won't be a plus.

3. VixSkin is more "squishable" on the surface than the O2s. To me, the new O2s were a couple of levels squishier than the O2 Revolution was, but still not quite as much as the VixSkin.

Hope that helps
~~~ Michele
02/03/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Alan & Michele
No, I'd keep Johnny because without being able to try the Lone Star I can't say for sure it would work for me, but I *know* Johnny works for me.

The "Other" would be to consider the new Tantus O2 line, which to me feels ...
Michele - Wow! Thanks for all the info. So far the vote is heavily in favor of Johnny and I'll admit that I like the looks better. My only reservation is that Carry Ann wrote a review claiming the Lone Star as her all time favorite.

I'm kinda hoping she weighs in on the question.

Thanks again!
02/03/2011
PussyGalore PussyGalore
Great thread! I think I'll be getting the Johnny now.
02/03/2011
Miss B Haven Miss B Haven
I picked the Lone Star after making the same consideration with Johnny. I chose LS because I wanted a realistic dildo and I already have a lot of g-spot curved toys. It looks a little short but it is such a nice size in every way. I can't wait to see which you decide to go with
02/03/2011
Modern^Spank^Anthem Modern^Spank^Anthem
both seem pretty fantastic
02/03/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Miss B Haven
I picked the Lone Star after making the same consideration with Johnny. I chose LS because I wanted a realistic dildo and I already have a lot of g-spot curved toys. It looks a little short but it is such a nice size in every way. I can't wait to ...
Miss B Haven - are you planning to review the LS? Has it met your expectations?
02/03/2011
Xavier7 Xavier7
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
For Valentines Day I want to get my wife a large new soft silicone dildo. I've read all the reviews for the Lone Star and Johnny VixSkin dildos - both get 5 stars from most reviewers - so I just can't make up my mind.

Your help is appreciated.
If I was a girl, I'd pick the Vixen Lone Star.
02/03/2011
dv8 dv8
Awww, is the Outlaw out of the question?
02/03/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by dv8
Awww, is the Outlaw out of the question?
No need to spend the extra $30 - my wife can't handle more than about 6.5" to 7" in length and she's rarely in the mood for a full 2" dia. I was looking for something closer to 1.75" - but I can live with 1.875" dia.

BTW - it's out of stock anyway. Thanks for the tip.
02/03/2011
NarcissisticLust NarcissisticLust
I was considering the Johnny VixSkin for quite awhile but have settled on the Maverick instead. However, compared to the Lone Star, I would choose Johnny without a doubt. Aesthetically it is beautiful and the reviews seem more promising. Good luck.
06/09/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by NarcissisticLust
I was considering the Johnny VixSkin for quite awhile but have settled on the Maverick instead. However, compared to the Lone Star, I would choose Johnny without a doubt. Aesthetically it is beautiful and the reviews seem more promising. Good luck.
Thanks - we have the Johnny now and love it.
06/09/2011
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
For Valentines Day I want to get my wife a large new soft silicone dildo. I've read all the reviews for the Lone Star and Johnny VixSkin dildos - both get 5 stars from most reviewers - so I just can't make up my mind.

Your help is appreciated.
I would go for the Johnny Vixskin
06/16/2011
REDRUM REDRUM
I've been lusting after the Johnny Vixskin for awhile. So that is my choice.
06/16/2011
toxie m toxie m
I have the Lone Star and it's absolutely my favourite dildo. Everything about it is just perfect - size, shape, material. If I had to buy it again, I would in a heartbeat.
08/01/2011
Miss Nessa Miss Nessa
Johnny VixSkin
08/06/2011
LadyDragonfly LadyDragonfly
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
For Valentines Day I want to get my wife a large new soft silicone dildo. I've read all the reviews for the Lone Star and Johnny VixSkin dildos - both get 5 stars from most reviewers - so I just can't make up my mind.

Your help is appreciated.
also might i suggest the wonderful rabbit also a great choice
08/07/2011
Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
I like the curve on the Johnny better.
09/03/2011
badk1tty badk1tty
I enjoy the curve of the Johnny a lil more.
09/03/2011
geliebt geliebt
Johnny
11/20/2011
Diabolical Kitty Diabolical Kitty
Johnny!
12/04/2011
  • 1
  • 2
Total posts: 34
Unique posters: 27