Most Realistic Dildo

  • Christmas shipping schedule

Most Realistic Dildo

ButchAndFemme ButchAndFemme 10/10/2010

I'm looking to try out the most realistic dildo out there. I was reading about the Marcos Banderas uncut cyberskin dildo and it says the skin actually moves up and down the shaft. That sounds fun!

Can anyone suggest another dildo that might have that same feature? The three I've listed are the ones that I've heard are the most realistic. Your opinion?

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
ButchAndFemme ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Shellz31 , Ms. Spice , P3ngu1n78 , deltalima , spiced
5
gs61 , Lady Marmelade , potstickers , Judas Iscars , CAKES , Beck , Jon S , P3ngu1n78 , Stinkytofu10 , SilverMinxxx , TrenchcoatHunters , Kitt Katt , SMichelle , Girly Juice , amenti
15
Waterfall , Sir , Selective Sensualist , Yesenia , Envy , Yoda , Alan & Michele , Jobthingy , Owl Identified , SomewhatSomewhere , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , ToyGeek , sasweetheart89 , dv8 , Alegria , billboard , celibacysucks , I'll Miss You EF :( , C4ss , pinkcupcakes , kawigrl , The Awesome Penguin , ds1964 , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Lio , Miss T , liilii080 , SexyStuff , rdytogo , Valentinka , toxie m , leela , Kaltir , qquisi , Lady Marmelade , potstickers , sixfootsex , IndependentlyHappy , Lady Venus , BeautiFullFigured , ellejay , navigator-d , slynch , Solar Ray , zracer , guy4guyz420 , eggiweg , Ladygaga , mystepmotherisafish , Drifter86 , chidoll , Adam02viper , BeautyMonster , miamortis , tickle me pink , jankit , DCorrelle , LanaBean , Lolla Munz , mb , xX Plepsyt Xx , angel142stx , lolsos , Dyma , Anjulie , Howells , k3 , Akira , ichwillwaffels , jjonk , UunicornN , The Curious Couple , jay28 , Donord , Novs , namelesschaos , 3d3n1 , ybe1986 , Jackol , Reyes , AOutrajus , ToyGurl , kelaaa33wish , Elnoa , carenautilus , Miss Nessa , toysforall , mizzmilla , caligaliber , Lucky21 , LuciFaery , sktb0007 , Apirka , Greenleaf , MR Chickhabit , Maxx , fufucat , comatose-kitty , Djiffy , Love Perpetua , vampyroteuthidae , ge0rge , sweetpea12 , godweensatan , Lizzy , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , Lady Bear , GONE! , DreamWolf , Kithara , roskat , A.Mari , LavenderSkies , Bzz , Jlynn123 , Geogeo , Missmarc , Bethy Cassatt , booyahshaka91 , sXeVegan90 , solitudinarian , unfulfilled , TrenchcoatHunters , Kitt Katt , xgamerx , XYCopperheadSly , BlooJay , ghent529 , mpfm , Bignuf , edeneve , BoobCopter , LAndJ , TiffyPixie , maketime , Neurogasm , AriaRN , Stagger13 , squire , sixfootsexxx , AWL , deltalima , Anne , nimbuscloud3 , bh253 , PropertyOfPotter , mbrdr2012 , tortilla , glasskitten , Sima-pusya , Feisty , Gluesnffr , mamaseatspoop , sexxxkitten , J5ive , pixylove101 , blondie , Lildrummrgurl7 , Lioncub , sugar&spikes , SecretKinksters , Wonderstruck , TheProfessors , xOhxSoxScandalousx , Neotigress , BrittaniMaree , malantha , Dr. Curious , ashboo32 , LoneOokami , amenti , sexytileena / absolutely love sex
172
Total votes: 192 (185 voters)
Poll is open
10/10/2010
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Couples!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Her!
  • Save 50% on Gift Set For Him!
  • Save 25% on LELO and PicoBong
  • Holiday Clearance – Save 80%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Waterfall Waterfall
I just got the Vixskin Johnny and I love it! It is squishy with a firm core, so to me it feels pretty realisitc. You can't really move the skin up and down the shaft, but it still feels nice. Also, I think this one feels pretty realistic orally as well!
I assume since the Mustang is made out of the same material that it feels just as real as Johnny, but I haven't tried that one yet.
10/10/2010
Sir Sir
Get Johnny Vixskin. It is worth the money, and it is an excellent prosthetic/dildo.
10/11/2010
Yesenia Yesenia
If I were you I would buy the Johnny Vixskin it's 100% silicone, Perfect length, girth, and very realistic.
10/11/2010
Envy Envy
I vote for the Johnny.
10/11/2010
Yoda Yoda
Johnny is the best dildo I've ever owned. Very lifelike.
10/13/2010
ButchAndFemme ButchAndFemme
Quote:
Originally posted by ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
Thanks for your thoughts everyone... looks like I know what to get for that next purchase. (=
10/13/2010
Jobthingy Jobthingy
I dont have any of them but I hear great things about Johnny!
10/13/2010
Owl Identified Owl Identified
The balls on the Johnny alone are worth the purchase: they are freaking beautiful and very realistic. Go with Johnny but keep in mind it's a VERY, VERY big toy. VERY girthy, so make sure your partner/you are down for the size!
10/14/2010
SomewhatSomewhere SomewhatSomewhere
I love how we all agree on this. I've never used any of them, but I like the look of Johnny... and now it's probably going on my wish list.
10/14/2010
Alegria Alegria
Johnny out of the ones you've picked. But don't forget to check out the new line of Tantus O2 dildos (Mark, Adam, Mikey). They feel so real in use!
10/14/2010
ToyGeek ToyGeek
My vote is based on seeing Johnny in the store, and being a bit creeped out expecting it to move like some sort of disembodied mummy part in a dirty horror movie, but I haven't used it.
10/30/2010
trios trios
We own both the Mustang and Johnny, and the cyberskin cybercock, not the banderas. The Johnny is freakin big in our opinion (my wife and mine), but more realistic overall than the Mustang. The mustang has a bulbous head, which is not as soft and squishy as a real penis head, which is marshmellowy in feel. The Johnny overall is pretty soft and has a soft head, but is not as smooshy as a real head, but more realistic than the mustang. But the mustang is more towards the average size (that is reported)...

Dont know about the other, although the cyberkin cock is softer and the head is the most realistic. My wife actually prefers our cyberskin cybercock over any Vixskin, but that is due to shear size and she prefers the softer feel. Hope that helps.
10/30/2010
Vexed Vexed
I like the way that Johnny looks, compared to those, but I must admit that I'd buy the Tommy Gunn before these because it's girth is 6.5", which FEELS oh so nice!
10/30/2010
SexyySarah SexyySarah
I haven't tried any of these, but my favorite realistic cock is this one link I absolutely love this one and it's so real feeling, it doesn't have the moving skin, but sure feels pretty real.
10/30/2010
ScottA ScottA
Most realistic would probably be Johnny or Goodfella. VixSkin + balls.
10/31/2010
ToyGeek ToyGeek
Quote:
Originally posted by ToyGeek
My vote is based on seeing Johnny in the store, and being a bit creeped out expecting it to move like some sort of disembodied mummy part in a dirty horror movie, but I haven't used it.
Let me add that having now used the Raquel, which does not look realistic at all but which is made of the same material as the Johnny, I'm definitely voting for the Johnny.
01/07/2011
NuMe NuMe
I own the regular Johnny and the Vixskin Mustang. They're both very nice and feel somewhat real. But I have to admit I would like to try the Marcos. I prefer uncut and would like something that has a bit of surface movement.
01/07/2011
*Huxley* *Huxley*
Good to know. Thanks for the post I was curious too!
02/14/2011
toxie m toxie m
I haven't tried any Vixskin yet but it is at the top of my to-get list. I voted Johnny coz it has testicles and I feel that helps with realism, but the Mustang would be great too.
02/14/2011
leela leela
I just got the Johnny and I am *so* impressed with VixSkin. If you want something that's realistic feeling and silicone, definitely get something made from VixSkin. It's really great.
02/15/2011
UnknownGirl UnknownGirl
The Johnny looks pretty good to me.
02/15/2011
IndependentlyHappy IndependentlyHappy
I would go with the Johnny, based on the reviews that I've seen - it's supposed to be really soft and realistic. Definitely go with VixSkin versus cyberskin, though.
02/20/2011
slynch slynch
I would say Johnny from the choices above
02/26/2011
Shellz31 Shellz31
I have both Marcos and Johnny Vixskin.
You can't beat cyberskin for real feeling. Johnny may look real but definitely doesn't feel like human skin. My skin doesn't feel like rubbery vinyl.

I must be about the only person who isn't all that keen on Johnny. I find it somewhat uncomfortable and I hate that lube just won't stay on it properly.

In my opinion, ya simply can't beat the feeling of cyberskin or UR3 if you want truly realistic feeling along with looks.
03/03/2011
guy4guyz420 guy4guyz420
I love realistic dildos.
03/03/2011
miamortis miamortis
i prefer non realistic but go for it
04/03/2011
tickle me pink tickle me pink
I'd go with the Johnny. It looks the most realistic out of the three and VixSkin is a much safer and easier to clean material compared to cyberskin.
04/03/2011
jankit jankit
Johnny all the way! If you treat him gently and care for him right, he will last you a lifetime! Body safe and easy to clean!
04/06/2011
Linga Linga
Exactly how much realism are you looking for size and shape wise?
I searched high and low for a realistically average sized and shaped dildo ( About the size and thickness of a real cock, nothing exaggerated) and I found the Goodfella. It's fantastic
04/08/2011
lolsos lolsos
Johnhy!
05/09/2011
Judas Iscars Judas Iscars
Mustang
05/09/2011
Ms. Spice Ms. Spice
Quote:
Originally posted by ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
i got a thing for uncut boys
05/16/2011
Anjulie Anjulie
JOhnny viskin definitely--it's worth the money!
05/16/2011
hotcoktail hotcoktail
all of them looks fun
05/19/2011
yatinp30 yatinp30
yap true
05/19/2011
tiname25 tiname25
nice post
05/19/2011
johnad45 johnad45
hmm
05/19/2011
Rupom Rupom
  •   (1)
    Spam
05/20/2011
mohima mohima
05/20/2011
ToyBoy ToyBoy
I don't have any, but I want the mustang and have heard great things about johnny
05/27/2011
3d3n1 3d3n1
I had Vixskin Goodfella, which is basically Mustang with less useable length due to the balls... and the material is very nice... I like it better than Cyberskin.

Still, I voted for Johnny since that's one I'd like to try, already knowing I like the Vixskin material.
05/28/2011
Miss Nessa Miss Nessa
I'm gonna go with the Johnny VixSkin. I hear good things about this dildo.
08/28/2011
toysforall toysforall
Go for the Johnny Vixskin. Looks like a nice one.
08/28/2011
mizzmilla mizzmilla
Johnny Vixskin for sureee.
08/28/2011
Greenleaf Greenleaf
Vixskin is a wonderful material, very nice feeling. Johnny *looks* the most realistic, and the balls probably contribute as well. :]
01/22/2012
Maxx Maxx
Quote:
Originally posted by ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
Johnny Johnny Johnny
01/26/2012
Djiffy Djiffy
Johnny looks lovely.
02/25/2012
sweetpea12 sweetpea12
Quote:
Originally posted by ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
Vixskins are supposed to be really really realistic
03/08/2012
Lizzy Lizzy
Vixskin
03/08/2012
Lady Bear Lady Bear
vixskin!!!
03/09/2012
DreamWolf DreamWolf
Johnny VixSkin...
04/05/2012
<3BF <3BF
I've never heard or an uncut dildo before
04/05/2012
ScottA ScottA
I'd go VixSkin. It's more expensive, and doesn't have a "moving foreskin", but it will last forever with proper care and will always be safe and clean.
04/06/2012
SilverMinxxx SilverMinxxx
Mustang
04/12/2012
booyahshaka91 booyahshaka91
johnny vixskin
08/04/2012
unfulfilled unfulfilled
I don't realistic looking ones
08/04/2012
TrenchcoatHunters TrenchcoatHunters
Quote:
Originally posted by ButchAndFemme
I'd like to find out if these three dildos feel and look as real as they say they do. It seems that there aren't enough quality ejaculation dildos on the market just yet, so I'm going for the next best thing- moving skin!
Johnny and Mustang are both great ones. I just got the Mustang and it was well worth it.
08/04/2012
Kitt Katt Kitt Katt
The VixSkin toys are the most realistic toys in my collection.
08/04/2012
BlooJay BlooJay
Johnny VixSkin
08/04/2012
edeneve edeneve
Johnny looks like most realistic but the balls part is what you'll have to hold on to making it less when using it
08/04/2012
LAndJ LAndJ
Johnny's shape and size looks best for me.
08/04/2012
SMichelle SMichelle
I just got the Mustang, and it definitely feels realistic.
08/04/2012
maketime maketime
I want the bandit too.
08/04/2012
Neurogasm Neurogasm
You absolutely cannot go wrong with Vixskin.
08/04/2012
AriaRN AriaRN
I haven't tried any of them but the Johnny looks the most realistic. Once you get one, let us know how you like it!
08/05/2012
choux choux
So, no one knows of one with surface movement? I am also looking for this feature in a dildo! Does it exist?
08/05/2012
squire squire
Love the Mustang, but if you like more size then Johnny is for you. I have that one as well and it's amazing.
08/05/2012
Claire-Bear Claire-Bear
I personally love the mustang, but Johnny looks the most realistic.
08/05/2012
Girly Juice Girly Juice
My Mustang is super real-looking.
08/08/2012
nimbuscloud3 nimbuscloud3
johnny
08/13/2012
bh253 bh253
Go with VixSkin. Safety first!
08/13/2012
Feisty Feisty
Johnny VixSkin
09/05/2012
Sima-pusya Sima-pusya
Johnny VixSkin (Vanilla)
09/06/2012
Gluesnffr Gluesnffr
Johnny VixSkin
09/11/2012
pixylove101 pixylove101
Johnny
09/11/2012
J5ive J5ive
The Johnny VixSkin
09/11/2012
sugar&spikes sugar&spikes
Quote:
Originally posted by J5ive
The Johnny VixSkin
same
09/11/2012
xOhxSoxScandalousx xOhxSoxScandalousx
Johnny vixskin
10/23/2012
BrittaniMaree BrittaniMaree
Johnny VixSkin (Vanilla)
10/23/2012
malantha malantha
I badly want to try something made of vixskin. Get the Johnny!
10/23/2012
amenti amenti
Both the VixSkin ones are perfect, it only matters if you want balls or no balls.
03/09/2013
spiced spiced
At this point, I'd recommend UR3 only if realism is the overriding concern. The Noches latinas cocks are good, but the smell is annoying! Cyberskin was better, but it's gone.

The Johnny and the Mustang are both much better dildos than anything UR3, if you're also concerned about hygiene and durability. Vixskin is somewhat less realistic-looking and -feeling than UR3, but it's plenty realistic for most folks.

Personally I like Vixskin for anything involving penetration and UR3 for oral practice only - but both Mustang and Johnny are both pretty good for oral, too. Mustang's about average size (slightly longer than average) and Johnny's above average in both length and girth. Johnny has "half balls" with a realistic front and a flat base. The balls feel good during pegging.
03/09/2013
sexytileena / absolutely love sex sexytileena / absolutely love sex
Johnny VixSkin (Vanilla)
03/09/2013
Total posts: 84
Unique posters: 81