My most realistic toys are the Fun Factory Curve and the Gold Laced G, so I think it's safe to say I don't have anything realistic at all. My favorites are the Pure Wand and the Jollies Thrust -- I don't think it's possible to get less realistic.
9-10. I have the Silicone Crystal Cote. Real penises however are not clear with a pink center. So to me, the color is the only thing making it non realistic making it a 9 to me. it's a bit short, but hey, a lot are now-a-days