Vixskin vs O2

muffles muffles 12/09/2010

Hi, I'm looking into getting one of these "more realistic" dildos - based off feeling more than looks in importance. Which do you prefer and why?

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
muffles muffles
I'd like to know the differences between these two from your perspective.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
41  (34%)
81  (66%)
Total votes: 122
Poll is open
12/09/2010
  • Add More Pleasure to Your Collection! Buy 1 Vibe, Get 1 FREE
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 70%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • Better Price - Save 40%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Waterfall Waterfall
I dont own the Mustang, but I have the Adam and the Vixskin Johnny. I find that O2 is more firm than Vixskin, by a lot. I find the Johnny to be more realistic, though some say that it is softer than a real penis. I enjoy Vixskin a lot more, even though both are great.
So I would say that if you want something realistic but firmer, then go with Adam, but if you want realsitic but softer go for Vixskin.
Hope that helps and didnt make it more confusing
12/09/2010
Tuesday Tuesday
I don't have either of these toys but I do have Lonestar and the O2 Mikey. Waterfall is right about the firmness difference. Oddly they both feel real. But its easier to climax with an O2 toy just because the extra firmness applies more pressure. So I voted for Adam just for that reason.

The case where you might want to go with the vixskin option is if you're not sure if you can handle that size. Then softer is easier.
12/09/2010
ToyGeek ToyGeek
Check out this video for a comparison of the two materials:

link
12/09/2010
Rockin' Rockin'
I compared the O2 Rascal to the Vixen Lonestar in this video: link

Skip to about 3:10 in the video to see the Rascal and Lonestar side by side. I concur with other posters about Vixskin being softer than the O2 silicone. (I know the Rascal O2 isn't a realistic dildo but it's still the same kind of dual density design.)
12/10/2010
Adriana Ravenlust Adriana Ravenlust
O2 isn't realistic at all, IMO. If that's your goal, go with Vixskin.
12/12/2010
Xavier7 Xavier7
Quote:
Originally posted by muffles
I'd like to know the differences between these two from your perspective.
Definitely the 02 Adam. I've wanted it since it came out.
12/12/2010
ScottA ScottA
In general Vixen's silicone seems to be softer. It's not so soft that it's hard to use, but it is noticeably softer (this extends to the regular silicone as well).
12/12/2010
muffles muffles
Quote:
Originally posted by ToyGeek
Check out this video for a comparison of the two materials:

link
wow, this is a great vid comparison, thanks!
12/14/2010
muffles muffles
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
I dont own the Mustang, but I have the Adam and the Vixskin Johnny. I find that O2 is more firm than Vixskin, by a lot. I find the Johnny to be more realistic, though some say that it is softer than a real penis. I enjoy Vixskin a lot more, even ... More
Haha, a little confusing or - but with your post, tuesday's and the two videos I can grasp a good bit of the differences. I chose those two to compare because I'm not sure if I can fit some of the other ones... yet at least.
I guess I'm leaning towards the vixskin, but might compare one of the bigger ones since they are squishy. I'm not though if I might like the extra pressure - I haven't used too many toys so far so that makes it harder, lol.
Thank you all for your input... now to try and decide for myself which one =)
12/14/2010
Reserved Reserved
I look forward to trying vixskin. I have tried o2 and like it alot. The squishy outer silicone is great.
01/13/2011
kawigrl kawigrl
i like softness so i'd go with vixskin (I have a vixskin but my next toy might be from the o2 line to try it out)
01/19/2011
ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by Reserved
I look forward to trying vixskin. I have tried o2 and like it alot. The squishy outer silicone is great.
The texture on my VixSkin (Maverick) is really nice as well. The lube sticks in it well, but it isn't enough to irritate during use.
01/19/2011
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
I prefer Vixskin, absolutely, but couldn't choose in the poll because both have a predominant ridge around the head and those tend to catch for me and hurt.
02/03/2011
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
I prefer Vixskin, absolutely, but couldn't choose in the poll because both have a predominant ridge around the head and those tend to catch for me and hurt.
Carrie Ann - I have a poll question out there link asking for advice on whether to pick the Lone Star or Johnny Vixen dildos. Your review of the Lone Star is quite emphatic - what do you think of Johnny?
02/03/2011
BadgersRose BadgersRose
Adam looks better to me.
03/12/2011
softcoeur softcoeur
I have the O2 Niagara, Revolution, and Rascal, and the Vixskin Goodfella. I don't know if all the Vixskin finishes are like the Goodfella, but it's more glossy and sticky than the O2. I much prefer the O2 texture and finish.
03/13/2011
CafeSabroso CafeSabroso
In this instance I prefer the look of the Adam. I don't know it just looks a bit more finished and doesn't have the super-prominent ridge where the head meets the shaft (corona?). But I think I prefer the Vixskin material to O2, though I'm basing this off of the O2 of the Rascal, which I've heard is a older version of O2. For this one, I'd say go based on looks...
03/13/2011
muffles muffles
Quote:
Originally posted by softcoeur
I have the O2 Niagara, Revolution, and Rascal, and the Vixskin Goodfella. I don't know if all the Vixskin finishes are like the Goodfella, but it's more glossy and sticky than the O2. I much prefer the O2 texture and finish.
hrm, thanks for the input... I actually got an njoy pure wand in the meantime and saving up my budget for a next "deluxe" purchase

looks like the O2 is probably next, although would be nice to have both I suppose...
03/14/2011
3d3n1 3d3n1
Having owned O2 Mark and Vixskin Goodfella... I voted for Mustang...

As others have mentioned, the O2 is alot firmer, and the inner core is pretty stiff. While O2 Mark is a well made toy, I don't like it for those reasons.

I much prefer the softer outer Vixskin layer of Goodfella and the more flexible inner core.

As far as the head of Goodfella (and Mustang)... it's prominent but so soft that it isn't uncomfortable at all. Actually, the ridge on the Tantus VIP Supersoft, which looks alot less prominent, was actually annoying for me... and the that's the Supersoft (ie. entirely made of the outer layer O2 material).
05/29/2011
kelaaa33wish kelaaa33wish
They both look great so I just went with the one I would choose for myself.
05/30/2011
Anjulie Anjulie
I own both and have to go with the mustang. To me, it just feels more realistic
05/30/2011
CAKES CAKES
I like the mustang better because the head is more defined.
05/30/2011
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by muffles
I'd like to know the differences between these two from your perspective.
Adam for sure.
06/05/2011
Eucaly Eucaly
Quote:
Originally posted by muffles
I'd like to know the differences between these two from your perspective.
I'm just basing my vote on interest rather than experience. I've been interested in O2 dildos for some time.
06/05/2011
Inwitari Inwitari
Mustang, I like the shape better
06/05/2011
NarcissisticLust NarcissisticLust
Everyone I've talked to suggests VixSkin but they both look fantastic.
06/05/2011
krisvida krisvida
O2 Adam
06/06/2011
squire squire
Mustang is my favorite toy right now. I own The johnny, O2 Rascal, and the Niagara...the mustang is just the right shape/curve/length/gir th for my body.
09/06/2011
Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
I love the shape of the O2 Adam, the curve looks like it would be great for G-spotting. Plus, the firmer material would give more pressure. The head looks nice and pronounced.
09/14/2011
Sinfully Sinfully
I really want the mustang.
11/26/2011
Silverdrop Silverdrop
Obviously you need to get both. Where's that option?
01/17/2012
Rawhide Rawhide
I really want both
01/19/2012
Greenleaf Greenleaf
I really, really like O2. It's a little firmer, but passes the feeling/squeeze test better imo.
01/20/2012
BlooJay BlooJay
adam
08/14/2012
Girly Juice Girly Juice
I have both and I lean toward Adam, because O2 is firmer and so it does a better job of hitting my G-spot. But both are wonderful toys.
08/15/2012
crazycouple7281 crazycouple7281
Vixskin.
08/15/2012
ginainohio ginainohio
adam
08/15/2012
ashboo32 ashboo32
vixskin
01/09/2013
Anne Anne
Adam
01/09/2013
comatose-kitty comatose-kitty
Of these 2 I recommend VixSkin, but i want Adam.
01/09/2013
Mr. John Mr. John
Quote:
Originally posted by muffles
I'd like to know the differences between these two from your perspective.
We have most of the Vixskin line, and some of the O2 line. My wife's opinion is that the Vixskin is a more realistic feeling when inside her.
04/11/2013
joiedejouets joiedejouets
I usually prefer Vixskin, but I'm not fond of the Mustang so I would go with the Adam.
04/11/2013
Rawr4483 Rawr4483
O2 Adam
05/23/2013
karenm karenm
The Mustang because I prefer Vixskin toys. O2 toys are too firm for me.
05/28/2013
Total posts: 45
Unique posters: 41