Im curiouse what you surfers like as far as toy matierials go.
Silicone, steel, glass, acrylic. Plastic is okay for vibrators but only hard plastic.
Edited to add: A previous poster made a good point - I love me some silicone toys but my fav lube is silicone-based, so not being able to use it with said toys makes me a sad kitty. Thankfully, I have a water-based back-up for those occasions that works almost as well.
Occasionally I'll enjoy something that is rubber, but it's sort of high maintenance - I like lower-maintenance toys.