I've tried Ky (multiple types of KY, at that. All pretty much horrible), astroglide, one sliquid, JO H20, and Kama Sutra Love Liquid Classic (which I reviewed here
. Sliquid was an improvement but I preferred JO h20. My favorite of them would be the Kama Sutra though.
All of those are fairly accessible and can be bought on this website as well as found in many sex shops, both chains and smaller/local type places. They're very popular brands.
The lube I'm loving now though is a bit more difficult to get and I'm debating whether it's worth the trouble. It's definitely my favorite lube I've ever tried though. It's the water-based by YES lubricants found here
It's organic, hypoallergenic, no sugars or parabens or other funky ingredients, long lasting. Best of all, when the website says it's "realistic lubrication" and a "perfect substitute for the body's natural lubricant," I've found that's entirely true! Especially compared to other lubes I've tried.
I'm one of those people that's easily distracted and even completely turned off by things that don't feel natural. It can be too thick or too clumpy, too slick or thin. Anything that heats cools or tingles is a no go. Smells effect me the same. Even latex. If I get a waft of condom smell during sex, I'm immediately turned off. YES smells faintly of aloe, which doesn't bother me at all though I suppose others may dislike it. It's a very faint scent, anyways. And of course having a good or at least inoffensive taste is strongly preferred. YES tastes about as it smells, very mild and faint but distinctly of aloe. I don't mind this. There hasn't been a single lube I've tried that didn't have a slight taste one way or another and the hint of aloe is probably the most natural and inoffensive of them all. For me, YES wins in every category.
The primary downside is that YES isn't currently sold in the US, and so I've had to order it directly from their website, which brings me to...
EDENFANTASY STAFFERS, if you read this, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE look into carrying YES lubricants. I think they'd be a terrific asset to have on this site.