I've only owned one jelly toy. That thing can just go die.
I bought it from an inferior website a couple of years before discovering EF, and hated it from the moment it arrived - it was too big, smelled bad, and felt all greasy and gross! I didn't know too much about sex toys at the time, and thought that plastic, jelly, and rubber were the only materials they were made from (I'd heard about glass toys, but I figured that they weren't really meant to be "used" and were just a kind of sexual art), and so while I liked plastic just fine, I felt bummed that there weren't too many options with toys.
Thank goodness I found EF and discovered the whole slew of options out there! That jelly toy now basically sits around in my Box of Shame until I decide what to do with it - I'm thinking "dissection." I don't think I'll ever have another jelly toy.