I know the feels.
I often wish there were an in-between tone of vanilla and caramel. I feel like it would benefit me. I feel like my "actual" skin color is close to vanilla, but for me and what I notice around a lot is genital color is a bit darker than rest of the body color, but I feel like the caramel doesn't nearly match my genital color well.
Maybe what it is that I want is a more "skin-like" caramel color for me. For me when I look at the caramel I'm both like, "That's not my genital color" and "Does anyone have junk that color?"