Which Liberator shape for dorm storage?

MaryExy MaryExy 06/02/2011

I gave in and decided that I'm REALLY tempted to get my first Liberator shape early in fall semester. I'll need to wait to get to the dorm and make sure I have space for certain shapes, and I'll get fewer questions from my parents if it appears after I move to the dorms as opposed to during the moving. I am looking for a couple of different features/characteristi cs:

-super discreet shape (something like the Pulse might be a little hard to explain off as a pillow)
-relatively compact, hopefully so I could easily stow it on my bed with my pillows and still fit on the bed
-suitably shaped for at least reclining against, bonus points if it could be a nap-time pillow or sleeping pillow
-shaped well to support doggy style

I would prefer to order a shape from Eden, but I am open to ordering from the Liberator site if there's a shape that Eden doesn't have (Jaz Motion is the only non-Eden shape that really intrigued me). The Flip Ramp is still in the running, but I think I'd rather save that shape for an apartment where I have room for a chair-and-ottoman combination. The Wing looks nice because of the toy mounts, but I don't think I'd be using those enough to make them a deciding factor. And I'm at a loss to see the big difference between things like the Jaz and the Wedge...

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
MaryExy MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
ToyGurl , dv8 , Wondermom , potstickers , SiNn , mpfm , Zombirella , ellejay , LoveBug721 , sexyfun , Ex-prude , panthercat23
12
ToyGurl , kittychilla , CAKES , Dusk , Misfit Momma , Airen Wolf , darthkitt3n , sarki , Ms. Spice , SiNn , Dark Muse , GoodMorningSunshine , pfoof , TameTemptress , phunkyphreak , boobookittyfuk , ily , Beck , idunshire , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , Zombirella , te , Gracie , eeep , SexyRayne , marrythenight , BlooJay , Kirsten A , awesomeness , Fawkes , sexxxkitten , mmmmm , Anne
33
ToyGurl , kelaaa33wish , CafeSabroso , Bignuf , SiNn , oohlookasquirrel , John Baddi , idunshire , OroNomi , SilverMinxxx , wdanas , Undead , theavocadopit
13
Chilipepper , OhMy! , Jobthingy , jay28 , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , namelesschaos , Nando , wetone123 , Hanna , CAKES , Dusk , The Curious Couple , ichigostrawberry , ElleMNOP , Novs , Sweet-Justice , cujo467 , Akira , Lummox , big b , Kdlips , ichwillwaffels , Lady Venus , darthkitt3n , Reyes , Jazz , ddd masturbator(bye all!) , Keegski , SiNn , Acorn , Dark Muse , GoodMorningSunshine , Elnoa , LittleTree , FETIS , GirLicious , missap , ThoughtsAblaze , Miss Nessa , phunkyphreak , PiratePrincess , sktb0007 , authorzero , ily , Beck , Adriana Ravenlust , Masokisti , Maxx , PiƱa Colada , GONE! , Greenleaf , Entropy , unfulfilled , Jon S , Gimme More , DeliciousSurprise , mistre$$ , ninja250 , eeep , Master DarkWolf , DreamWolf , True Pleasures , marrythenight , Azule , roskat , pokefan15 , callsignhusker , LavenderSkies , Fawkes , jmex83 , SkinFlute , Hallmar82 , Vegan Silk , chantalgiardina , Do emu , Sauceboss , SadoMas , babycakess , FHeemz , mmmmm , sexyfun , Terri69 , satinlady550
83
Shellz31 , potstickers , lovemuscle n cookie
3
Howells , wetone123 , zracer , Alyjazz , liilii080 , married with children , Misfit Momma , AgnesTrevejo , Lummox , GoodMorningSunshine , cherryredhead88 , MJ1337 , dezzydezire , null , Azule , humpday , butts
17
newfoundlust , UunicornN , lovemuscle n cookie , BlooJay
4
SexyRayne , indiechick
2
Total votes: 167 (138 voters)
Poll is open
06/02/2011
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 70%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • Better Price - Save 40%
  • Try a luxury harness with a dildo and save 45% on a kit!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Chilipepper Chilipepper
Whirl can be explained as a body pillow without anyone questioning it. Plus it'll work for under the neck or supporting your legs when lying down.
06/02/2011
ToyGurl ToyGurl
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
The heart, jaz or wedge would be best. All three can easily be disguised as some sort of pillow for your neck/back/etc. They blend in on any bed with a pillow case, and are small enough to keep in a closet.
06/02/2011
ToyGurl ToyGurl
Quote:
Originally posted by ToyGurl
The heart, jaz or wedge would be best. All three can easily be disguised as some sort of pillow for your neck/back/etc. They blend in on any bed with a pillow case, and are small enough to keep in a closet.
The whirl XT is good too! probably even better because you can sleep with it!
06/02/2011
Jobthingy Jobthingy
I have the Whirl and I leave it on my bed at all times. I have a 12 year old running around here and she even uses it to lean on while watching tv.. yes i wash the cover after use. It really just looks like a firm bolster. my mom even saw it and just said "nice pillow"
06/02/2011
MaryExy MaryExy
So far the Whirl XT seems to be the winner. Just curious, anyone know the difference between that and the regular Whirl on the official Liberator site? The colors of the Whirl might be more flexible for me, but I don't know if the two Whirl versions can be considered equally.
06/02/2011
namelesschaos namelesschaos
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
So far the Whirl XT seems to be the winner. Just curious, anyone know the difference between that and the regular Whirl on the official Liberator site? The colors of the Whirl might be more flexible for me, but I don't know if the two Whirl ... More
Going by the product pages the regular Whirl is bigger:

Whirl XT 9" x 24"
Whirl 10" x 36"
06/02/2011
MaryExy MaryExy
Quote:
Originally posted by namelesschaos
Going by the product pages the regular Whirl is bigger:

Whirl XT 9" x 24"
Whirl 10" x 36"
Oooooh. I couldn't find the dimensions of the regular when I looked haha. A foot longer would probably be too much for now. Oh well.
06/02/2011
MaryExy MaryExy
Ok, now I have to ask. The Whirl is winning for some good reasons, but no one has recommended the Wing? The Wing is a little wider, so is it less body-pillow-shaped? Are the holes very obvious? Is it much less comfortable? Is it poorly shaped for doggy? Why do such similar-looking pieces get such different votes?
06/02/2011
CAKES CAKES
The heart or the whirl would fit right in with any other pillows on your bed and just look decorative.
06/03/2011
Kindred Kindred
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
Ok, now I have to ask. The Whirl is winning for some good reasons, but no one has recommended the Wing? The Wing is a little wider, so is it less body-pillow-shaped? Are the holes very obvious? Is it much less comfortable? Is it poorly shaped ... More
The Wing is more oval shaped and so much wider than the Whirl. It will be less discreet in my opinion. The holes for toy insertion aren't super obvious, but they will draw some attention unless you cover it up with a case of some sort. Personally, I find many of the Liberator pieces can be used similarly, just not as effectively. So I would say how you primarily plan to use the pillow should be how you decide on which shape to get taking into consideration you and your partners body sizes. Not every pillow works for every body size.

The Wing works well for doggie if that is your primary use. For us, it does not work well for lower back support (as with Missionary) since it is too high and the foam is firm. It's also a pretty large size and not compact at all.

I think the Whirl could be used for Doggie, I just think that the Wing would probably work better given its size and shape. I think the Whirl would work better in other positions.

The Wedge (I own), Heart, and Jaz all seem fairly similar, so if you chose one of those, it would probably be based on your body size and which works best for you. I'm not sure I would use any of them for Doggie unless you mean to be standing and leaning on it on the edge of the bed. They just seem a little low for that purpose.
06/03/2011
Shellz31 Shellz31
I would go with the Wing.
I actually put a standard pillow case on mine so it protects it from lint and it honestly just looks like a nice full pillow in the case.

Unless someone touched it to feel the dense foam, they would not think twice about it.
06/03/2011
namelesschaos namelesschaos
Quote:
Originally posted by Shellz31
I would go with the Wing.
I actually put a standard pillow case on mine so it protects it from lint and it honestly just looks like a nice full pillow in the case.

Unless someone touched it to feel the dense foam, they would not think ... More
I honestly never thought about covering a shape with a pillow case before I'm going to have to try that when I eventually get a wing. Thnaks foe the idea.
06/03/2011
MaryExy MaryExy
Quote:
Originally posted by Kindred
The Wing is more oval shaped and so much wider than the Whirl. It will be less discreet in my opinion. The holes for toy insertion aren't super obvious, but they will draw some attention unless you cover it up with a case of some sort. ... More
I mainly like the idea of support for doggy, so far I'm good for missionary. So that's where I might lean more towards the Wing based on your information. It's just rather disconcerting that no one's really voting in favor of the Wing.
06/03/2011
MaryExy MaryExy
Quote:
Originally posted by Shellz31
I would go with the Wing.
I actually put a standard pillow case on mine so it protects it from lint and it honestly just looks like a nice full pillow in the case.

Unless someone touched it to feel the dense foam, they would not think ... More
That sounds like an excellent idea! Thank you for making me feel loads better about being interested in the Wing haha. That sounds like the perfect way of hiding it
06/03/2011
Sweet-Justice Sweet-Justice
Liberator Whirl.
06/04/2011
big b big b
the flip
06/05/2011
CafeSabroso CafeSabroso
The Jaz is always out and no one has seemed to notice. I usually keep it wedged between the bed and the wall. It's pretty great for doggy, and I regularly use when I'm reading on my side in bed.
06/12/2011
Wondermom Wondermom
I would say the heart wedge or the whirl for ultimate discretion. The wing would work if you got a pillowcase for it when not in use
06/12/2011
Kdlips Kdlips
Liberator Whirl XT
06/12/2011
Airen Wolf Airen Wolf
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
Personally, I'd go for the heart wedge as it could be just another pillow in a dorm room...course the ramp or wedge could be great for studying in bed.
06/13/2011
Lady Venus Lady Venus
The Whirl or the Heart wedge I would say would be the most discreet.
06/13/2011
Lady Venus Lady Venus
The Whirl or the Heart wedge I would say would be the most discreet.
06/13/2011
ddd masturbator(bye all!) ddd masturbator(bye all!)
I voted the Whirl because it would be the most likely option to fit in with other pillows on the bed. The heart is cute, but if it doesn't go with your current decorations, it might stick out. I guess the big question is who you are wanting to hide this from...
06/21/2011
Bignuf Bignuf
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
Won't lie. We have EVERY shape pillow Liberator makes. The one that gets 99% of use..not too high, great for ALL position activities, is the JAZ!!! One of our more recent acquisitions.
06/22/2011
Acorn Acorn
I agree that the whirl would be very inconspicuous, especially if you put a cover on it.
06/24/2011
oohlookasquirrel oohlookasquirrel
I keep my Wing on my bed in a pillowcase, but you might need an extra large one because you want to make sure that none of the holes for toys peek out and give you away. The Wing wouldn't make a great pillow on its own, but it's great for propping yourself up in bed if you put a cushier pillow on top of it. But if you need to share a twin XL bed with the Wing every night, it will probably be too big for your needs unless you like to sleep propped up. Twin XL beds don't have a lot of space for extra pillows. I love my Wing, but it's too big if you need to keep it on your bed all the time, unless you have an unusually large dorm bed.

Make sure you have a seam ripper handy for removing the "Liberator" tag that comes sewn on to all of them if you're not going to cover it with your own pillowcase. Otherwise, a curious roommate googling "Liberator" is going to bust you almost immediately.
06/24/2011
Dark Muse Dark Muse
I think the whirl or heart wedge are the most discreet. I had a body pillow in college, and I think that that's what most people would assume what the whirl would be. It's easy enough to just push to the bottom of the bed when not in use, or you could curl up around it when sleeping. I think that's probably the best option. The heart would be discreet as well, but I don't think it would be as useful. The wing could probably be discreet too, if you add a pillowcase over top to hide the holes. It's also much more expensive. If you don't plan on using it with toys often, it might be more worthwhile to get the whirl for now and upgrade later.
06/25/2011
GoodMorningSunshine GoodMorningSunshine
I'd say the heart wedge or the whirl for sure. Those are the only two you could pass off as pillows without having to come up with some longwinded story. Plus either of them are both really cute.
06/28/2011
Miss Nessa Miss Nessa
Liberator Whirl XT
07/17/2011
phunkyphreak phunkyphreak
Heart of Whirl XT both can be passed off as pillows
07/18/2011
boobookittyfuk boobookittyfuk
The heart wedge. It makes a really cute center pillow on our bed. Nobody ever says "hey is that a sex pillow?" and its really cute!
07/18/2011
idunshire idunshire
Having just come from living in dorms I would go for discretness... so either the jazz (because it's small) or the heart (because no one would ever question it).
01/15/2012
Greenleaf Greenleaf
The whirl looks just like one of the fancy pillows that people buy from frufru bed and bath stores, so it'd be really easy to pass off as a regular pillow. Plus you could use it as a backrest if you read/study on your bed like I do.
01/15/2012
Entropy Entropy
If you're concerned about being discreet then I would go with the whirl. It blends in as a body pillow.
01/15/2012
SilverMinxxx SilverMinxxx
I think any of the first 3 choices would be great!!
01/17/2012
Zombirella Zombirella
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
I really want the heart wedge.
01/17/2012
Gimme More Gimme More
whirl
01/18/2012
Bullfanch Bullfanch
Did you end up getting one during the fall? I'm curious about what you chose and how well it's worked for you.
02/02/2012
mistre$$ mistre$$
Whirl just looks like a body pillow to me.
02/02/2012
Master DarkWolf Master DarkWolf
Whirl XT.
04/02/2012
DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by Master DarkWolf
Whirl XT.
Yup... ^^
04/02/2012
SexyRayne SexyRayne
Id go for the heart or the bon bon.
04/02/2012
Azule Azule
The basic flip ramp and whirl XT just look the most comfortable for me and better for long term use because of all the different combinations.
04/03/2012
BlooJay BlooJay
The Jaz or the Heart.
04/07/2012
pokefan15 pokefan15
The whirl is great for doggy style!!! I have one and I love it. Other people just assume its a regular pillow.
04/08/2012
callsignhusker callsignhusker
the heart seems like more of a novelty, I would get something else
04/09/2012
CindyH CindyH
Quote:
Originally posted by callsignhusker
the heart seems like more of a novelty, I would get something else
Liberator Whirl XT will pass as a pillow
04/09/2012
LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
The Liberator Whirl XT
05/05/2012
Fawkes Fawkes
the heart or xt depending upon your decor
05/09/2012
Undead Undead
The Jaz.
05/09/2012
SkinFlute SkinFlute
I live in a dorm right now and I say the whirl looks better!
05/23/2012
theavocadopit theavocadopit
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
05/25/2012
theavocadopit theavocadopit
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
05/25/2012
Hallmar82 Hallmar82
All of them except for the heart wedge could be covered with a blanket and be discreet.
05/25/2012
indiechick indiechick
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
The flip ramp is going to meet your need for a doggy style pillow however have fun hiding that in a dorm room. The easier to hide in plain sight is going to be the heart, you can but it front and center on your bed and no one will be the wiser.
05/25/2012
Vegan Silk Vegan Silk
whirl is most discrete I think.
05/25/2012
chantalgiardina chantalgiardina
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
whirl
05/25/2012
Do emu Do emu
Quote:
Originally posted by MaryExy
These aren't the specific colors that I would choose, so please don't vote based on color preferences.
I like the Whirl.
05/25/2012
Sauceboss Sauceboss
whirl looks like a body pillow so it gets my vote.
05/26/2012
SadoMas SadoMas
heart
05/27/2012
mmmmm mmmmm
heart wedge
06/09/2012
Terri69 Terri69
Whirl XT
07/19/2012
panthercat23 panthercat23
the wedge, it will be easier to store than some of the larger ones.
08/16/2012
Phosphorous Tick Phosphorous Tick
Get the heart one- it looks just like a novelty pillow in my opinion and would probably function much like one. No one would question a heart shaped pillow on a girl's bed.
08/16/2012
Total posts: 65
Unique posters: 56