The Black Magic Vibrator: The added ribbed texture is stupendous. Hits a few extra spots.
The Black Magic Bullet: Can't compare too much, considering the bullet is actually meant more for clit stimulation and such. . .
The Black Magic Pocket Rocket: Again, even with the different head for this thing, it's meant more for external pleasure, while the ribber texture of the Black Magic Ribbed Vibe is more for pleasuring a lot more of you on the inside.
The Black Magic Mystical Squirmy: While this one is meant for in and out, the ribbed vibe actually beats. Why? Because the Ribbed Vibe has more insertable length, while the MS is less insertable length with some clit stimulation, though the clit stimulation is nice, I, myself, prefer more insertable length.