My favorites would probably be my VixSkin Tex and Johnny, Hitachi Magic Wand, Tantus Alumina Motion, Jimmyjane Little Chroma, LELO Ina, FunFactory Yooo, Vibratex Silky, Jopen by Vanity Vr3, Whipspider Tentacle Jr., Je Joue G-Ki, NobEssence Turned G-spot, NobEssence Smooth S Shape, NobEssence Romp, NobEssence P-Spot, and NobEssence Dual Use S Shape (really, just all my NobEssence toys---though if pressed, I'd probably say the Smooth S Shape is my most favorite NobEssence toy).
I have quite a few glass pieces. I really like my Gold Laced G and Don Wands Bent Graduate. I also like my Don Wands Rainbow Mega Nubby during those times when I can handle that much texture. Oh, and another glass piece I like is my Don Wands Duchess (which looks just like the SSA Deepwater G).
If my Jimmyjane Form 2 did not shift its vibrations down to the base every time I turned around, that toy would definitely be within my top three favorite toys. It feels amazing when it works properly. From what I understand, some units trigger the glitch more easily than others. I am in the process of trying to get it replaced under warranty. Wish me luck with my replacement unit!