I have the vixskin Johnny and Mustang. My favorite thus far is probably Mustang. I use both for prostate and butt play, Johnny when I am feeling like a stretch, but Mustang is the perfect width, the material is amazing, and it's one of the best harness compatible dills that I have used with my wife. Just versatile I guess
I've only tried Lone Star and the Tristan 1.5 plug---and Lone Star beats that by a mile.
I'm looking forward to trying a VixSkin dildo with a defined glans, and then I'll have a real comparison for you!
I struggled for a long time about whether to get the Lone Star or Johnny - most people recommended the Lone Star - but I went with Johnny because I believed it was more in line with my wife's preferences.
Since I don't have the Lone Star I can't say which is better - just that she's happy with Johnny - and since the Outlaw is mostly a larger - straight version of Johnny, I'm hopeful.
My only Vixen Creations toy right now is the Spur, but I love it to pieces! I'm looking at getting a Mistress Vibe Kit sometime soon, and down the line I may go ahead and get the Tex. My best friend has the Leo, and she really loves it.
We have several Vixen Creation products but it's really hard to say which is a favorite as they fill specific needs. When the wife is feeling like it's a "bigger is better" night the Outlaw fits the bill like nothing else. When something less intimidating is order the Mustang gets the call and the smooth contours of Raquel are preferred for backdoor visits. The item most frequently used item these days is the Colossus which unfortunately EF doesn't seem to carry but is a slightly larger version of the Ride On made for larger males.
The one item we really didn't like however was the Nexus. We ordered it after a disappointing tryout for the a similar product called Feeldoe. We'd hoped that the people at Vixen could pull it off better and while it was of the high quality we've come to expect from them it's simply a product/concept that's better in theory than execution.