I *personally* don't generally like realistic toys (penises OR vulvas) because they look dismembered to me, so I usually choose artistic, abstract designs. I think it's different for me when they're worn (such as a strap-on or packer) but I don't like just seeing them sitting out. But I don't think it's at all WEIRD to like them, it makes perfect sense, and I don't see anything wrong with it.
I find sex dolls (the whole body) much more creepy, though, because dolls terrify me in general! Very personal thing. And a lot of high-end super-premium sex dolls fall into the "uncanny valley". Again, I don't think it's weird for people to like that (just like it's not weird for people to like regular dolls aesthetically or whatever), but I would be always uncomfortable if one was in my house. Haha.