First experiences with butt plugs

Jammin14580 Jammin14580
How was your first experience with a plug?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
HATED it
Rossie , Lily Bee , pokefan15 , untster69
4  (4%)
LOVED it
jay28 , 12345678 , The Curious Couple , Masokisti , Clandestine , philly , Sublime , Jammin14580 , Kitka , AmandaV , potstickers , te , bayosgirl , Dreaus , Ahatmadeofshoes12 , zeb , Bebela , oneeyedoctopus , tpfks , toxie m , Raizer911 , ichwillwaffels , MistressDandelion , LavenderSkies , Missmarc , iabicpl09 , Bullfroggy and Rose , ben12 , butts , Supervixen , Robespierrethecat , subbieforHer , 1001 Pleasures , TheirPet , SecretKinksters , pierced cock 4 her , hotinpink , hhh , Incendiaire , solly , Happyinmypants , noway , XYCopperheadSly , bog , sophia430 , Rawr4483 , M's boy
47  (52%)
I'm neutral about it
MrWishyWashy , aliceinthehole , snowbumbunnie , Beck , indiglo , BuckeyeGal04 , Allstars316 , Sohotdinosaur , eggiweg , MR Chickhabit , Rin (aka Nire) , toastedbananas , sweetpea12 , Stagger13 , Maximusx , spiced , SexyWalrus , GirlOnGirl , Lady Smile , Arlinnae , evie.amor , Trysexual
22  (24%)
Other
Gracie , Lucky21 , T&A1987 , Jordan B , skeeterlynn , Cat E. , LoooveMonkey , Hummingbird , StarrStacked , SaucyxGirl
10  (11%)
Give me my EdenPoints!
LunaDragon , bethd1708 , ToyBunny , MilitaryLove , hillys , vulvalicious , Isola
7  (8%)
Total votes: 90
Poll is closed
12/12/2011
  • Save 40% on Vibrators
  • Get 3 amazing toys for $60 only
  • Eye of Love Pheromone Kit - Save 25%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 70%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Rossie Rossie
I don't even remember what its name was, but I hated it, I'd probably used it twice before dumping it. It was a silicone plug that looked like the Lil'l End, aside from helping to open-up my behind (which could be accomplished by using a finger), it was a useless piece of junk.
12/12/2011
The Curious Couple The Curious Couple
I loved my first time using a butt plug!
12/12/2011
Masokisti Masokisti
It was great
12/12/2011
Clandestine Clandestine
My second toy was a butt plug, Ryder, and it was decidedly different than a dildo. This was over two years ago, now.
That popping sensation as it moved into place, and the fullness it provided... It is difficult to forget something like that. As I was relatively new to anal at the time, it felt so foreign and nice.

I still like them to this day, and they have become my favourite type of toy, bar none.
My favourite so far is the Pure Plug Large, though the Pure Plug 2.0 is on the way. It's exciting!
12/12/2011
philly philly
I loved the jolly jack, then moved up to the ryder which is still a little big for me. Next is a njoy for sure!
12/12/2011
MrWishyWashy MrWishyWashy
The first one I tried was too small for me, looking forward to trying to some others with provide more fullness and are larger. All in all, not a good or bad experience the first time.
12/12/2011
Sublime Sublime
I liked it
12/12/2011
Gracie Gracie
I'm still just flirting with the idea.
12/12/2011
Lucky21 Lucky21
I am pretty new to the world of plugs. It didn't go very smoothly, but I didn't hate it. I had to work up to the one I had a bit more. I love LOVE lOVE my Icicles 14. That thing is awesome.
12/13/2011
Kitka Kitka
I loved my first time using a plug.
12/13/2011
Beck Beck
My first one was not that great, but I remain neutral about it.
12/13/2011
indiglo indiglo
The first time I used it, I was neutral about it. Once I got used to the sensation, and got over the foreign feeling, I really liked it. Same toy each time, but the experience got better as I became more used to the sensation of stimulation in an area that wasn't used to being stimulated.
12/14/2011
T&A1987 T&A1987
was good, not great. about 6.5 on a scale of ten.
12/15/2011
te te
Me gusta!
02/04/2012
bayosgirl bayosgirl
I liked the feeling (I was no stranger to anal play, though) but it had a habit of popping out, so that was kind of a downer.
02/05/2012
Allstars316 Allstars316
My first time I was very unsure about it. But since then I enjoy it and still exploring. I'm adding to my collection of butt plugs each time I place an order.
02/05/2012
Ahatmadeofshoes12 Ahatmadeofshoes12
Quote:
Originally posted by Jammin14580
How was your first experience with a plug?
I love butt plugs, loved it the very first time I put it in my ass. Wearing a butt plug makes my orgasms much more powerful.
02/05/2012
zeb zeb
Quote:
Originally posted by Kitka
I loved my first time using a plug.
same here
02/05/2012
Bebela Bebela
Quote:
Originally posted by Clandestine
My second toy was a butt plug, Ryder, and it was decidedly different than a dildo. This was over two years ago, now.
That popping sensation as it moved into place, and the fullness it provided... It is difficult to forget something like that. As ... More
That's truly unforgettable!
I remember my bf tried bp's on me as soon as he could because he anxious to get my booty.
Definitely an ass man heheh...
02/08/2012
oneeyedoctopus oneeyedoctopus
Just got my first one last week. It was pleasant, but not what I was expecting.
02/13/2012
toxie m toxie m
I loved it. I was so happy to finally have an actual toy rather than just fingers
02/13/2012
Raizer911 Raizer911
I enjoyed my first time greatly. The receiver not so much.
02/13/2012
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by Jammin14580
How was your first experience with a plug?
I was really nervous but I loved it. Just had to make sure I used lots of lube.
02/14/2012
sweetpea12 sweetpea12
Quote:
Originally posted by Jammin14580
How was your first experience with a plug?
I was really excited when I bought my first set of but plugs. I thought it was kinky and a cool idea. But when I actually used them it just felt like I wanted to poop. It wasn't an awful feeling just something that I was like eeh just make sure I don't poop while doing this .
04/09/2012
cepl5869 cepl5869
she loves it got the b-bomb and she loves it even more
04/09/2012
LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by Jammin14580
How was your first experience with a plug?
Love it
04/10/2012
Jordan B Jordan B
I'm still searching for the best first one
04/10/2012
Exploring Manliness Exploring Manliness
Quote:
Originally posted by Jordan B
I'm still searching for the best first one
I just got into anal play and ordered my first toy, a butt plug, from EF. It is the Luxotiq anal plug made out of pink glass. It is beautiful and I love it, but now I want the pure plug small or medium because the curve looks like it would fit better and I want to get into extended play. The first night I slept with the Luxotiq plug in, it was hard to get it out the next day and there was some pain. Nothing I can't handle, but I want to slow down and let my body adjust.

If you have any questions just message me and I'll be happy to share any of my experiences with you. Good luck on starting a new chapter in pleasure!
04/17/2012
Maximusx Maximusx
havent tried one yet, soon though....soon lol
06/07/2012
  • 1
  • 2
Total posts: 55
Unique posters: 54