Punishment plug - butt plug discontinued by Topco Sales - review by Sammi

The Punishment Plug by Topco is a fun dual use toy for experimentation with BDSM. It’s good for beginner through advanced play, and is a fun way for you and your partner to experiment with flogging as well as more interesting plug designs. My husband and I have been playing with BDSM a bit, and this looked like a fun toy to open up a new area in our play. I wasn’t sure how he would feel about flogging me (although he definitely likes to spank me), so this seemed a safe, fun, and inexpensive way to introduce a flogger and see if he would take up the challenge. If not, the punishment plug would be used as a cute butt plug with its tail.

The plug comes in your choice of red or black (with matching tail color). The smooth plug end of this toy is 4 1/4 “ long (with an insertable length of 3 1/4") and about 1 1/8” at its widest point. The plug is made of smooth jelly, with a soft and rubbery feel. Unfortunately, it has a funny rubbery smell as well. Several washings and dryings did remove the scent fairly well.

Attached to the flared base of the plug are lots of “rubber” tails, about 6” long. There’s a good number of them, and together they look a bit like a short horse’s tail. They are long enough to tickle your pussy lips and clit if you’re on your hands and knees.

Since the Punishment Butt Plug is made of jelly, it can not be sterilized, nor should it be shared unless you use a condom on it. The plug can be cleaned with warm water and toy cleaner, or a mild soap. It should be stored in a cool, dark place when not in use. Use plenty of water soluble lube when inserting the plug!

My husband was intrigued by the toy and chuckled a bit at the tail. He was as eager to try this as I was, and so I got into doggie position. I thought he was just going to use it as a plug, but instead he used the plug as a handle and began to gently flog me with the tails. It stung a bit while he did this, but not badly. This was making me quite horny, though, and I asked him to go harder. Ouch! I know he wasn’t hitting me full force, but boy did those tails sting when they whacked my ass! They were leaving small welts and lines too, although no blood. It was unbelievable how arousing this was, for both of us! Soon my ass was aching and red, and I begged for mercy for him to stop.

I wasn’t done with the toy yet! My husband slipped the plug in my ass (with plenty of lube). I usually use a bit smaller of an anal toy, so this really seemed to fill my ass up quickly! Since the material has some give to it, though, he was able to get it in without too much discomfort. Rocking back and forth, the tails slapped gently between my legs and turned me on even more. We had an explosive sex session, and afterward my husband expressed interest in getting another flogger. That way I can have the pony tail in and be flogged at the same time.

I would recommend this toy for anyone interested in trying “kinky” BDSM play. It’s definitely fun, good sized, and will add some spice (and a bit of sting) to your session.

This is such a cute plug! My husband really likes the tail effect, and we use it a lot during our more kinkier play. The feel of the tail as a whip is great, and it seems to have more sting to it than the other rubber whips I have. The feel of it just tickling when it's inserted is a great sensation. This plug stays in place well for me.

The smell has mostly dissipated, although I don't think it will ever completely go away. The plug is holding up well with no signs of wear, and the whip ends have stayed attached. They do tend to tangle somewhat, but easily detangle with my fingers.

I'm glad this is a toy we added to our collection.