Pony play whip - butt plug discontinued by Doc Johnson - review by Sammi

Have you ever wanted to have a tail? Do you like to play a bit kinky? Like a little something up your ass? Then the Pony Play Whip from Doc Johnson may be just what you’re looking for.

My husband and I have been exploring some kinky things lately, and we saw a porno where the girl was wearing one of these. My husband thought it was pretty hot, so I decided to order one to surprise him.

This plug arrived with only the plug packaged in the plastic. The long tail hung out below the package. The plug is a nice red color, and about 4” long (3 1/2” insertable). It’s only 1” wide, so it’s perfect for beginner play. The tail is about 8” long, and feels like it’s made out of nylon. Lots of individual strands come out of the bottom of the plug to create the tail, which is black. The tail can be decorous, or used for a bit of light flogging and whipping.

The plug is smooth, and has a bit of a smell right out of the package since it’s made of rubber. Rubber is porous, so although it has a long life and wears well, it cannot be sterilized and can be difficult to clean. Antibacterial soap and warm water work well. A condom should be used for safety. Water or silicone based lubes can be used safely with rubber toys.

I decided on a naughty black number, then inserted the plug myself, with lots of lube. The plug went in easily, since it’s tapered, all the way in. It also wanted to come back out, since it’s a bit narrow. A larger bulge towards the base might have helped hold it in place. I made due by putting on a small black g-string that wasn’t very stretchy. It didn’t interfere with the look of the tail and helped to hold it in my ass. It didn’t take a lot of pressure to do so.

I crawled out to the living room where my husband was waiting, wiggling my butt with the plug in it. That was a definite turn on. He liked the way the tail looked in my ass, and I liked the whispery feeling of the tail strands brushing and tickling my inner thighs. It definitely set the mood for a kinky session!

The tail can also be used as a whip. Although the strands are fairly light, they are numerous, and they will sting if swung on flesh with sufficient force. We didn’t manage to break the skin or create welts, but red lines were visible for a while afterwards.

All in all, this is a fun and erotic toy, and fun to use in combination with other gear like floggers. It’ll bring out the kink in you!

I do wish this plug stayed in better. While it stays in fine with a non-super stretchy g-string, it won't stay in otherwise. Sometimes you don't want a g-string on! A bit more of a bulb would do wonders for keeping this in. I do really like the look of this, though.

We do like using the tail part as a whip, and I haven't found it to tangle too badly with a bit of care. The plug doesn't show signs of wear. It still retains a light scent, so I keep it stored away from other toys.