Time to begin packing!! But how big?

Genderfree Genderfree 11/03/2012

Hello there, I've been out as male for about 5 months now. I pack with a good 'ol sock, but I think it's time to get a real packer. I don't know how big my penis should be, though!

Fun fact: I'm going to be in Rocky Horror, and I'm playing Rocky, and I need something gold to go for!

What size would seem realistic for me? I'm a measly 5'3", I have tiny hands, but my shoulders are getting broader because I've been working out a lot. My hip measurement is 34 inches, if that helps at all.

To me the extra small just seems too small (and the head too big) and the small seems to big in general. Also note that I've only ever seen 3 penises before in real life, one of them larger, one of them average, and one of them belonging to a trans woman.

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

Genderfree Genderfree
Mr. Limpy XS or Mr. Limpy S?
  • Buy 1 Toy, Get 1 FREE
  • Save 20% on Luxury Toys
  • Pick Any 2 E-Stim Toys, Get 60% Off A Kit
  • Fall Clearance! Save 80%. Limited Quantity
  • Fall Clearance! Save 50% on select items
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
charletnarouh charletnarouh
i really think it depends on what you're wearing over it. For Rocky, i think the small would be a better bet because you want to have a big package for that. For every day, i think it depends on the type of underwear you favor and what style of pants you prefer. If you prefer tight skinny jeans, then i'd say stick with the extra small, just so you're not going to have an uncomfortably huge bulge, but if you go with looser pants, i think the small will work fine. But it's really about what you're most comfortable with. If you want to show off a big bulge, then bigger is better. If having a big, really visible package is going to make you uncomfortable and self-conscious, then go smaller. They're not wildly expensive. For a total of less than $30, why not buy both and try them on and compare how they feel and look? As a drag king, which i know is obviously different but i still pack when i'm in drag, i pack with socks and customize the size and shape of the package to suit the outfit i'm wearing at any given time. Good luck and congrats!!
closed account closed account
unfortunately there needs to be a size in between those two. I have the small and it felt too obtrusive to me. But when i look at the reviews on the extra small, i just dont' like that one either.

I do think Mr limpy is an affordable first packer, but it won't last long. I've heard good things about Mr right

It is better quality, better material, comes in 3 skin tones, and is in between those two in size.

side by side comparison for easy reference
deltalima deltalima
Originally posted by Genderfree
Mr. Limpy XS or Mr. Limpy S?
Genderfree Genderfree
Unfortunately, I am not ready to pay 50 dollars for pack 'n play when I already have my Goodfella, which I spent 100 dollars on.

I saw pictures of some people wearing the XS and I believe that the XS will work better for me. I do wear a lot more tight clothing (I wish my legs were not so.. feminine though) and the small just seems too big.

I also like the suggestion of getting both. Maybe with different outfits one will look better than the other...

Thanks everyone. I'm still taking suggestions, though!
Andrew1992 Andrew1992
Originally posted by Genderfree
Mr. Limpy XS or Mr. Limpy S?
For everyday, I would almost certainly recommend the XS. Its ultimately up to you, and the mr limpys aren't so expensive that you couldn't buy both to try, but I find that the XS makes a perfect size bulge.
Schattenstern Schattenstern
The XS is great for anyone who isn't 7 feet tall. As a general rule. The S just makes this unrealistic huge buldge because the balls are right there, too.
llellsee llellsee
I have owned both sizes and I'd say the XS , the small isn't far off the length of most dildos and is -very- noticeable when packing it.
Total posts: 8
Unique posters: 7