Women what was your first creampie like and would you do it again?

panthercat23 panthercat23
I just had my first creampie the other night and I was wondering if my reaction is a typical one or if I'm just weird. For me it was one of the most magical and special moments I've ever experienced. For the most part I think I would say it was more of a mental reaction but the creampie itself was enough to make me squirt and then remain horny for the next 12 hours. I wasn't horny because of being unsatisfied in the least bit either. And then the connection I feel with my boyfriend is deeper than I would have thought possible.

Because of some previous threads I've read, I'm going to clarify creampie as a man cuming in you, and specifically in your vagina for this question.

Please, also spare me the lecture of the consequences of having my boyfriend cum inside of me. I know what I'm getting myself into and I can handle it.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
Yes, I've had one and I would do it again.
23  (77%)
Yes, I've had one but I wouldn't do it again.
No, I've never had one but I would like to try it.
4  (13%)
No, I've never had one and I don't want to try it.
3  (10%)
Total votes: 30
Poll is closed
04/23/2012
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 70%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • Better Price - Save 40%
  • Save 60% on 3 item set for couples

    • Passionate wrists cuffs
    • Luxury fetish passionate eye mask
    • Eden 20 function remote bullet
    Save 60% on this 3 item set

    Expires on Aug, 29 at 8pm ET Terms

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Badass Badass
I love the feeling of it.
If I could, I'd get my boyfriend to do it every time.
04/23/2012
Beck Beck
I can feel cum being pumped inside me. I'm very sensitive to this. I LOVE it.
04/23/2012
Various Various
I remember it, but I don't remember feeling like it was special or anything.
04/23/2012
PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
I'm on birth control, so that's the only way we do it! LOVE it!
04/23/2012
Ansley Ansley
I'm not on birth control but when I was, I loved it.
04/23/2012
underHim underHim
I know it always feels amazing when he cums in me. Usually if I am close the sensation will send me over the edge.
04/23/2012
StarFire StarFire
Not on birth control so that's not happening anytime soon :/
04/23/2012
Deeder Deeder
I can tell when he's cumming, because I can feel a difference in his muscle movements and such, but I can't say that it feels particularly amazing.
04/23/2012
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Somethings lost on me here - I have never used a condom! All of my partners have been on the pill. The only time this was not true was when we were planning to conceive. So every sexual encounter with my wife has resulted in a 'cream pie' - its just normal PIV sex!?
04/24/2012
humblepie humblepie
It was like "What...the condom broke?!" Not very magical once we realized what had happened, but while we just lay there it was very nice. A cute bonding moment.

I like it when my partner cums inside me, and hopefully I will soon be on the pill so we can get back to doing it regularly.
04/24/2012
Azule Azule
I've always enjoyed it but probably not to that intensity.
04/24/2012
Calla Calla
I actually don't remember the first time, even though it would only have been about a year and a half ago. Now it's just what happens every time we have sex. I don't find it to be a turn on, it really doesn't make any difference to me. I do like feeling the pulsing when he ejaculates, but I can feel that whether we use a condom or not.
04/25/2012
Zombirella Zombirella
I've never heard of this referred to as that, lol.

I'm on the pill and engaged so usually all the time. I don't know why but for some reason it turns me on more after I feel him do it. Maybe just knowing he is satisfied does it? But I like him to and if I'm not there yet that usually helps.

I do hate the clean-up though. The whole clench and run to the bathroom like my life depends on it. I don't want it getting on the sheets or my clothes when I dress. Then sometimes even after you go to the bathroom, sometime later you feel a little leak, ugh hate that! Sometimes he wants to keep going after he does but I just can't, it's too much lubrication and I have to go clean up.
04/25/2012
Terri69 Terri69
I love the feeling of him cumming inside of me.
04/25/2012
Annemarie Annemarie
Quote:
Originally posted by Beck
I can feel cum being pumped inside me. I'm very sensitive to this. I LOVE it.
Ditto! I loathe condoms because that emotional connection just isn't there for me.
04/25/2012
Khanner Khanner
I was using the sponge the first time, so the spillage was much more contained. It's awesome but I'm off the pill now so I can't do it anymore. If only my body didn't go nuts around progesterone.
04/25/2012
NewEnglandCouple NewEnglandCouple
I never let him pull out. Cum was meant to be inside so it can slowly dribble out are be a lasting reminder of the sex I just had.
04/27/2012
Pinkshirt Pinkshirt
I remember the first time and I kind of felt like you did. My husband had a vasectomy so now it's a typical thing for us and no longer magical.
07/24/2012
Pinkshirt Pinkshirt
Quote:
Originally posted by Zombirella
I've never heard of this referred to as that, lol.

I'm on the pill and engaged so usually all the time. I don't know why but for some reason it turns me on more after I feel him do it. Maybe just knowing he is satisfied does it? ... More
Lol I do the same thing, the running to the bathroom and then you think it's all out and leaks as soon as you get back to bed.
07/24/2012
xcapricax xcapricax
They make me horny all day
07/24/2012
misskat misskat
I have been on the pill for a long time now so I don't really remember what the first time was like. It does make me feel closer to my man even though it's really messy haha...he thinks it's very hot to have his cum all over me and coming out of me though and I love that.
07/24/2012
libbyv libbyv
Quote:
Originally posted by panthercat23
I just had my first creampie the other night and I was wondering if my reaction is a typical one or if I'm just weird. For me it was one of the most magical and special moments I've ever experienced. For the most part I think I would say it ... More
i love when my husband cums in me. we've only done it once though, our wedding night. and although i'm on the pill, my husband is afraid of the 1% chance of getting me pregnant.

the one time he did, i love feeling him continue to slide in and out, using his cum as lube.

he typically pulls out and cums on my breasts, or in my mouth now
11/15/2012
Liz2 Liz2
I totally love the feeling as he pumps and fills me up. I have an IUD so now can now totally enjoy the experience.
But.....after sex during the day when I have to get up and dressed, the wet feeling afterwards is uncomfortable, so for daytime sex, I try to use a condom on him.
11/15/2012
shielaray shielaray
Quote:
Originally posted by panthercat23
I just had my first creampie the other night and I was wondering if my reaction is a typical one or if I'm just weird. For me it was one of the most magical and special moments I've ever experienced. For the most part I think I would say it ... More
I'm on BC, so my boyfriend usually cums inside me. Like you said, it is more psychological than anything, and is not a huge deal for me anymore at all... but the feeling is definitely preferable than condoms.
11/15/2012
ViVix ViVix
Quote:
Originally posted by panthercat23
I just had my first creampie the other night and I was wondering if my reaction is a typical one or if I'm just weird. For me it was one of the most magical and special moments I've ever experienced. For the most part I think I would say it ... More
I'm on birth control, so bring it on! P.S. I totally understand that you are capable of making your own sexual choices. lol.
11/16/2012
Babylove09 Babylove09
Quote:
Originally posted by panthercat23
I just had my first creampie the other night and I was wondering if my reaction is a typical one or if I'm just weird. For me it was one of the most magical and special moments I've ever experienced. For the most part I think I would say it ... More
Cream pie I think yes. . . I love when my husband does this with me I can feel all the cum shooting inside me! It feels amazing we do it all the time.
11/18/2012
Total posts: 27
Unique posters: 26