Other? I don't play FPS (I assume they are) because they make me all worried and stuff, that those fuckers are gonna shoot me, am gonna die, ahhh, hurry, run run, shoot shoot, aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhh !!!!!!!! Nope, they go on my nerves and freak me out, so I choose the not-there "Other"... ^^
Personally, I liked them both. The first one was more memorable to me and I preferred the piano theme over the violin version of the music. Gameplay wise, the second one was more fun to me, but the first one has a special place in my heart.
Here's a dorky fun fact: I wrote a damn poem/rap about Max Payne back in high school, because I was obsessed with it back then; I dressed up as Mona Sax for Halloween that year, too LOL.
I know I commented on this already, but I saw a lot of gameplay stuff from Max Payne 3 and just sighed...It's pretty much like any other game that's out now. It should of stopped after Max Payne 2 in my opinion.