Okay so I originally started with Jelly all those many many many years ago. I had the Lock n Load butt plug and LOVED IT. It felt great. I recently have been sticking to only using silicone anal toys/butt plugs. Loving them, they are comfortable and flexible etc.
However I just got the Icicles No .14 (Glass plug) and oh my god it is amazing. I have never felt anything quite like it (probably because it's my first glass toy), but it feels so comfortable. I honestly thought the glass would hurt.