Lone Star vs. Buck vs Vixskin Johnny: Which should I get?

Waterfall Waterfall 09/30/2010

I have been looking at Vixskin toys for a LONG TIME, but have not saved up enough until recently. Now I am having a hard time deciding which one to get. The all seem to have features that provide good g-spot stimulation, they are all larger than my average toy ( I am looking for one big boy for the collection), and they all look delicious! (This is why this is so hard) Just wondering which one people think is the best out of the three and if you have an opinion on whether they have something extra that the other two don't have or if they provide better stimulation.

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
Waterfall Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
cherryredhead88 , Carrie Ann , pinkcupcakes , sarki , etlon4 , 3d3n1 , HannahPanda , Badass , deltalima , souris , chicmichiw
11
Adriana Ravenlust , Selective Sensualist , Persephone Nightmare , beautifulpierced , mllebeauty , Alegria , Pleasure Piratess , Lady Venus , Yoda , ~LaUr3n~ , Tuesday , Owl Identified , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , sasweetheart89 , meganthomas , Sera , dv8 , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Miss T , ellejay , dhig , sophie2229 , sweet seduction , thedude , Solar Ray , Lio , Kaltir , sixfootsex , Lady Marmelade , DCorrelle , Adam02viper , navigator-d , Drifter86 , C4ss , potstickers , The Curious Couple , MJ1337 , Endocott , viola , Rebel Flower , ofackmird , JoanJett , Mika R. , Howells , CAKES , Jenimi , Elnoa , AnyBariz , dezzydezire , Lucky21 , pfoof , boobookittyfuk , kelaaa33wish , ichwillwaffels , sktb0007 , Bignuf , starklover , pleasurehunter , unfulfilled , DixieDoo , eeep , Jon S , ily , punkstar283 , Rawhide , ksparkles16 , Beck , kz916 , HannahPanda , Stagger13 , Entropy , Missmarc , Funtastic , Badass , DreamWolf , GirlOnGirl , kawigrl , padmeamidala , sweetpea12 , glasskitten , mpfm , sugar&spikes , comatose-kitty , Neotigress , tortilla , mmmmm , mjtheprincess , sexxxkitten , LavenderSkies , Bethy Cassatt , 425shark , GONE! , malantha , Alyona , PropertyOfPotter , Lori Gonzales , SepZet , SilverMinxxx , Dr. Curious , skeeterlynn , lovebites , spiced , damnbul12 , Cat E. , Gunsmoke , BlooJay , SecretKinksters , Flash777 , ashboo32 , Stinkytofu10 , Anne , amazon , SMichelle
113
SexyStuff , Shellz31 , Swish , SubmissiveFeminist , Lizard , tequilafish
6
Total votes: 130 (128 voters)
Poll is open
09/30/2010
  • Save 15% on Luxury Brands
  • Annual Clearance - Save 30%
  • Buy Cascade vibe and save 50% on lubricants!
  • Save 20% on self-lubricating Cascade vibe and sleeve kit
  • Better Price Sale - Save 20%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
trios trios
We have the coco Lonestar and coco Vixskin Johnny. I bought them for my wife for threesome play. My wife won't take them in,they are way too big for her. As far as feel goes, the Lonestar is thicker and it seems to be a little firmer than the Johnny, perhaps thicker core?. The VS Johnny is a little longer and does have more give/squishiness to it, esp at the head. It is not really that much thinner than the Lonestar. The johnny has a bigger head (both longer and wider), so that might get your g spot better. Both measured 6" circumference at the widest part, Lonestar was just 6" more uniformly than the Johnny. I don't know the buck.

My vote goes for VS Johnny based on the overall qualities. Even though she doesn't use them/take/insert them, I keep them nearby for a visual to get me jealous. But take this with a grain of salt becuase I am a guy and my wife has never used either! That's why I didn't vote.

Want more of a head- go Johnny. Want thicker and a little firmer- go Lonestar. Hope this helps somewhat....
09/30/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
We have the coco Lonestar and coco Vixskin Johnny. I bought them for my wife for threesome play. My wife won't take them in,they are way too big for her. As far as feel goes, the Lonestar is thicker and it seems to be a little firmer than the ... More
Thanks for the help
09/30/2010
Adriana Ravenlust Adriana Ravenlust
...Nevermind. I should learn to read first.
10/01/2010
Selective Sensualist Selective Sensualist
I had a very hard time deciding between these exact three myself! After looking through the VixSkin line, I narrowed it down to Buck, Johnny, and Lone Star. After much anguished deliberation, I decided to go for the Johnny because I was very, very, VERY attracted to that extreme curve (it looks like a more extreme curve than Buck's curve). The Lone Star is very similar in its dimensions, but it lacked the curve. Another difference between Lone Star and Johnny is that Lone Star does not have the bigger, more defined, bulbous head that Johnny has.

I was worried that the more defined head on Johnny might be painful. But the head is so squishy that it has not been painful at all. So I am glad that I chose Johnny because I have all the benefits of a big, bulbous head without the cons (i.e., catching on the pubic bone).

In comparing Buck and Johnny, Johnny is longer than Buck. Johnny also has balls while Buck does not. I was not so sure that I even wanted balls, so it was not exactly a deciding factor for me. However, they have turned out to offer some very nice benefits! The balls provide a large, heavy, and stable enough base that I can ride this big boy just by setting him on a chair or any other surface. Plus, I often like to turn him around and ride him backwards so I can grind my vulva and clit against the balls. (Big win!)

I have recently added Raquel to my collection as well. I can honestly say that, with VixSkin, it would be quite hard to make a bad selection -- unless you bought a size that is simply too big for your body to accommodate. I had purchased the Randy and it was absolutely HUGE! Randy is much, much larger than other toys that I knew I had a difficult time taking. So, I knew that Randy would just not work for me at all.
10/01/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by Selective Sensualist
I had a very hard time deciding between these exact three myself! After looking through the VixSkin line, I narrowed it down to Buck, Johnny, and Lone Star. After much anguished deliberation, I decided to go for the Johnny because I was very, very, ... More
Very helpful comparison information You are making me lean toward Johnny! Never thought I would actually like a realistic toy with balls but your experience with them sounds tempting... Thank you very much for the help! I will let you know who I pick (this is going to be a b-day present to myself in the next week or two )
10/01/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Any more opinions?
10/02/2010
ScottA ScottA
VixSkin is a bit softer than most, so I'd say you'd want something a bit more curved than you'd go for in a "straight silicone". I'd go for Buck or Johnny (I guess the big difference is whether or not you want balls).
10/02/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
VixSkin is a bit softer than most, so I'd say you'd want something a bit more curved than you'd go for in a "straight silicone". I'd go for Buck or Johnny (I guess the big difference is whether or not you want balls).
Thanks for the tip. Not sure about whether or not I want balls, thats one of the reasons why I'm having a hard time . I have no reason not to want them.
10/02/2010
trios trios
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
Thanks for the tip. Not sure about whether or not I want balls, thats one of the reasons why I'm having a hard time . I have no reason not to want them.
Balls make it easier to hold during use?!
10/03/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Balls make it easier to hold during use?!
Yeah, seems like it. Seems like everyone is leaning toward Johnny in this poll.
10/03/2010
trios trios
Waterfall, let us know what you decide. If you want a 'big boy' Johnny is your man... Hope you like it!
10/04/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Waterfall, let us know what you decide. If you want a 'big boy' Johnny is your man... Hope you like it!
I will let you know Will decide soon!
10/04/2010
trios trios
Just wondering- why the 2 chocolates and 1 caramel? The Johnny is great in chocolate?
10/04/2010
trios trios
Sorry for the extra post. But you may want to consider buying 2 out of the 3 and seeing (and feeling with your hand) for yourself which one you'd like and send the other back. I am of the mind to not return it if you actually use one, but maybe that's just me...
10/04/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Just wondering- why the 2 chocolates and 1 caramel? The Johnny is great in chocolate?
I was doing what was in stock, but I want chocolate for them all
10/04/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Sorry for the extra post. But you may want to consider buying 2 out of the 3 and seeing (and feeling with your hand) for yourself which one you'd like and send the other back. I am of the mind to not return it if you actually use one, but maybe ... More
If I had the money I would buy all 3 lol.
10/04/2010
ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Sorry for the extra post. But you may want to consider buying 2 out of the 3 and seeing (and feeling with your hand) for yourself which one you'd like and send the other back. I am of the mind to not return it if you actually use one, but maybe ... More
Many companies will not take them back, just because they can't guarantee that they've never been used, so they would have to trash them and take the loss.

If you go to a good B&M toy store that carries them you can fondle the samples all you want
10/05/2010
cherryredhead88 cherryredhead88
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
Many companies will not take them back, just because they can't guarantee that they've never been used, so they would have to trash them and take the loss.

If you go to a good B&M toy store that carries them you can fondle the samples all you want
Eden seems to be good with returning things though, although I cannot say they would refund a toy simply because you chose which one you wanted... lol.

Good suggestion on going to the b and m store, whatever that is lol
10/05/2010
trios trios
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
Many companies will not take them back, just because they can't guarantee that they've never been used, so they would have to trash them and take the loss.

If you go to a good B&M toy store that carries them you can fondle the samples all you want
What's a B and M store?!
10/05/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
What's a B and M store?!
I was wondering the same thing lol
10/05/2010
Alegria Alegria
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
What's a B and M store?!
Brick and Mortar. It means one you can physically go in, versus an online store like EF.
10/05/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
I've decided on JOHNNY in chocolate! Can't wait for him to get here
10/06/2010
trios trios
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
I've decided on JOHNNY in chocolate! Can't wait for him to get here
Great! You should have lots of fun. Let us all know how you like him!
10/06/2010
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
I prefer the Lone Star because it has a less ridged head, which doesn't catch on my pubic bone - but I'm a sensitive sally that way
10/06/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
I prefer the Lone Star because it has a less ridged head, which doesn't catch on my pubic bone - but I'm a sensitive sally that way
Because I'm such a toy addict, I might try Lone Star next
10/06/2010
Selective Sensualist Selective Sensualist
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
I've decided on JOHNNY in chocolate! Can't wait for him to get here
Yay! As everyone is probably sick to death of hearing from me, I absolutely LOVE my Johnny! I would like to add every single one of the VixSkin toys to my collection though.
10/06/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by Selective Sensualist
Yay! As everyone is probably sick to death of hearing from me, I absolutely LOVE my Johnny! I would like to add every single one of the VixSkin toys to my collection though.
All of their toys do look amazing
10/06/2010
Yoda Yoda
I have several vixskin dildos, and the johnny is by far my favourite. It's big but not too wide. But then again, I use mine anally, so....
10/06/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
I just got Johnny in the mail today and I have used him 3 times and every time was GREAT! I am soo happy with my decision!
10/07/2010
trios trios
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
I just got Johnny in the mail today and I have used him 3 times and every time was GREAT! I am soo happy with my decision!
wow! I was just going to ask. Does it hit the G spot like you wanted?
10/08/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
wow! I was just going to ask. Does it hit the G spot like you wanted?
Yes, it does a really nice job of hitting the g-spot. I think because it is so thick and because the of the curve it provides a nice amount of stimulation.
10/08/2010
Tuesday Tuesday
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
I just got Johnny in the mail today and I have used him 3 times and every time was GREAT! I am soo happy with my decision!
We received our Johnnys on the same day! Mine is vanilla.

I agree that he's just incredible. Mine is much softer than my Lonestar and I'm wondering whether vixskin becomes more firm with age. I remember being surprised at how squishy Lonestar was at first but now he's nowhere near as squishy as Johnny.
10/08/2010
Waterfall Waterfall
I'm happy you are enjoying Johnny as well He is wonderful and I can't believe I went this long without trying Vixskin! I have heard that Lonestar is more firm than Johnny, so maybe its not that they get more firm with time.
10/08/2010
trios trios
Quote:
Originally posted by Tuesday
We received our Johnnys on the same day! Mine is vanilla.

I agree that he's just incredible. Mine is much softer than my Lonestar and I'm wondering whether vixskin becomes more firm with age. I remember being surprised at how squishy ... More
Actually, I was thinking that the Vixskin gets more squishy with age. I really think that the Lonestar has soften up a bit and the head of the Johnny has too. I am hoping that they do soften a bit more, maybe my wife can take them if they do!

I do notice that the cyberskin that we have has definitely softened to the point that it is limp now, but the materials are different so am sure there is no parallel, just an observation!
10/08/2010
Sera Sera
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
The Johnny VixSkin is by far the safest and most high quality dildo I have ever seen. I would go with that one.
11/02/2010
sweet seduction sweet seduction
Love the johnny vixskin
02/01/2011
Waterfall Waterfall
Quote:
Originally posted by sweet seduction
Love the johnny vixskin
Johnny is AMAZING! I am thinking of trying Lone Star next
02/01/2011
SexyStuff SexyStuff
The Buck looks like a good size for g spot
02/16/2011
slynch slynch
We love the Outlaw Vixskin!
03/30/2011
sarki sarki
The Lone star looks good
07/03/2011
ofackmird ofackmird
Johnny!
07/04/2011
Lucky21 Lucky21
Johnny would be my choice.
07/08/2011
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Johnny vix skin, but me personally would go with cream!
07/08/2011
starklover starklover
Quote:
Originally posted by trios
Balls make it easier to hold during use?!
agreed
10/30/2011
pleasurehunter pleasurehunter
def johnny
10/31/2011
mfmtrios mfmtrios
Both Lonestar and Johnny are too thick for my wife.
11/05/2011
Rawhide Rawhide
I'd vote for Johnny, but here's a thought: if you're considering Buck, what about Maverick?
01/28/2012
Rawhide Rawhide
or perhaps Randy?
01/28/2012
HannahPanda HannahPanda
Johnny x 9000. Have it, adore it, would buy it again.
01/29/2012
Entropy Entropy
Johnny for sure
01/30/2012
Badass Badass
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Lone star or Johnny VixSkin
02/02/2012
kawigrl kawigrl
I have Johnny trying to decided between buck and lone star
04/13/2012
padmeamidala padmeamidala
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Johnny VixSkin
04/13/2012
sweetpea12 sweetpea12
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
I have wanted the Johnny Vixskin for a while, I would choose that one.
04/13/2012
comatose-kitty comatose-kitty
I have Johnny and Lone Star and I can say right now that Johnny completely dominates in that comparison
10/03/2012
Neotigress Neotigress
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
I'd actually get the Happy Valley Big Boy.. but that's me.
10/03/2012
mmmmm mmmmm
Johnny VixSkin
10/03/2012
sexxxkitten sexxxkitten
Johnny
10/03/2012
LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Johnny VixSkin!
10/07/2012
Bethy Cassatt Bethy Cassatt
Johnny
10/07/2012
Lizard Lizard
Buck looks appealing to me.
10/07/2012
Alyona Alyona
Johnny VixSkin (Caramel)
10/08/2012
Lori Gonzales Lori Gonzales
johnny
10/08/2012
SepZet SepZet
Vixskin DOES look really tempting...I'm curious myself.
10/11/2012
skeeterlynn skeeterlynn
Johnny VixSkin
12/06/2012
spiced spiced
I think you made a great choice with Johnny. I also have Buck, but it's one of my least-used dildos. Not quite sure why...it's high-quality and does have a nice curve.

But Johnny is just so...perfect, I guess would be the right word. Johnny is more skin-like than any of the other Vixskins I've tried. I do have to warm up with something smaller before Johnny, though. If we don't have a lot of time, we usually go with the Vixskin Mustang, which is my 2nd favorite Vixskin so far.

I'm interested in the Bandit. Anyone tried Johnny and Bandit??
12/07/2012
damnbul12 damnbul12
Quote:
Originally posted by Waterfall
In your opinion, which one is best and why? (If you like 2 out of the 3 that is also helpful)
Johnny VixSkin
12/07/2012
Cat E. Cat E.
Johnny looks pretty good and would definitely cause a G spot orgasm.
12/07/2012
ashboo32 ashboo32
now i need one of these! johnny looks great but i want most of them
01/08/2013
Anne Anne
johnny vix skin
01/08/2013
amazon amazon
Caramel... mmmmmm
01/08/2013
Total posts: 72
Unique posters: 45