While I wouldn't say no to a toy, I'd much, much prefer a gift card because I'm more interested in lingerie than things that go vroom. I would love to be gifted a wearable, so it's not that I feel the need to control exactly what I get, I just have a preference for things that go on your body and not in it.
Either would be great! I would love a gift card because my husband is pretty clueless in what I like and quality (I'm slowly educating him). Though, I would love getting a toy from him, because it would mean he stepped out of his comfort zone for me!
I like gift cards so that I can pick out something for myself, but if they are buying off of my wishlist I am happy as well. The key is that it is something that I pick out, as there is limits on size and designs that work for me.
Toy if it's from my partner card if it's from anyone else since my partner probably knows what kind of thing I'm currently wanting but anyone else would have to guess from my wishlist and that can't always reflect what I have my eye on NOW.