Originally posted by
Perhaps a guy prize and a girl prize for each potential winner? So say that a girl wins one, then she'd get the girl prize, and if a guy wins, he gets the guy prize.
To be honest, when I'm awarding the prizes I have a selection on hand of stuff I know I can give out, and I try to award something I think the winner would like. Like if I know the winner is in a relationship I might pick a couple's thing, or if I know they like flavored lubes I'll try to pick one of those. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. If I don't know, I pick at random and if there's an issue, they've let me know.