Originally posted by
You have to throw jelly toys out whenever they get sticky or start to smell bad.
I was gonna say, don't jelly toys always smell bad?
I agree with everyone else; condom it up, or get a phthalate-free toy. However, it's also possible you've got some sort of infection; it could be bacterial, viral, possibly an STI, or bacteria vaginosis (assuming you have a vagina). If changing a toy doesn't help, I really suggest heading to a doc to get it checked out. Infections in your nether regions are NEVER fun!