How Big Is Too Big?

Relevant topic analysis on Big Dildo:

Should big dildo's vibrate?
Should big dildo's the stuff that is wrist thick and bigger than 10 inches vibrate. Some say adding such features to such a big toy is ludicrous as..

Larger?
I WOULD LOVE to try a glass toy, but it seems they are all pretty small in girth....i need a much larger girth than what i've seen....any suggestions?

Biggest UR3/CyberSkin dildo
Just as the topic says. Does anyone know what the biggest suction cup dildo made of UR3 or CyberSkin is? I know some people don't care for the...

if you like big dildos, do you like real parts?
I am considering various dildos for myself and the wife. She prefers average or so she says. Can you enjoy large dildos and not necessarily care...

Large jelly dildos, do they all smell?
Every large jelly dildo we've ever used has had a stroooooong smell, has this been the case for any of you, are there any that don't smell?

that one really doesn't seem too big, on paper anyways! i would give it a try

I enjoy my Tantus General quite a lot. The Tantus Cowboy is just too big for me to take the last two bulges. The A-bomb is so damn big I cannot take any of it at all.

I can only fit about 6" of length inside me. In terms of girth, anything above 1 1/2" feels like a stretch. I guess I'm pretty small.

I'm petite and I prefer smaller than that for girth.

I really haven't met too big yet. I have to admit I'd use Goliath as a warm up toy...
I also own the Tantus "General". He is great; wish he were a tad bit longer though, ok, well, alot longer. I recently bought Dick Rambone and am enjoying him alot. I wish he came in a better material.. The Biggest Dildo I've attempted is "Doc Johnson Giant Jumbo Jack XL". He is 15" long and 2.5" in diamater...

I'm tempted, except I'd need to work at it.

I really like toys that are 1.75 inches in diameter. I need a nice warm up session before anything closer to 2 inches in diameter.

I'd lovvveee to the get Randy in Vixskin. I think that would be my first toy that's officially listed as 2 inches. I have one Tantus toy that I got in the closeout section that looks A LOT like the General, but was sold under the name The Captain. My boyfriend and I used our digital calipers to measure it one time just because it looks SO BIG. Looking at pictures I've found online I think it might actually be a General. Ah, well. The mysterious dildos...

Depends on if I have time to warm up a while first with smaller toys, but most of my favorites seems to be around the 1" or 1 1/2" diameter range.

I have this one and I can only take it about halfway before it gets too girthy for me but I love it anyway (provided I've warmed up first, it's not something I like to use straight away).

Right at the max

i can't seem to get past 5-6 inches inside me and with my vixskin dildos anything over 1 1/2 inches in diameter are very difficult. I'm trying to work up to larger diameters but its hard! i ordered vixskin johnny and hoping ill be able to use him.