Mine was a simple bullet vibrator i ordered online with my boyfriend (now my husband) and we were in high school. We also had like a bucket of 60 condoms in that order haha. I think i was 17 when we bought that.
The first toy I bought was a black and white, cheetah print vibrator. It was alright. I ended up having to replace it within a year. I still buy vibrators like it, simply because of strong the first one was.
"Jumbo LifeSaver". It's a big traditional vibe I bought it on here for, like, $6, and it has a vinyl a case that looks like a LifeSavers wrapper (it's discontinued as of a month or so ago). And it's still one of my favorites. Woot!