I cheated - I found mine at a dating site. A vanilla dating site, but when he has a screen name of 'knotty_or_nice' ... yeah.
There are different grades of male Dom, so there aren't any set 'traits' to be able to look for. Outwardly my Master is polite, inconspicuous, gentlemanly, quiet, serene ... what everyone associates with the boring and vanilla 'Nice Guy'. By ourselves he's intense, demanding, and firm.
I guess if I had to pick through a line up, it'd be the quiet introvert with a gleam in his eye. There's a reason the cliche of "It's always the quiet ones ... " exists.