Winter wonder lip gloss trio Winter wonder lip gloss trio by Cake Beauty
Purchase details
Winter wonder lip gloss trio

Lip gloss by Cake Beauty

Our Price:$24.99
In stock

 
 
( 128 users added this item )
 
 
Product info

Add resource

Kissing in a Winter Wonderland??

If you love a natural vanilla scent and don't mind lip gloss that is sticky and thick and may take an hour or so to really soak into your lips, this is a great product for you. It is also nicely packaged if you wish to give it as a gift.

However, if you prefer a lip gloss that glides on or want "kissable lips" that don't stick to your partner when they try to walk away, I'd suggest you look elsewhere.

This is a great product, just not sure it is a great value.
Published: December 14, 2011
Pros:
Great Vanilla Scent
Wonderfully Boxed for a Gift Set
Cons:
Very Sticky and Thick
Rating by reviewer:
3
extremely useful review

Use

Cake Beauty has come out with a thick, sensuous nearly-nude line of lip glosses that add shimmer and sparkle to your lips. With the glitter and shine in these glosses, I recommend them more for evening use than daywear.

The set is made up of three glosses: Vanilla Frost, Pink Icicle and Gold Glimmer.

Vanilla frosted is creamy pearl with an "opalescent shine". I find it to be a very pale pink which mainly gives the lips some sparkle and glimmer without much color.

Pink Icicle is supposed to be sheer pink with a diamond sparkle. As others have noted, it is more of a bubblegum pink color.

The final shade is the Gold Glimmer. This one is supposed to be nude with a golden sheen.

I tried to put these on my arm to show you the colors but that did not work because they were too light. So instead, I put them on a white sheet of paper.



I was also able to get my daughter to model one for you.

Here she is without the lip gloss:


With the lip gloss on:
    • Bridal gift
    • Mood enhancer

Texture / Consistency / Thickness / Viscosity

This lip gloss is VERY thick and very sticky. When I was kid, I'd play with a tiny dot of paste between my thumb and my forefinger to see how sticky it would be and watch it form little threads back and forth.

This lip gloss is not quite that thick but close. I find that it is also very shiny and very pretty once it is put on.

I wanted to find a way to compare it to others so I picked up some lip gloss at the local dollar store. I found that the New York Color brand went on very easily and smoothly. The L.A. Colors was a bit more stiff but still nowhere near as thick as the Cake lip glosses are.
    • Sticky
    • Thick

Taste / Aroma

My husband loved the taste when he kissed me. He said that it reminded him of vanilla sugar cookies which was what it reminded me of also. I know others have compared it to vanilla cake mix, but for me it has a sweeter smell and taste than that. However, while my husband was willing to kiss me once with it on,he preferred kissing me without it more. He said that it felt very thick and sticky and he preferred my lips to be more natural.

When I asked my daughter to model more colors later on, she was ok with doing so but really wasn't excited about it. It felt sticky to her also for an hour or so after she'd tried the first one.
    • Strong smell

Performance

I know that I've talked a lot about how thick and sticky this product is and I don't want to give you the idea that it is bad. I found it to be very long-lasting and it did not have to be reapplied for a long time. Once it absorbed into my lips, it did so very nicely and made my lips soft.

I think if I wanted to wear this to have "kissable" lips when my husband was coming home from work, I would apply it an hour or so before he came home so that the stickiness would go away and my lips would be soft.
    • Absorbs into skin nicely
    • Gets sticky
    • Long lasting

Packaging

Cake did an excellent job packaging these lip glosses for those who want to give them as a gift. Let me share some pictures with you. You can even use the label on the back of the box to share who the gift is for and who it is from.

The front:


The back:


The insert that holds the lip glosses VERY securely:
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y139/PegFlint/Eden%20Fantasys%20Dec%202011/IMG_0622.jpg
    • Would make a nice gift

Special Features

I would like to add that the lip glosses are paraben free and do not contain Triclosan.

Personal comments

There are some things that I want to point out before I get to the end of this review.

First of all, I have no doubt that Cake Products make high quality items. I must admit that the vanilla smell of this lip gloss has no chemical aftertaste and is very pleasant. In addition, the packaging is very professionally done and would be a pleasant surprise in anyone's stocking or under a tree.

But while I like quality in my life, I often have to also consider value or the "cost per use" of an item. Therefore, it bothers me that I have 3 tubes that are .37 fluid ounces each for $24.99 when I can buy a .32 fluid ounce tube at the dollar store for $2. To be honest with you, I even preferred the smell of the NYC color lip gloss (.24 fluid ounces) over the Cake's vanilla scent - and vanilla is one of my favorite scents!

So I feel myself really torn over how to rate this - because I know so many times we may buy products based on a number of 5 star reviews.
This product was provided free of charge to the reviewer. This review is in compliance with the FTC guidelines.
Become a Reviewer. Get free toys. Enjoy Special Deals
About author
Reviewed by Hot 'N Sexy TexasMama (Eden Writer) Never too old to learn or play with my hubby
Rank
 
8.5
wrote 161 reviews
Do you like this review?
Comments
Owl Identified (verified)

Really nice review. I appreciate your honesty and the time that went into this. I suspect that I may end up having to try these for myself, even if I don't like them...I'm just too curious!

12/14/2011
The Curious Couple (verified)

Great review, thanks for sharing!

12/14/2011
Kira (stainedclear) (verified)

Great review. I just adore these glosses. I'm sorry you don't like them! I don't find them to be sticky at all, but I have a lot of super sticky lip glosses at home. LOL

12/14/2011
Pink Jewel (verified)

Thanks for the great review and pictures.

12/15/2011

Owl - they are nice quality and you might like them. I certainly don't regret that I received them to review as my free assignment.

StainedClear - I do really prefer slick glosses that aren't sticky so these just feel really thick to me. They are very pretty as far as not giving "too much" color but just enough and adding shine. I'm glad you adore them.

Everyone else - thanks for the comments. I'm glad that I was able to share a slightly different perspective than others.

The thing is - I probably wouldn't hesitate to spend the money on them as a gift for someone else. But for me - for everyday use - I'm too frugal and "cheap" when it comes to makeup, etc. I'm not a high quality gal - I appreciate it - but it isn't one of those things where I HAVE to have a high quality brand.

12/15/2011
sweetiejo (verified)

I got the vanilla one in a gift set (a review i did) i found the lipgloss super sticky to. I did the ice cube over it after putting it on and it seemed to help alot with the overall stickiness of it. I'm personally a thin shiny kind lip gloss gal. Awsoe review though gld i wasn't the only one who found them sticky.

12/15/2011
unfulfilled (verified)

vanilla sugar cookies yum, my hubby would like that. I'm not much of a makeup girl at all and when I do wear a little, I don't want anything that's sticky. Thanks for the awesome review.

12/15/2011
mom&wife08 (verified)

cute set!

12/16/2011
darkkitty (verified)

very nice review!

12/20/2011
angel142stx (verified)

Thanks for the review

Jan 7, 3:27 am
chantal coopette (verified)

thanks!

Jan 12, 8:55 am
Apirka (verified)

Thank you for your honest review!

Jan 12, 1:07 pm
Forever17 (verified)

thanks

Jan 13, 6:41 pm
lalapetitee (verified)

Great review!

Jan 16, 8:21 pm
Willow Wand (verified)

Great review! Thanks for the pics!

Feb 11, 4:38 pm
TransMarc (verified)

Ugh, sticky gloss :/ You can find 1 to 5€ glosses that aren't sticky where I live :/ Nice review, though.

Apr 6, 12:19 am
Miss Me? (verified)

Apr 11, 7:53 am
dragonn (verified)

Great review, I'll definitely consider this set.

Apr 13, 2:43 pm
Forum
  • Other flavors?
    • Will they be making other flavors?
    1 posts Read all
  • sticky or slick?
    • Has anyone tried these? Are they sticky?
    • I ordered the other kit with a lip gloss in it. Should be here Thursday if the mail runs that day or Friday if not. Ask me then and I'll let you know!
    • Quote: I ordered the other kit with a lip gloss in it. Should be here Thursday if the mail runs that day or Friday if not. Ask me then and I'll let you know!
      Have you tried these yet?
    12 posts Read all
Thank you for viewing Winter wonder lip gloss trio review page!