Beginner plug vs. next one up...

captainsgirl captainsgirl 03/03/2013

Ok, I tried my first butt plug. (I have only ever done anal once and it was well over ten years ago and I was drunk :/ ) so anyways, I tried the Mood Naughty Medium Silicone Plug.. It went perfect with no troubles. So my question is which plug do you recommend as my next step?

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
captainsgirl captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
ShadowedSeductress , ashboo32 , padmeamidala , PropertyOfPotter , higs , hotinpink , married with children , Bignuf , chicmichiw , MrWill , Lioncub , Gdom , rihanne , deltalima , solly , noway , SilverMinxxx , Gone (LD29) , BlooJay , GONE! , GirlOnGirl , SecretKinksters , amazon , mpfm , BrittaniMaree , hhh , Hummingbird , srexom , mdnght , LavenderSkies , sillylilkitten , mlmac , Real or memorex , comatose-kitty , bog , ChubbyNerd , iabicpl09 , Master DarkWolf , DreamWolf , karenm , eri86 , Genderfree , damnbul12
43  (80%)
kinksters
1  (2%)
Bill220 , Incendiaire
2  (4%)
evie.amor , spiced , SMichelle , Two Grand , 783883877299373783 , Rossie , ginnyluvspotter , roskat
8  (15%)
Total votes: 54
Poll is open
03/03/2013
  • It's Better Than Real! Buy 1 Dildo Or Anal Toy And Get 1 FRE
  • Try a luxury harness with a dildo and save 45% on a kit!
  • Better Price - Save 40%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
kinksters kinksters
bubble butt is a good stretcher. if you're wanting to hold it for a bit, the gumdrop is a good choice too.

good luck!!
03/03/2013
ShadowedSeductress ShadowedSeductress
I personally would not go with anything that isn't silicone, glass, or stainless steel because you just can't sanitize them. I would think using a condom with a plug would surely put a damper on your fun!

Since you have tried silicone and seem to like the medium mood plug I'd go with the large as your next step. Just be sure to use the medium first as a warm up!
03/03/2013
ashboo32 ashboo32
mood naughty of those choices
03/03/2013
padmeamidala padmeamidala
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
mood naughty large plug
03/03/2013
higs higs
If you liked your Medium, move on up to the large
03/03/2013
hotinpink hotinpink
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
Mood Large
03/03/2013
evie.amor evie.amor
I too am a complete anal beginner and recently purchased my first plugs. I got the Plug of Lust small and the Mood Naughty medium. I really like the shape of the plug of lust and I think I will be getting the Plug of Lust large. I had no troubles getting the Mood Naughty in, but once in I kind of felt ho-hum about the shape. It's a great place to start but I won't be buying the large. My next purchase will be the Tantus Ryder or the Plug of Lust Large.

Good luck fellow beginner!
03/03/2013
captainsgirl captainsgirl
Quote:
Originally posted by evie.amor
I too am a complete anal beginner and recently purchased my first plugs. I got the Plug of Lust small and the Mood Naughty medium. I really like the shape of the plug of lust and I think I will be getting the Plug of Lust large. I had no troubles ... More
thanks..illl check those out
03/03/2013
MrWill MrWill
I would caution you not to even consider the Classic butt plug royal... It is LARGE. 2 and a half inches.. I consider myself to be pretty experienced with large toys and I can't get past 2 3/8s yet...
03/03/2013
spiced spiced
Of the ones on your list, the best choice would the the Mood Naughty large. I agree about sticking with non-porous materials (silicone, glass, metal).

You didn't say how you'd be using the plug, which makes a difference. I like tapered glass plugs (like the Moon Shine) as a warm-up for anal, and more rounded silicone plugs (like the Tantus Ryder) to wear during sex or solo play, or for extended wear.

If you're interested in the Ryder, but it's a little too big (1 1/2" diameter), the Joe Rock is a very similar design, with the same diameter as the Mood Naughty large (1 1/4").
03/03/2013
Gdom Gdom
The Mood Naughty Large seems like a logical next step
03/03/2013
captainsgirl captainsgirl
Quote:
Originally posted by spiced
Of the ones on your list, the best choice would the the Mood Naughty large. I agree about sticking with non-porous materials (silicone, glass, metal).

You didn't say how you'd be using the plug, which makes a difference. I like ... More
I'm new to plugs altoghter. I would like to use it for stretching and during intercourse. What can you tell me about probes and is glass or steel actually comfortable since they have no give?
03/03/2013
solly solly
With butt plugs, as long as you know you want to keep the toy and use it for a while I would definitely go with glass or silicone just so you know it will last. Any other materials can harbor bacteria and have the potential to cause infections or break down over time (not to mention they can't be fully sterilized).
03/03/2013
SilverMinxxx SilverMinxxx
I would say the Mood Naughty large. I would also stick with silicone.
03/04/2013
Gone (LD29) Gone (LD29)
I'd go with the Mood Naughty large.

I'll warn you from experience with another toy in the line, that Gumdrops butt plug is a *lot* larger than you probably think it is.
03/04/2013
BlooJay BlooJay
Mood naughty large
03/04/2013
GirlOnGirl GirlOnGirl
Mood naughty large plug
03/04/2013
SecretKinksters SecretKinksters
Mood Naughty Large...or any other SILICONE plug, we love Tantus toys for our anal play.
03/04/2013
amazon amazon
Mood naughty should be good
03/04/2013
Bill220 Bill220
I voted for the Classic Butt Plug Royal for one reason. It's nicely tapered, which means that you can slowly work your way up to being able to take the entire toy. I have one of these and was able to fully insert it within a month but I use plugs almost daily so your experience with it may vary.

If you buy the Mood Naughty Large, I'll bet you'll be looking for something bigger in a very short time.

The Gumdrop looks interesting but I've read that the neck of the toy isn't long enough and it tends to pop out.

The Bubble Butt is really short. At only 2 3/4" insertable length, I bet it would pop out easily.
03/04/2013
Hummingbird Hummingbird
I would stick with the Mood Naughty Large, a product line you're already familiar with. I've got the Gumdrop in grey and am still trying to figure out how to insert it past the last width before the flange.
03/04/2013
evie.amor evie.amor
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
I'm new to plugs altoghter. I would like to use it for stretching and during intercourse. What can you tell me about probes and is glass or steel actually comfortable since they have no give?
I just got the Pure Plug Medium on sale a couple week ago and tried it for the first time the other day. It was surprisingly comfortable and easy to insert after only warming up with the Mood Naughty Medium for a couple minutes.
03/04/2013
spiced spiced
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
I'm new to plugs altoghter. I would like to use it for stretching and during intercourse. What can you tell me about probes and is glass or steel actually comfortable since they have no give?
I haven't tried steel yet, but I find some glass pieces comfortable enough to wear for the duration of a sex or solo session (15 minutes or so). I've used the Moon Shine plug for that and it worked pretty well - but I have had it come out when I didn't want it to, which is majorly annoying and mood-breaking. If you guys have 'marathon' sex sessions, you'd probably be better off with something silicone like the Joe Rock or Ryder.

I usually prefer glass for warm-up/stretching. It's so incredibly smooth that it's easier to insert. I used to like my Cobalt Bubble plug (now discontinued) for this; I found I like the Moon Shine even better.

Lately, though, I've just been using my silicone Tantus Ryder. It's about as smooth as silicone gets, I can get it in without any other warmup, it's comfortable for a long time (I've worn it for almost 2 hours, and plan to try it for longer soon) and it stays in really well. It's big enough that it works to prepare me for pegging with either the Vixskin Mustang (1 1/2" diameter) or Vixskin Johnny (1 3/4" diameter). If you're looking for "one plug to rule them all", the Ryder might be a good choice. The only concern is that it's a pretty big step up from the Mood Naughty Medium.
03/04/2013
srexom srexom
Mood naughty large plug
03/04/2013
mdnght mdnght
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
The mood naughty large! I have the medium as well, and I think the large's a great step up in size, and it's a great material for a good price too
03/04/2013
Incendiaire Incendiaire
I always suggest going for something a little bigger and working your way up to it.
03/04/2013
mlmac mlmac
Well if the Mood naughty medium plug worked as well as you said, then the only clear choice for your next step should be the Mood Naughty large.
03/04/2013
783883877299373783 783883877299373783
njoy small.
03/04/2013
Real or memorex Real or memorex
If you liked the medium, the large seems like a logical next step.
03/04/2013
comatose-kitty comatose-kitty
The mood plug
03/04/2013
bog bog
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
I have a black Mood Naughty large and it is FANTASTIC! Check out my review. I couldn't recommend it highly enough!
03/04/2013
Rossie Rossie
Your next plug should be a Njoy Pure plug.
03/04/2013
iabicpl09 iabicpl09
Mood naughty large plug
03/05/2013
Master DarkWolf Master DarkWolf
First one.
03/07/2013
DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by Master DarkWolf
First one.
Yep...
03/07/2013
roskat roskat
Maybe you could look at some glass options next.
03/11/2013
damnbul12 damnbul12
Quote:
Originally posted by captainsgirl
i have only used the mood naughty medium plug. which do you recommend next?
Mood naughty large plug
03/11/2013
Total posts: 38
Unique posters: 34